4 Bros Pizza

Excellent pizza excellent customer service, Would highly recommend to anybody.

Very good plain slice. Noticeable larger than your standard slice. Price to quality ratio is incredible. Crust is crispy on the outside with just the right amount of char. At the same time it’s fluffy and moist in the inside and not at all brittle. I think there’s a little rye in the dough but not so much that it makes the whole thing sour like these Neapolitan style pizzas out there. The cheese and sauce have that milky-mozzy salty sweetness and golden oil that make it impossible to stop driving each bite into your face one after the other grasping for air in between bites. Truly a perfect NY slice. Garlic knots were juicy and properly seasoned, fluffy and moist in the inside like the pizza crust. Unpretentious marinara sauce to go along with it. Zeppoles came out sitting on a mountain of powdered sugar. Looked like I was about to chow down on Scarface’s nuts. Totally unnecessary and most of the sugar got thrown out but it was the kind of loving gesture that makes you feel like you’re grandmother/Nonna is serving you. Kind, professional, & attentive staff.

Drove down to new Rochelle to try Shirley’s India and didn’t realize there would be a long wait. We were starving so while we waited we saw a pizzeria on the corner and went in for a slice, best decision of the night! I got the 4 cheese and fig slice, my husband got a New York slice, the crust was extremely thin, yet crispy and flavorful. Blown away by how good the pizza was, even got talking to the owner and his wife and it’s clear the passion they have for what they do. Owner even gave us a bonus grandma slice and it was BANGING! Will definitely go out of my way for this place!

Having moved from NYC to New Rochelle recently, I was not expecting to find this gem. Exceptional pizza - they do the perfect crust and right amount of sauce.

4 Bros Pizza serves up classic NY slices with quality ingredients and a simple menu. Expect thin, crispy crusts, fresh toppings, and fast service. Perfect for a quick, affordable bite in New Rochelle.

I had the urge to eat garlic knots. So I went to 4 Bros Pizza to try them out. And let me tell you, they were delicious 😋. They were so savory & fresh! I highly recommend them at this place. I’ve also tried their pizza. And it’s also tasty!!! Stop by and try them out!!!

Ordered delivery. Will stop in soon. Pizza was above average. Would recommend well done. Zeppoles though we're phenom. Beyond generous with the powdered sugar. Double bagged so I don't get a stain on my lap. Good portion. Really relieved to find a good pizza place in town.

Absolutely exceptional. Hands down the best pizza in new ro and the only place we will order from. The pizza has true NY style taste. My mom grew up in brooklyn and visited, she was blown away by this pizza! The vodka chicken parm sandwich is a MUST try. These guys are legit!!!!!!!

Thanks to my new friends at 4 Bros. Pizza for an amazingly good pizza. Will, Carlos, and Bryan are awesome. I didn’t get to meet Danny (the 4th brother). When you have the opportunity, stop and get a pizza here. Your tastebuds will thank you. #4brospizza

+2

Stop by to buy a vegan cheese pizza pie for the wife. Pizza was great. Good tasting vegan pizza. Will come back again to try there other specialty vegan pies they have.

Appreciated 4Bros for serving Club West. I'm very picky with it comes to pizza and I have to say this was a pretty good pizza. Thank you

SO good! Everything from here has been incredible. Recently they had a vodka parm slider special and they were some of the best tasting things I’ve ever had. Also the caramalized Bianco pizza is to die for!!

The vibes are perfect off the rip. Good music and good vibes. They have options for both me and my mom. She’s vegan. I’ll definitely recommend!!

I hope this review encourages you to come here. I ordered two slices; a plain and an upside down pepperoni slice. I can honestly say this was some of the best pizza, if not THE best pizza I have ever had. The slices were crispy and had no flop. The sauce had a perfect balance of sweetness and tanginess and the hibiscus tea was perfect. To top it off they gave me a free house made chocolate chip cookie. I can honestly say this pizzeria is worth going out of your way to drive to and I will definitely be back for more.

Great pizza and amazing service! Definitely recommend, and would come back!

I had an event catered by 4Bros, Carlos was a pleasure to work with, delivery was on time and food was great!

Ordered pickup a few times and the food is always ready on time when they say it will! The FIG & 3 CHEESE PIZZA is amazing omg and surprisingly sweet. The goat cheese is great. The regular slice is perfect too. My dogs LOVE pizza and whine everytime we have pizza at home so I attached their photos too lol. The fig pizza is a staple. Perfect portions.

Really delicious slice. Crispy crust. Doesn't flop. Has the golden delicious NY oil a pizza should have. Really good crust. Did I say that already about the crust? Sauce is good not to sweet, cheese is just the right amount. The staff are friendly and attentive. Highly recommend if you are in New Rochelle

Saw that 4 Bros had a collab with my other favorite restaurant - Shirley’s India - so I had to try. Got their limited special “Chicken Tikka Fried Onion Pizza” and an order of their wings with Garlic Parm rub. The pizza crust is just the way I like it - thin, crispy and chewy. Of course what I ordered is not a typical topping but it was amazing. Shirley’s makes some of the best Indian food in Westchester. Combine that with a solid pizza from 4 Bros and that’s magic. The wings were huge and plump. The Garlic Parm was a dry rub and had a nice dark, roasted garlic flavor. Definitely will return to try some more of their other specialties.

Still the BEST pizza in Westchester, fight me! Check out there new weekly deals! Mondays 30% off all pies no exclusions, Wednesdays 30% off all Sandwiches, Thuradays 30% off all Wings! TVs playing sports and music playing in the background makes for a great vibe to. To top it off they serve the best breakfast in New Rochelle hands down! They serve traditional breakfast good but YOU GOTTA TRY THE BREAKFAST PIZZA! You will thank me when you do 💯

I recently had the pleasure of trying the incredible sliders from the collaboration between 4 Bros Pizza and Duke's Ramen, and I couldn't be more impressed! This unique fusion combines the best of both culinary worlds, creating a delicious and unforgettable dining experience. The sliders perfectly showcase the creativity and skill of both establishments. The flavors are remarkably balanced, with the savory elements from Duke's Ramen perfectly complementing the rich, hearty taste of 4 Bros Pizza's ingredients. Each bite was a delightful blend of textures and tastes, leaving me wanting more. If you haven't tried the sliders from this fantastic collaboration, do yourself a favor and head over to 4 Bros Pizza. This is a match made in foodie heaven that you won't want to miss!

If you’re looking for a personal touch on a traditional pizzeria, this is the spot. The bros are great at what they do. Everything is hand made, and the service is exceptional. My personal favorite tho….. the 4 bros classic sammich. 🤌🏼

Topazio R

Ordered pickup a few times and the food is always ready on time when they say it will! The FIG & 3 CHEESE PIZZA is amazing omg and surprisingly sweet. The goat cheese is great. The regular slice is perfect too. My dogs LOVE pizza and whine everytime we have pizza at home so I attached their photos too lol. The fig pizza is a staple. Perfect portions.

bizzy izzy

Really delicious slice. Crispy crust. Doesn't flop. Has the golden delicious NY oil a pizza should have. Really good crust. Did I say that already about the crust? Sauce is good not to sweet, cheese is just the right amount. The staff are friendly and attentive. Highly recommend if you are in New Rochelle

Jin

Saw that 4 Bros had a collab with my other favorite restaurant - Shirley’s India - so I had to try. Got their limited special “Chicken Tikka Fried Onion Pizza” and an order of their wings with Garlic Parm rub. The pizza crust is just the way I like it - thin, crispy and chewy. Of course what I ordered is not a typical topping but it was amazing. Shirley’s makes some of the best Indian food in Westchester. Combine that with a solid pizza from 4 Bros and that’s magic. The wings were huge and plump. The Garlic Parm was a dry rub and had a nice dark, roasted garlic flavor. Definitely will return to try some more of their other specialties.

Carlos Terrones

Still the BEST pizza in Westchester, fight me! Check out there new weekly deals! Mondays 30% off all pies no exclusions, Wednesdays 30% off all Sandwiches, Thuradays 30% off all Wings! TVs playing sports and music playing in the background makes for a great vibe to. To top it off they serve the best breakfast in New Rochelle hands down! They serve traditional breakfast good but YOU GOTTA TRY THE BREAKFAST PIZZA! You will thank me when you do 💯

The Gentleman's Lab

I recently had the pleasure of trying the incredible sliders from the collaboration between 4 Bros Pizza and Duke's Ramen, and I couldn't be more impressed! This unique fusion combines the best of both culinary worlds, creating a delicious and unforgettable dining experience. The sliders perfectly showcase the creativity and skill of both establishments. The flavors are remarkably balanced, with the savory elements from Duke's Ramen perfectly complementing the rich, hearty taste of 4 Bros Pizza's ingredients. Each bite was a delightful blend of textures and tastes, leaving me wanting more. If you haven't tried the sliders from this fantastic collaboration, do yourself a favor and head over to 4 Bros Pizza. This is a match made in foodie heaven that you won't want to miss!

Brian Matthews

If you’re looking for a personal touch on a traditional pizzeria, this is the spot. The bros are great at what they do. Everything is hand made, and the service is exceptional. My personal favorite tho….. the 4 bros classic sammich. 🤌🏼

Jamey Parker

Thanks to my new friends at 4 Bros. Pizza for an amazingly good pizza. Will, Carlos, and Bryan are awesome. I didn’t get to meet Danny (the 4th brother). When you have the opportunity, stop and get a pizza here. Your tastebuds will thank you. #4brospizza

Edgar Gonzalez

Stop by to buy a vegan cheese pizza pie for the wife. Pizza was great. Good tasting vegan pizza. Will come back again to try there other specialty vegan pies they have.

Really good pizza with fast, reliable delivery for the Club West girls event. Everything arrived hot and fresh, and the flavors were spot on. You can tell they take pride in their quality. Definitely adding this place to my regular rotation.

Highly recommend this place 10/10. Our guest loved the food when it came to catering. The customer service was great we had a last minute change to our order and they were so understanding. The staff were very helpful. Superbowl week the prices were great (definitely take advantage of the deals) :)

Really enjoyed their pizza they hosted for a Club West event! I love that their slices are smaller, so it feels more guilt free. LOL. The crust is thin. The sauce has a little sweetness to it, which I prefer in a pizza sauce. The pepperoni was bite size and not large slice that are sliding off the pizza. Can’t wait to go back and try more food! Special shoutout to Carlos for the delivery!!!

Thank you 4Bros and Carlos for the amazing service. The pizza was still warm when delivered and super tasty. The pepperoni was my favorite, nice and crispy. Club West appreciates the support!

I was at a party and the pizza was delivered. It was still hot and fresh. It was amazing. Crust was perfect, the sauce was really good, but the pepperoni was my favorite. 10/10 definitely recommend.

The pepperoni pizza was absolutely delicious. Delivery was fast, and the service was excellent. Carlos was very professional and generous in sponsoring Club West. Truly appreciate the support and great experience all around.

Found this little spot while visiting New Rochelle and we were very happy with everything. We were a total party of 12 & the staff were amazing in accommodating us. The prices were great, staff friendly, & the food was so good! The pizza, chicken cutlets and wings were delicious! Definitely will go back & highly recommend. This little spot is a definite gem!

Review for sandwiches only! I've never had the pizza here but this spot holds my favorite sandwich ever in New Rochelle (amongst lots of spots we've tried including delis and restaurants and grocery stores). The Classic 4 Bros sandwich is heavenly -magic combo, and we're regulars for it. Also, the bread is divine - house made. Yum.

I Decided to take the kids out for pizza today and went to another pizza place fortunately they were closed so we decided to go to 4bros because they were on our list to try as well. We are so happy we went here. The pizza was amazing! We ordered a pie to bring home. The pie never made it out the shop lol! The customer service was on point. We were greeted on our walk in and they made us feel so comfortable that we decided to sit and have a slice which eventually ended up with us finishing the pie lol. The kids then had ice cream which they took to eat in the car on our way home. This is my new favorite pizza shop! I will definitely be back.

4 Bros Pizza catered a Club West event I attended- the food & service was phenomenal! Pepperoni pizza was delicious! Highly recommend ordering from here!

I just came back from two weeks in Hawaii and my first stop after dropping off my stuff at home was 4 Brother's because I needed a REAL slice of pizza. My go-to for garlic knots and a hearty sicilian slice. Also really appreciate they have plant-based pizzas for the vegans in my life.

Julissa Santos

Really good pizza with fast, reliable delivery for the Club West girls event. Everything arrived hot and fresh, and the flavors were spot on. You can tell they take pride in their quality. Definitely adding this place to my regular rotation.

J Cosme

Thank you 4Bros and Carlos for the amazing service. The pizza was still warm when delivered and super tasty. The pepperoni was my favorite, nice and crispy. Club West appreciates the support!

Alicia Rosario

I was at a party and the pizza was delivered. It was still hot and fresh. It was amazing. Crust was perfect, the sauce was really good, but the pepperoni was my favorite. 10/10 definitely recommend.

Jay M.

Really enjoyed their pizza they hosted for a Club West event! I love that their slices are smaller, so it feels more guilt free. LOL. The crust is thin. The sauce has a little sweetness to it, which I prefer in a pizza sauce. The pepperoni was bite size and not large slice that are sliding off the pizza. Can’t wait to go back and try more food! Special shoutout to Carlos for the delivery!!!

Elorna Pierre

The pepperoni pizza was absolutely delicious. Delivery was fast, and the service was excellent. Carlos was very professional and generous in sponsoring Club West. Truly appreciate the support and great experience all around.

Vanessa Gomez

4 Bros Pizza catered a Club West event I attended- the food & service was phenomenal! Pepperoni pizza was delicious! Highly recommend ordering from here!

Oprah W

I Decided to take the kids out for pizza today and went to another pizza place fortunately they were closed so we decided to go to 4bros because they were on our list to try as well. We are so happy we went here. The pizza was amazing! We ordered a pie to bring home. The pie never made it out the shop lol! The customer service was on point. We were greeted on our walk in and they made us feel so comfortable that we decided to sit and have a slice which eventually ended up with us finishing the pie lol. The kids then had ice cream which they took to eat in the car on our way home. This is my new favorite pizza shop! I will definitely be back.

Margie Boitel

Found this little spot while visiting New Rochelle and we were very happy with everything. We were a total party of 12 & the staff were amazing in accommodating us. The prices were great, staff friendly, & the food was so good! The pizza, chicken cutlets and wings were delicious! Definitely will go back & highly recommend. This little spot is a definite gem!

Thanh

Review for sandwiches only! I've never had the pizza here but this spot holds my favorite sandwich ever in New Rochelle (amongst lots of spots we've tried including delis and restaurants and grocery stores). The Classic 4 Bros sandwich is heavenly -magic combo, and we're regulars for it. Also, the bread is divine - house made. Yum.

Kenji Kaneshiro

I just came back from two weeks in Hawaii and my first stop after dropping off my stuff at home was 4 Brother's because I needed a REAL slice of pizza. My go-to for garlic knots and a hearty sicilian slice. Also really appreciate they have plant-based pizzas for the vegans in my life.

Great customer service! Carlos took wonderful care of us at Club West! Thank you!

Specialty slices are good and probably the best deal of the local places. Regular pizza is very oily and usually reheated too long. Much better priced and fresher at a place a few blocks away on Main. They took away the soda w 2 slices deal. C town a few steps away has the same cans for $1.00. Prices increased. Quality went down. Music is way too loud but a good mix of Spanish, Hard Rock and Edm.

For my preferences, everything I’ve tried here has been average. Their best thing is probably their plain cheese slice. Do not recommend the chicken roll….just seems like a lot of cheese and a few pieces of chopped up chicken cutlets.

Per Google and the sign on the door they don’t open until 3PM Sunday. I called at 3PM and was told to call back in 15-20 minutes. I called back in about 20 minutes and my order for pick up was taken over the phone and my card charged since I was a “new customer.” I was told my order would be ready in about 15 minutes. I live very close so I walk over to pick up my order was surprised to see the door was locked and lights off. I called again and was told whoever took my order before forgot to mention that all employees went to an event and my order wouldn’t be ready until 5:30 (about an hour and half later). I opted for a refund, which I have yet to receive. I’ve had their pizza before and it was great but this was unacceptable.

Zaria Graham

Per Google and the sign on the door they don’t open until 3PM Sunday. I called at 3PM and was told to call back in 15-20 minutes. I called back in about 20 minutes and my order for pick up was taken over the phone and my card charged since I was a “new customer.” I was told my order would be ready in about 15 minutes. I live very close so I walk over to pick up my order was surprised to see the door was locked and lights off. I called again and was told whoever took my order before forgot to mention that all employees went to an event and my order wouldn’t be ready until 5:30 (about an hour and half later). I opted for a refund, which I have yet to receive. I’ve had their pizza before and it was great but this was unacceptable.

Not sure what the guys name is at the counter that day but the customer service was bad. He seemed annoyed that I was there as soon as I walked in and asked to see a menu. It’s like they don’t really acknowledge you and greet you as a business that wants your business, more like they’re doing you a favor is what it felt like. The pizza was pretty good although slices were small, but I guess that’s their style. Really just annoyed by businesses with employees that seem like they are miserable and end up misrepresenting the business.

Went into Pizza shop. Was not welcomed in, first red flag. Moved past being ignored by the singular person working. Went on to get a beverage from the refrigerator and waited to be greeted, was not. Asked to buy the drink because I wasn’t going to order food. Guy came to the register, asked “cash or card” I said “card” he put the price up for the drink and walked away before I could even pay. Pretty rude, yes I know. On top of the fact that I could’ve stolen the drink, thankfully I’m not that type of person. So I told him, I’ll pass on the purchase returned the drink to the refrigerator and left. I don’t know if he is the owner but if he is, this type of service is pretty awful. If he’s not the owner, I hope the owner holds him accountable. This type of service isn’t really acceptable. I’m not sure if you have cameras in the restaurant but if you do I hope you review this because, what the actual heck? I’m so annoyed with myself because the one time I don’t wear my Mets glasses I get treated like dirt on the street.

This place is absolutely filthy. I saw a roach crawling on the counter as soon as I walked in. Staff were handling money and then flipping pizzas back to back without washing their hands. Completely unsanitary. The owner and staff also have a disgraceful attitude—while I was there, they kicked out a woman and her child who were simply trying to pick up their order because she had a service animal. Truly a dirty and unprofessional establishment. I would not recommend this place to anyone.

Kendall Herman

This place is absolutely filthy. I saw a roach crawling on the counter as soon as I walked in. Staff were handling money and then flipping pizzas back to back without washing their hands. Completely unsanitary. The owner and staff also have a disgraceful attitude—while I was there, they kicked out a woman and her child who were simply trying to pick up their order because she had a service animal. Truly a dirty and unprofessional establishment. I would not recommend this place to anyone.