Firestrike

Yum! A great spot for comfort food and drinks that's open pretty late! The atmosphere is cozy and has pretty lighting, and there's both a bar and separate tables. The kitchen seems like it closes at 12am, so do keep that in mind (the bar is open quite a bit later). I got the sausage with mashed potatoes and gravy and it was delicious! The gravy was rich and flavorful, the sausage springy and juicy, and the mash teetered on the perfect balance between creamy and fluffy. Loved the onions on top too! Everything together made for some wonderful bites. A comforting and hearty meal for sure. I didn’t order any drinks this time but I would imagine that a tall glass of beer would've completed the experience. Maybe next time! Update: I came back and tried the fish and chips with a couple of beers. Also really good! The batter was crispy and the fish was tender and juicy. The tartar sauce was delicious, sweet and tangy, although I do wish it came with some more. The guiness beers had the perfect layer of foam on top of them too!

David S

Holy "Hole in the Wall" Batman! Molly's is a cozy little pub offering drinks and food with an old worn out wooden bar top and booths carved into a small opening on 3rd Avenue. Serving up classic Guinness stout's there's just something about enjoying a Guinness so much more in an authentic Irish setting like Molly's! The food was just as authentic, our burger and special beef brisket sandwich with onions were both served up meeting high marks in all categories. The burger was cooked as ordered, filled the toasted bun with a thick, juicy, flavorful, nice cut of meat, lettuce onion and tomato, too. The special brisket sandwich, also nice and tender, juicy, in a tasty gravy smothered in onions and piled on a toasted ciabatta bread, so delish! The onion rings cooked perfect and the accompanying curry sauce was a pleasant surprise to dip French fries into! Give Molly's credit for taking a basic dish and making it correctly in their own way, so you can enjoy right to the last bite. The lady serving(Aisling)was quite a marvel, she clearly knew what she was doing, serving up drinks at the bar and waiting tables too...only few in this business could do so smoothly and efficiently like her, almost without effort( others should watch and learn). You'll love the warm cozy atmosphere this place radiates! Erin go bragh!

+4

Charles B

Shepherds (Cottage) pie was awesome! Meatloaf special was amazing. Very large portions, though. Get there early, if you want a table. Love that the staff all sounded like they were actually Irish... :) All in all, it is an amazing place with an amazing staff.

+5

Thomas

Very cozy place . Staff was very friendly and attentive . Had the burger with onion , sautéed mushrooms . The add on’s were soo good . The burger was very simple otherwise . Felt like there could have been more fat to give it more flavor . Deff have had a better burger in my life before . But truly I enjoyed the simplicity of it . I would happily come back . It really is a very comfortable atmosphere .

+3

ReedH

The perfect spot to celebrate St. Patrick’s Day, this place has got so much historic character! We were lucky to snag a table and were well attended to by a lovely server who managed incredibly well on such a busy day. We had a really nice corned beef sandwich with nice crispy fries which was washed down by a perfect pint of Guinness. I look forward to trying again on a slightly less crowded day.

Charlie O'Neill

Excellent establishment. Guinness was perfectly poured. The food was authentic Irish American pub food and some of the best you will ever have. The chicken curry over rice and fries was solid but the Shepard’s Pie stole the show. The staff was friendly. Music was nice. Will be going back soon

Jennifer Winthurst

Loved this place! A very chill place. We didn't eat just had some drinks outside. Kevin was our waiter and he was super friendly and accommodating. Loved the dimness of the bar. It had a very Irish feel. I would definitely be back. They have Michelob Ultra in bottles

+4

S S

Stopped in here for brunch as we gave up looking for places that didnt have ques out the door ( we visited on a busy period) food was fresh and homemade with good portion sizes but pretty average taste wise. Service was slow to get food and to get the bill but there was only one waitress working and it was busy so im guessing she could of used some help. I liked how it was decorated with all the lights inside it made it feel festive and cosy.

Mike D

Classic Irish pub with a great menu. Had the wings and fish and chips. For the wings, received 9 drums and 1 flat. Disappointing but the drums were pretty 7.4 The fish was very moist and tend and the batter was crunchy. The tartar sauce was quit nenmmmmmmm

David Chin

A true gem and a delightful throwback to a bygone era! The moment you step inside, you’re instantly enveloped by the charm and rich history of this wonderful establishment. While I came for the lfish and chips, I found myself completely captivated by the incredible atmosphere. The nostalgic 70's and 80's tracks set the perfect vibe, making the experience feel both cozy and lively. The fish and chips were very good—crispy, golden, and perfectly cooked, just as you’d hope for. I also had the pleasure of trying the corned beef sandwich, which, while slightly drier than I anticipated, was still flavorful and satisfying. The real star of the meal, however, was the introduction to the English mustard—its bold, tangy kick elevated every bite and left me wanting more. This place is a must-visit for anyone seeking a memorable dining experience filled with great food, fantastic music, and a warm, welcoming ambiance. I can’t wait to return and explore more of the menu!

+2

Ali Vidler

I live in the area and walk by all the time but never took a moment to stop in mostly because I could never see inside without stopping to look through a little creepy window. I met my friends here for dinner and a drink and it was very cute. They had lights everyone for the holidays I suppose and the very authentic sawdust on the floor. We ordered a few drinks and mine were well mixed. I got virgin drinks but my friends ordered wine and other cocktails. We ordered food and I was pretty happy with mine. I ordered the chicken sandwich with fries and the only complain I have is that the chicken was a bit over cooked and tasted a bit rubbery in the sandwich. Other than that the flavor was good and so were the fries it ordered. I would come here but avoid the chicken. The staff was nice but messed up the order sometimes which I’m fine with. If you’re more picky then probably not your place.

+46

Noha

I first visited back in 1988 and used to stop by regularly for a pint or a meal over the years. On a recent visit to the city, my wife and I dropped in again. While the pub has a classic NYC Irish vibe, I was disappointed this time—service was slow, and the atmosphere felt a bit worn. We still hung out for a while and met some friendly people, but overall it didn’t live up to the memories. I’m not sure I’d rush back.