Cathy Lepore

Let me start by saying your pizza almost brought a tear to my husbands eye!! I promised Tyler I would write a review so here it is. Tyler was fantastic by the way. So very nice and so personable. (Let her know that we tried to find her at the Choir Concert, but didn't see her). So, my husband Jerry is originally from New Jersey. His family moved to Vegas where his Dad and Uncle opened up a Pizza joint called Angelina's. Anyway...life has brought us here to Oklahoma. We have tried so many pizzas from so many different pizza places. None of them have even come close to back East pizza, let alone his uncles pizza. Well, Uncle Vinny's is IT!! As soon as the pizza was brought to the table, we looked at each other and almost at the same time said, "This might be it". You could just tell by the thinness of the pizza and the way the crust looked that it was probably gonna be good. We ordered pepperoni, sausage, and breakfast bacon. It was SO GOOD!!! The sauce was fantastic, the cheese was just right, not too much, not too little. The toppings were on every piece. The whole time while we were eating, my husband was saying that eating that pizza was making him a little bit sad (not in a bad way). His dad and uncle have passed on. I just want to say thank you for giving him a little piece of home. Uncle Vinny's will now be our go to spot for pizza. We aren't close as we live in North Tulsa, but we will for sure make our way to you at least once a month. I only have one little dislike and it's not that big of a deal, but we did not like the ranch. We had the regular and the ghost pepper (Before you ask, no we did not use it for the pizza...it was for the cheesy knots). The ranch did taste like it was from a bottle, but since we were there for the pizza, the pizza is all that matters. Uncle Vinny's is the true NY Pizza. Again, thank you for restoring my husbands faith in pizza.

Andrea Toranzo

First time trying this place, and it was fantastic! The online ordering process was super easy, and my order was ready right on time. The pizza was delicious, with fresh, high-quality toppings. Honestly, it’s the best New York-style pizza I’ve had in BA! I usually stick to pizza at pizza places, but this one was so good it made me want to try more from their menu. We will be back!

Andrew Fowler

My family has been coming here for years! Big fans of the white pizza! They even made a pizza for us to bring home and bake in our oven since we live 3 hours away! You must give them a try.

devin shoemaker

I ordered 2 calzones this go around, and will definitely be ordering more! We like to try something different every time we come here and have not been disappointed yet!

Andrew Smoot

Absolutely amazing. The food is off the scale here. Wish I could give them more stars.

Natalie Harrison

The first time my boyfriend and I ate here, he told me he wanted to become a regular. All of the staff are so kind, and most of the time the family who owns Vinny's are there and happy to see you! We come here multiple times a month and they have our orders memorized at this point 😂 The food always comes out fast, hot out of the oven. They are VERY generous with their slice sizes (hand in pic for reference). Also the cheese knots are amazing, it comes with three but I couldn't wait to take the photo 😆 Definitely our favorite pizza joint, you should definitely give it a try! 🍕

Alexandra Finley

Love getting pizza by the slice! They are great size for the price! Been a repeat customer now for a lil over a year

Milla

Absolutely delicious! The Funky Chicken pizza, with added jalapeños on half, was packed with flavor and the crust was spot on—crispy yet perfectly chewy. The garlic knots were fluffy, buttery, and were overall just garlicky perfection. Service was outstanding; the staff went above and beyond and even accommodated our last-minute change from takeout to dine-in with a smile. A true hidden gem—we’ll definitely be back and recommend to everyone!

Charlie Bravo

Well I have to give it to the Google community on their reviews because they were spot on as usual. My wife and I would like to say thank you for making our anniversary special. That's what this place is. It's a special pizza place and when you walk in I felt like I was at home like since high school home and we're not even from Broken Arrow originally. Once you walk in that's where this place sets its impression the way how you're greeted what you immediately see on the ready line behind the counter will have your mouth salivating. For my wife and I we were hungry and we were ready to throw down. So we ordered a 14-in supreme Pizza lasagna and House tossed salad. Everything was so good. The lasagna the filling to us. The pizza was foldable like a New York slice had all fresh ingredients on top of it. It wasn't loaded with too much sauce. It was perfectly balanced and it came out piping hot which have my wife stunned because at other places you don't see smoke coming off of the pizza. And since my wife was reminding me the whole day or the entire day, she took it upon herself to tell the staff that it was our anniversary. So they treated us with a lovely dessert with filling inside. That was just awesome. It wasn't overpowered by Sweetness. It was balanced so well and soft and tender pretty much like our marriage. So when you're in the mood some traditional Italian food but don't want to go overboard and you want that nostalgic home feeling. This is the place where you need to come. Uncle Benny's New York pizzeria. How-yaaaa-dooooooooin.

+4

Sarah

Amazing all around, I knew the second I walked in and smelled the pizza it was going to be phenomenal. Crust is thin and perfectly crispy, the white pie was delicious, along with the garlic knots. Prices and food were way better than Empire Slice! I highly recommend stopping in!

Elizabeth Cather

Uncle Vinnys has the best pizza in Oklahoma. They are friendly and have the freshest ingredients I have ever had on a pizza. Their crust is to die for. The cheese cake and appetizers are all fantastic. If you want a great pie this is where you need to go

Good - **** I have been search of good NYC pizza in town. There is one in 47th and Harvard and Ive reviewed it before. Uncle Vinnys is something I found lately and found the menu as pretty decent. Ordered a cheese and a 3 topping(sausage,jalapeno,pineapple) pizza. Got it within 10 minutes. It is kinda similar to Andolinis. The flavor was good. Expected little bit more cheese on the cheese pizza but still its good.

Jeramie OK

Good local place. Very affordable, good pizza. Staff was fantastic. Very mom and pop feel. Definataley a local pizza place to check out. I'm not a huge fan of pizza but will be headed back to this one. The Buffalo and Bacon Chicken Ranch were great!