Pizza Amore

Crowned Alpha Barbershop

Great place to get some pizza!!! Went to this location for the first time after trying their pizza that they served off of their food truck! It was GREAT!! Plenty of parking right in front, super friendly staff, pizza made to order and out the door in less than 15 minutes. Everything was made exactly how I asked and I even tried their cannolis…. Very good by the way. Thanks guys I’ll be back for sure… keep up the good work in North Tonawanda.

Becky Phillips

We're visiting the area and needed lunch while we were doing some errands and sightseeing. We saw this place and whipped in. We ordered a large Godfather. We both got a coke and our total came to $32.40 plus tip. We sat outside on this beautiful day. We had plenty leftover for later. The pizza was delicious.

Kelli

So I recently started a job across the street and I didn’t feel like making dinner tonight just so happened I checked the reviews on Google and they weren’t great but I was feeling lazy wanted to try something new and didn’t want to cook boy am I glad I got pizza from Pizza amore Literally The best stinger pizza I’ve ever had in my life no joke I got pepperoni pizza for the kids it was also really good no complaints we will be ordering from here again for sure!!! The staff was amazing!!!

LJ Metzger

Amazing pizza and amazingly friendly tall blonde girl working here alone 2pm 11/29/23 She also recommended me the old world square slice as well as the 2 slices for lunch special with a soda. It was like $10.60 for 3 slices of fresh delicious pizza, great service, and an ice cold bottle of soda.

Lyudmila Panasyuk

Absolutely in love with their prosciutto pizza! It's to die for! I just wish they would have an outdoor seating. It would be perfect.

Abandoned ah.

Delicious!!! A+!

Great food , great service

Taste good I love it

First time ordering here last night. Tried the Rib Eye subs. Awesome! You folks nailed it!

Great pizza and many good things on the menu including Mac n cheese!

Ordered a LG cheese and pep with BBQ fingers everything was cooked and tasted perfext

Excellent food, staff is very nice and food is ready when it is supposed to be. Fair prices, quality ingredients.

Of all the pizza places in all the world, you guys walked into my life

Customer service from dj was great! The galbani pizza is awesome

You can get a delicious personal pizza in about 5 minutes on a walk-in!

Great wood fire oven pizza. Wings and buffalo favorites also.

Just left from lunch here, great pizza and a great experience 😁

Very good pizza, staff was extremely friendly

Great pizza. I will be returning in the future.

Expensive but completely worth it. Delicious food.

Had these guys at the fair, can’t stop thinking about them it’s that honey drizzle

Great pizza. Great crust

Wood fired pizza was very good!

Their pizza is delicious 🤤😋

My favorite pizzeria

Can order what you want

The best pizza around!

Great food great staff both locations are a must try and would say if you haven’t yet give them a taste. Cannoli pizza is very good!! Nashville pizza if you like heat. Honestly it’s all good

The chicken fingers were amazing, brick oven, fire burned pizzas are out of this world! My fiancé is obsessed with the gabagool! He has one at least 3-4 times a week! Honestly refuse to go anywhere else! Also the staff is beyond amazing, very friendly, and always going above and beyond!

10/10 Pizza is amazing!! The best in NT that I’ve had. You guys will definitely be my go to for pizza from now on. I work right across the street in the plaza and will recommend you guys to everybody! Keep doing what you’re doing!

Pizza was great but their steak sub was awesome made with real steak (not steak ums) if I remember right it was ribeye steak .if your looking for some great food you got to check pizza Amore out . Side note try their Mac and cheese too its awesome .

Family business. They are so friendly and caring. They also support teens working.

Such good pizza. I’ve ordered from this place few times and every time the pizza was delicious. Definitely worth the drive.

Love it here! Definitely the freshest ingredients of any pizza place around! Fast friendly and great selection! Much better than anywhere else around!

This is very good pizza, there is not a lot of good pizza in the area. It is a little bit pricey but the quality is excellent.

Great pizza! Great sauce, great cup and char pepperoni, awesome crust! Both the old world style and regular cheese and pepperoni were exceptional!

Delicious! We've ordered at our office twice and we all agreed this is really good pizza!

Ordered for the First time via Door Dash. Very good, definitely be back.

Amazing pizza!!! One of the top 2 pizza spots in WNY, other is Forno Napoli. Great job. True pizza artisans and masters.

Love this spot!! So good

Great pizza, perfect crust. The Dee's Hot Honey pizza is our favorite.

Ordered the BBQ chicken pizza and a pepperoni pizza. They were delicious! Will definitely be part of the NT pizza rotation.

Best wood fire pizza around my kids love this place more than I do

Best Pizza I've had in a long time... great customer service delicious ingredients.

Great pizza and antipasta salad

Awesome food (pizza, wings): fresh, hot, delicious Awesome service: friendly and accommodating, charged my cell phone while I ate

I don't even like pizza ... I love this place ❤️

Consistently excellent. The depth of flavor in the crust is stellar.

Had two pizzas today and they tasted amazing!! Only issue is that I have a weak stomach and am experiencing the consequences after eating the Smores pizza😅 But its well worth it!! I met the owners before they officially opened the NT location at Panes restaurant when at the time I was their waitress! Sweet people and I am so glad that I finally had the chance to indulge in such good pizza! Thanks again guys and I will be back for sure!

Phenomenal service and fantastic pizza. The lady operating this location went above and beyond in her service to us. She gave us some great recommendations and all the food was delicious.

I recently enjoyed trying the Dee's hot honey pizza and found it to be delicious! It's full of flavor and a high quality pizza. It can be a bit messy, but totally worth it!

The great news is there are no deep fryers here and the Pizza, wings, chicken fingers and everything is cooked in a real wood fired oven, in fact they have two! The place has been redone very tastefully and it's nice to have another pizza place in North Tonawanda. Their signature thin crust pizza was actually pretty good and crispy. The staff was very friendly and responsive. Good luck.

We’ve always been fans of the Grand Island location Pizza Amore, so we were naturally excited to find out it was moving to North Tonawanda. The first time we tried the NT location was a bit disappointing, but we wanted to try it once again to see if they’d perfected their system. We ordered “The Dave” and it was fantastic! Perfectly sweet sauce, perfectly charred pepperoni cups, perfectly thick crust, and the tastiest pepadews and sausage to compliment the rest of the pizza. The pizza is more expensive than other pizza places in the area, but definitely worth the occasional splurge when you want some more quality pizza!

Best pizza/price in the area The buffalo chicken and spinach ricotta pizzas are excellent and reheat well

Phenomenal OMG thank you lord good pizza! Wow! Really delicious. Outstanding wings. I'd had their pizza from their food truck. Loved it. This is like top 5 pizza in a region that is known for incredible pizza/food. The whole brick oven technique is amazing. Then to see the menu. They have desserts and salads. Service was fantastic. Big easy to park parking lot. Very clean. Great location on Payne near North Tonawanda High School. This pizzeria is a destination!

Ordered for the first time tonight, we got the chicken bacon ranch pizza OMG that was a bomb pizza. We also order 1/2 tray of cheese and pepperoni also very good. Staff was friendly and the place was clean. All around pleased with my experience.

Anyone complaining about this pizza must've lost their sense of taste. It's woodfired right in front of you. The sauce is great, the toppings are great and generous. The staff are super friendly and helpful. This is one of my favourites in the area. Fantastic pizza.

This is by far my favorite pizza in this area. Their wings are also fantastic. You just can’t beat that wood fired flavor.

I rarely ever post reviews but WOW! I had to for this one. I got the stinger pizza and wow! It is the absolute best I've ever had! They do not hold back on toppings. Delicious taste. Seasoned well.

Wow! Outstanding pizza. Thin and delishious! Got the traditional Pizza Margarita & a Pepperoni Pizza w/Amore Sauce. Great Ribeye sub too. It's not cheap, but in this case, you get what you pay for. This is my new favorite pizza. As long as they keep cranking out great za, I'll keep lining up to buy it.

The Pizza is well worth the price! Their sauce is outstanding and the have the perfect char on their crispy crust! I'm confident in saying that this beats every pizzeria in the area (although it is a different style of pizza) My personal recommendation would be the Galbani Amore pizza

The dill pickle pizza is so good. They had an insane amount of orders at food truck Thursday and got everything done so quick and perfectly. Top notch place

We rarely order pizza anymore- it's so easy to make at home. That being said, Pizza Amore will get my vote, and my money. The Buffalo Chicken Pizza was absolutely perfect! Bonus points for super delicious and expertly cooked crust.

The best and most delicious pizza anywhere. Been going there for a long time and have never had anything less than 5 stars. The people that work there are the nicest and will go out of their way to make sure you're completely satisfied with your food. I can't imagine going anywhere else. Do yourself a favor and check them out.

I will never go anywhere else. This is by far the best pizza in the city. The brick oven can't be beat. I get the traditional sauce but they also offer a sweet sauce. Whatever your preference you will not be disappointed. So yummy.

Visited Pizza Amore in Tonawanda this evening and I can’t say enough great things about the entire experience. We stopped there after a long, sad day and it’s almost as if the gentleman at the counter could tell we needed extra kindness. DJ was attentive, courteous, helpful and took very good care of us. The rest of the staff followed his lead and were just as wonderful. The chicken wing pizza was phenomenal and the rest of our food was cooked to perfection. I highly recommend Pizza Amore. 5 stars 🌟

My work tried this pizza for the first time yesterday and it was awesome ! So many options that you can get in any size including personal so perfect for lunch! I had the spinach and ricotta pizza and added banana peppers. It was so good! Definitely will be ordering again. Give them a try !

If you like pizza that’s similar to Neapolitan, and open before 4pm grab some pizza amoreee. Their pizza was actually very good. Saucy! Pizza is always better hot & on the spot as any pizza via dlvy cools down & will not be the same. It was far better than I expected and these days,’ You’re not spending less than 25 plus on a pie. Pricing was actually very good because I can go down the street and spend double on a pie etc, that’s not nearly as good. It’s filling as well and the young lady there was very helpful. It’s easy to miss this place just because of the traffic & area. Try not to and thank me later ☺️The only thing I would say and maybe some more cheese on the slices? But that’s just a Ula request. The pizza is supposed to be exactly how It was made. I was impressed. Thank you!

jen kephart

Consistently excellent. The depth of flavor in the crust is stellar.

Ula Jebara

If you like pizza that’s similar to Neapolitan, and open before 4pm grab some pizza amoreee. Their pizza was actually very good. Saucy! Pizza is always better hot & on the spot as any pizza via dlvy cools down & will not be the same. It was far better than I expected and these days,’ You’re not spending less than 25 plus on a pie. Pricing was actually very good because I can go down the street and spend double on a pie etc, that’s not nearly as good. It’s filling as well and the young lady there was very helpful. It’s easy to miss this place just because of the traffic & area. Try not to and thank me later ☺️The only thing I would say and maybe some more cheese on the slices? But that’s just a Ula request. The pizza is supposed to be exactly how It was made. I was impressed. Thank you!

jenny

We rarely order pizza anymore- it's so easy to make at home. That being said, Pizza Amore will get my vote, and my money. The Buffalo Chicken Pizza was absolutely perfect! Bonus points for super delicious and expertly cooked crust.

Paul Scott

The best and most delicious pizza anywhere. Been going there for a long time and have never had anything less than 5 stars. The people that work there are the nicest and will go out of their way to make sure you're completely satisfied with your food. I can't imagine going anywhere else. Do yourself a favor and check them out.

Essa Karim

Phenomenal service and fantastic pizza. The lady operating this location went above and beyond in her service to us. She gave us some great recommendations and all the food was delicious.

Tony Gugino

I will never go anywhere else. This is by far the best pizza in the city. The brick oven can't be beat. I get the traditional sauce but they also offer a sweet sauce. Whatever your preference you will not be disappointed. So yummy.

T B

Visited Pizza Amore in Tonawanda this evening and I can’t say enough great things about the entire experience. We stopped there after a long, sad day and it’s almost as if the gentleman at the counter could tell we needed extra kindness. DJ was attentive, courteous, helpful and took very good care of us. The rest of the staff followed his lead and were just as wonderful. The chicken wing pizza was phenomenal and the rest of our food was cooked to perfection. I highly recommend Pizza Amore. 5 stars 🌟

Good pizza.

Amazing pizza

Pizza was great staff was friendly order was out quickly.

Pizza and chicken fingers was great. Steak Sub had way to much mayo on it for my taste. May get condiments like mayo and oil on the side for future sub purchases. My 11 year old daughter said the chicken fingers were some of the best she ever had. My mom enjoyed her spinach garlic pizza but wanted more garlic. Over all very good.

Used Uber pizza was very good after I had to reheat ,salad was cold,driver was efficient but Uber placed the order then looked for a driver took 28 minutes to get a driver,so pizza was cold,Uber needs to find driver first then order food

Michael Fyock

Used Uber pizza was very good after I had to reheat ,salad was cold,driver was efficient but Uber placed the order then looked for a driver took 28 minutes to get a driver,so pizza was cold,Uber needs to find driver first then order food

It's meatlovers. BURNED. Was not good

Pizza real good but chicken wing just horrible

Had the medium Pizza Margherita and the sauce was good but the middle of the pizza was too soggy from the sauce and the outer portion of the pizza was the best part of the pizza (almost like in Trapani, Sicily).

Customer service was 5 stars along with how fast I got my pizza. But the pizza itself was unfortunately just a major let down. I ordered a Medium Cheese and Pepperoni pizza to go. The pizza looked perfect nice and cheesy enough Pepperoni on each individual piece that I wasn't trying to pick off some from another slice to add to mine and the perfect amount of sauce so that it wasn't dry tasting but it also wasn't dripping all over you. But there was no flavor to it except for the cheese and Pepperoni.

Menu is very large and I saw no easy and quick way to build your own. Prices where high. $27 for two personal pan pizza's. I don't see us going back unfortunately. I recommend a really easy to see build your own option for a flat price. Pizza was alright.

Ate there 5/16/22. Ordered cheese and pepperoni personal pan and the suggested garlic knots by the cashier. Very thin crust, spicy pepperoni, burnt crust. Garlic knots, I've had better frozen ones. Taste was very average, not worth the price for both pizza and knots. No better than little Caesars that was there for years.

Food was way too burnt Love the fact that they bake the fries & wings but they kept it in the oven way too long. Crust on the pizza was also burnt! 1st and last order from this place. I just received this order 15 minutes ago.To the (Owner) On the website which is where I ordered from it didn’t give a option for a “lighter char” and the pizza still shouldn’t have been charred/burnt!! A friend of mine said I should have call u guys to complain but I had already left the review. Fries should’ve been delivered charred to hell & unable to eat though!! Make sure each order is properly cooked next time.

Vanecia C

Food was way too burnt Love the fact that they bake the fries & wings but they kept it in the oven way too long. Crust on the pizza was also burnt! 1st and last order from this place. I just received this order 15 minutes ago.To the (Owner) On the website which is where I ordered from it didn’t give a option for a “lighter char” and the pizza still shouldn’t have been charred/burnt!! A friend of mine said I should have call u guys to complain but I had already left the review. Fries should’ve been delivered charred to hell & unable to eat though!! Make sure each order is properly cooked next time.

New to the area and this place was extremely disappointing! Do not recommend. The price was outrageous for what we received. Arrived on time and was told it would be another 15 minutes. Ordered a Greek salad with cheese and 2 different dressings on the side because of allergies and they didn't put the cheese on the side, they ran out of feta, then said it would take 10 more minutes to remake it as well as didn't give us the correct extra dressing flavor that was paid for. No discount or remedy for it. Or friend the salad was ordered for wasn't able to eat the salad because of the cheese allergy, complete waste. Atmosphere and customer service was appropriate to a fast food restaurant not an expensive pizza place. That being said the pepperoni pizza and wings were good, the cannoli pizza was okay, and we won't return or recommend.

Michelle Yakich

New to the area and this place was extremely disappointing! Do not recommend. The price was outrageous for what we received. Arrived on time and was told it would be another 15 minutes. Ordered a Greek salad with cheese and 2 different dressings on the side because of allergies and they didn't put the cheese on the side, they ran out of feta, then said it would take 10 more minutes to remake it as well as didn't give us the correct extra dressing flavor that was paid for. No discount or remedy for it. Or friend the salad was ordered for wasn't able to eat the salad because of the cheese allergy, complete waste. Atmosphere and customer service was appropriate to a fast food restaurant not an expensive pizza place. That being said the pepperoni pizza and wings were good, the cannoli pizza was okay, and we won't return or recommend.

Staff are not helpful at NT and the food is not good either. GI location has a better product, more like a real pizza place

After weeks of anxiously waiting for the opening in North Tonawanda, I'm sad to say I won't go back - although the price was completely outrageous, I'm not saying you won't like it, it's just not my taste or style of pizza and wings that i prefer - they definitely defy our local norm !

It was cooked really good. The workers were great. The pizza is way over garlic taste and way over priced. When I eat pizza I want to taste it not just garlic. A personal pizza was $12. Much overpriced in my opinion. I will not order there again.

Ordered steak and cheese pizza , was originally told 20-25 min . Got there and had to wait an additional 10 minutes. Ended up giving us a personal pan pizza instead of small that we ordered originally. Had to pay the difference of the two pizzas . Kept personal pan pizza. Steak and cheese pizza was overloaded with banana peppers. Too much for a small pizza. Decent. 2 out of 5. May go back if in a jam or hurry.

mike mayville

Ordered steak and cheese pizza , was originally told 20-25 min . Got there and had to wait an additional 10 minutes. Ended up giving us a personal pan pizza instead of small that we ordered originally. Had to pay the difference of the two pizzas . Kept personal pan pizza. Steak and cheese pizza was overloaded with banana peppers. Too much for a small pizza. Decent. 2 out of 5. May go back if in a jam or hurry.

We ordered a large Dee’s Hot Honey. What a limp, sloppy, soupy mess! Is it always this bad or does it just not travel well during a delivery?

I ordered there famous pizza stingers chicken and it was saggy and looks like soup not pizza I returned it back and told them just give me cheese and mushrooms and i took it home it was the same allot of sauce and after waiting for it to kool down so I can pick it up it was the same thing every thing fall off it felt like I have to use a spoon to eat it I throw the whole pizza out waist of money and time please if you can’t make a good pizza don’t claim is good i had way batter pizza then that and your one slice of pizza that is missing it’s on the ground because it’s a soup not pizza it’s under cooked in side you should work on making your customers happy not the other way around and by the way the second pizza it went in the garbage i should have asked for refund

Jerry Boye

We ordered a large Dee’s Hot Honey. What a limp, sloppy, soupy mess! Is it always this bad or does it just not travel well during a delivery?

Usexpress Lo

I ordered there famous pizza stingers chicken and it was saggy and looks like soup not pizza I returned it back and told them just give me cheese and mushrooms and i took it home it was the same allot of sauce and after waiting for it to kool down so I can pick it up it was the same thing every thing fall off it felt like I have to use a spoon to eat it I throw the whole pizza out waist of money and time please if you can’t make a good pizza don’t claim is good i had way batter pizza then that and your one slice of pizza that is missing it’s on the ground because it’s a soup not pizza it’s under cooked in side you should work on making your customers happy not the other way around and by the way the second pizza it went in the garbage i should have asked for refund

Soggy pizza. If you like to fold your slice as you eat it, slathered in grease, this is your pizza.

This place ruins their pizzas by using cheap cheese or sauce! 🤮 😆

I wanted to try something new today and let me tell you this is the most overpriced pizza place in WNY. I just ordered 2 small pizzas and they showed up with tiny personal pan pizzas. I guess I should've known when they charge $2/chicken wing as well. Ill never be ordering from here again.

Tried a few different times now since they opened, also gave them a few extra chances. Asked for sweet pizza each time. Have yet to receive a pizza that tastes sweet at all. Disappointing.

Crust was good where it was charred, too soggy in the middle from the outrageous amount of grease that soaked in. First and last pizza from here. Too greasy, too expensive and not worth the hour wait!

Good food terrible customer service make you feel like they don't appreciate your business. Once again Friday night wife tried ordering food from there picked up phone hung up on twice then it seems like they just take the phone off the hook from 7:00 on we want Little Caesars back

This was my second visit. My first visit i waited 20 minutes longer than my order was to have taken then they forgot to put the pepperoni on the pepperoni pizza and it wasn't completely cooked. This time I stopped in for a slice. It was so greasy it took 2 paper towels to soak up the grease. The slice was burned around the crust and on the bottom in different places. Maybe that's how fire baked pizza is supposed to be but either way not for me and I won't be back. The one thing redeeming is the person working there was very nice. Honestly I go to a lot of different pizza places and the pizza here I would give no stars if possible.

I tried to order on line and certain subs were shown “out of stock” while others on the menu didn’t appear at all. I then tried to call and no one answered. Since I was ordering for other family members, I went there in person. The counter girl was courteous and took my order and was sure to ask if I wanted the rolls toasted, which I ordered. When I asked how long, the manager told me 30 minutes. When I came back in 30 minutes, they told me it would be 10 more. When I returned in 10 minutes, they told me it would be 5 more minutes. When I finally opened the order, the rolls were not toasted and in fact were cold.

Very disorganized. Ordered 2 pizzas and when I arrived to pick them up I was told my order wasn't ready even though I arrived ten minutes past the given pick up time. So I waited another 30 minutes in the parking lot only to be given the wrong order and when I said that I didn't order wings now mind you when I arrived I started my name and what I had ordered. When the server went to check the warmer there were my two pizzas the same two that had been in the warmer when I got there. So I get them home and they were terrible and cold and vary unenjoyable. This is the second bad experience I've had here so I won't be a customer at this location any longer.