Candice Cadena

I picked this spot for birthday dinner takeout and it did not disappoint! Very vegan friendly, and my non-vegan boyfriend loved our vegan meal as much as I did! They even had vegan shakes and the peanutbutter chocolate shake I had was delicious. I wish I had ordered a larger size! I am excited to return and try more of their menu!

Celia Eckstein

As you can see by my review below that my prior visit wasn’t good. I have to say that I tried again and the service, food and customer service was great. They made up for what they wete lacking. Thank you! Placed an order online for a sub, chicken wings and fried mushrooms. When I arrived the place was empty, no other patrons, and I was unpleasantly greeted by a girl at the back of the kitchen. I told her I was here to pick ip an order and was asked - what order. Since there were no other orders there I assumed she would know but I told her anyway. I was slid the order and told you’re good. When I hot home the wings were so badly burned they were not edible. The sub was soggy and the mushrooms so drenched in grease it was gross. I called them back explained about the wings and was told to call back in an hour and ask for management. I took the wings back in and was greeted by the unpleasant girl again. She took my name and number down in s binder, never looked at me, never apologized or offered any explanation and that was the end of the transaction. I worked to hard for my money to be spent for marginal food at an unappreciated place. I have had very good experiences in the past but this set a new tone. I will not be returning.

Kelly Johnston

LOVE the vegan/meatless options! So hard to find that ANYWHERE here, so I'm so glad we stopped by. The gluten free pizza crust was surprisingly good and the staff was willing to make my own frankenstein pizza I wanted. And it was DELICIOUS! We will find be going back!

Keith Milbrand

We have been ordering from you guys for many years, one of my children even works there for a little while, one of our favorite pizzas from there is the stuffed banana pepper pizza which we ordered last week, it seems somebody left the seeds in the peppers because the pizza was way too hot to eat And was a waste of $30

Megan H

We order from here at least once a week and they are usually great, but recently have been disappointed with wings and fingers. Horribly burnt fingers. You know they saw it before trying to cover up with sauce. Looks like we weren’t the only ones with burnt food recently from reading other reviews.

I arrived to pick up an order for someone else (2 pizzas and a fried dough) about 5 minutes past our estimated order time. The guy behind the counter asked me to wait while the fried dough was finishing up and said he'd bring the order to me when it was done. I grabbed a seat and figured it would take about 6-8 additional minutes, but wound up waiting almost 20 minutes. When I went back to the counter the same guy was talking to his buddy so I waited silently to see if he'd notice. After 45-60 seconds he finally stopped and saw me, then hurriedly grabbed the boxes sitting nearby and sent me off. I was told the pies were fine but the fried dough was like trying to eat soggy bread with a pound of cinnamon on it. Service experience tracks with what I've been reading throughout.

T C

Gluten free pizza with pepperoni. Tasted fine. I’m sorry $30 (29 and change) for this size?? Way too small. Kind of ridiculous. If I’m paying premium price I should be getting premium pizza

I really struggled with wheather or not to write this, but I have to. We've been long time customers of Wurlitzer Pizza back to when they were in the Wurlitzer building with the curtains on the windows and tables with cute tablecloths. We found our favorite. Lately, not at all. Yesterday I ordered the special, medium, ten (10) wing's. I specifically asked for thin crust and cut like a pie NO square's. For the third time, no thin crust and of course it was cut in squares. Sadly, this was our last order. I genuinely like supporting small local businesses, thankfully their are many other pizzas that give us what we order. This was Thursday February 26th at approximately 5:00 p.m., just in case the manager wanted to look over the orders.

Lee Trimmer

ordered take out for the first time, wont be back again, over priced for what it was, we got a large pizza half peperoni half just cheese, hardly any peperoni, also got double order of boneless wings, half BBQ half plain, wing were over cooked and very crispy a few were almost burnt. pricing is too high for quality/portion of food. too small of a size for a large pizza almost not enough 4 adults and 1 child. $57 for what we ordered. also we asked for a side of hot sauce because we ordered half the wings plain, we were charged an additional 85 cents for a cup of hot sauce. i would understand if it was an extra item but we ordered half the wings plain. it should have been included it is what prompted this review.

Rain Bow

Eating specialized food here is a waste. This is a Owner or Manager problem. The employees shouldn't be heald accountable. I did not eat in store. I felt bad for yelling at the employees for this one which is how I got small salad & medium pizza to my house for $43.47. That was before the pizza came! I ordered a Gluten Free Pizza which came with about half of pizza worth of topping. It's a Medium pizza compared to a normal large wheat flour pizza in size. I will add that it was an average pizza not over the top delicious. Just ok, but I just do not understand how it can be this much. & One SIDE salad which you will see in the pics it was being shared with my parrot. He can get very sick from spoiled foods. The rest of the salad SEEMED very fresh & I had to throw my salad out as you can see why in the photos. Plus I live probably 3-5 miles, at most... Cannot get much closer & my delivery fee was $5.50 I should have not gotten my food from here, what saddens me the most. They used to be my favorite place to go or get food from! If we continue to pay these high prices, we will continue to see these high prices. Why don't we get together & strike (by not ordering for a month) maybe then these prices will go down. I am utterly disgusted!

Ludmela Konshin

There is rarely something so egregious that it forces me to take action. My first experience with this business happened today. I was so excited to support this business and their vegan options. I cannot in good consciousness recommend this for anyone. If the owner is serious about bringing vegan options to the community, I am willing to help because what would we be to let others fall for this? I ordered 2 medium pizzas and a Personal deep dish pizza for $77 that was so inedible I could not in good consciousness give it to a homeless person because it would be an affront to the homeless. If this owner is not willing to make changes, I will be the competition.

Jessie Dodson

Hardest fries I’ve ever had, my chicken finger sub was the driest and most burnt one I’ve ever had, didn’t even put mayo on it which I ordered. I really loved this place but they have been nothing but inconsistent the last couple of times.

Kelsey Sholtz

I love Wurlitzer Pizza but my most recent experience was not good. To start to girl that answered the phone was extremely dismissive and rude, rushed through taking my order, and didn’t even give me a total just told me my order number then hung up the phone. I brought my food home to find the deep fried cauliflower I ordered was not only burned but wasn’t even a full order. The subs we had were okay but definitely not the usual standard. Very disappointed.