Al Ve

Came here for weekday lunch to celebrate my husband’s birthday. The food was amazing. The service was fantastic and very attentive. The lunch special prices are a great deal. They gave us a free dessert with a candle which was so nice. Highly recommend.

Robert JM

Fancy place to eat on Main Street. I had lobster ravioli and my date ate spinach salad. We enjoyed drinks at bar and had 2 seat table in corner. Food was delicious and service was excellent. Highly recommend. $100+ bill.

Stephany R.

La Fontanella is my favorite place to go when craving an exquisite food experience! Excellent place, atmosphere, and service as always. I strongly recommend 😊

Maria Di

I can say I am a restaurant junkie. This is by far the best food. The chef is incredible and all staff is warm and friendly. I took my son for his birthday and he loved it too. My daughter loved it as well. Here he is turning 30!

Unus Mareyo

This place was amazing!! It is a very fancy Italian cuisine with a beautiful setting. The waiters respond to your needs very beautifully and their food is delicious!!! I had their tiramisu, and it was delightful. Since I had about 22 people with me, we had a fixed meal. I was impressed on how the waiters responded well under pressure and delivered the food fast. I passed by Wolfs Lane dozens of times, but it's such a small restaurant that I barely even see it. But I'm glad I went. This is one of the best Italian cuisines I've been to in my life!!!!!!

My Umdnj

Update December 2025: I’ve been back twice since my first review and have thoroughly enjoyed every bite. I’ll keep going back. It’s now worthy of 5 stars. December 2024: My seafood salad and homemade pasta seafood special were expertly prepared except for too much garlic in both. I love garlic, but it should be subtle, not hit you over the head. Service was superb, atmosphere was most enjoyable. I will definitely go back and try other menu items or ask them to go easy on the garlic.

Kerene Edie

I enjoyed having dinner with my friends here this month. I was able to order Penne a la Vodka which was not on the menu and it tasted good. The portion could have been better for the price as I was still hungry. I ordered fruit punch and I don't know what they brought but it was so disgusting. I had to ask for it to be returned and I ordered something else- Cranberry. I didn't see much on the menu that caught my attention so I stuck to what I knew and ordered the penne. The staff was very helpful and attentive. We appreciate the customer service as they were excellent and professional.

Christian Sison

Tried to order takeout, and nothing we wanted from the menu was available. Can’t be a 4.7 if you offer takeout without an updated menu to use. Just don’t offer takeout; everybody in the reviews seems to love the food by dining in.

M M

Enjoyed our first visit here but probably won’t return. Sergios and Tutta Bella are better for traditional northern Italian fare. The carbonara ($22) was wrong - cream sauce, not enough parm, no egg. It was more like a runny alfredo with a few onions and a little bacon. The branzino in photo was very good ($25) in a delicate tomato caper sauce. The dining room is small, long and narrow - felt like a hallway. The service was quite good - except they didn’t know which diner in a party of six ordered which item. Also, waters ran out, and had to ask several times for check. Not horrible, but not perfect.

Tony Paris

Normally I would never give such a long rating to an establishment. We were there for a holiday party. The next day everybody came down. The next day half of the people that were there came down with the stomach virus. I was one of them. Not blaming the establishment. But I must make a note that this was the experience that I had here.

R F

I had a reservation here for my mother’s birthday. After we were seated, we waited over 20 minutes for menus even though our waitress kept walking around us and looking at us so she could obviously tell for those 20+ minutes that we didn’t have menus. The place wasn’t even busy. It wasn’t late, either. It was only 7:30. I asked to start everyone off with seltzer only to have another waitress mix our half full seltzers with tap water. Once we got our dinner after finally ordering, the food was cold. Our plates did not live up to the images posted on their website at all. The presentation was ugly, sloppy, overall mediocre. We ordered wine and never got it. We didn’t even want to stay for dessert, we asked for the check and it turned out that we were billed for the wine. We had them remove the charges. Then when we got the final bill to sign, they gave us someone else’s bill so they had to void it from my account and give us our actual bill. After paying, our waitress came up to us and said “oh there’s a birthday?” And my mother said “oh, no.” As we were about to leave, my mom was given a cheesecake. Although I appreciate the gesture, we just wanted to leave ASAP to celebrate elsewhere. I have never experienced service, quality, and food like that before. I would give this place zero stars if I could. Don’t come here.