Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

We order from this location alot. There sheet pizzas are some of the best around. I always order the double pepperoni with cheese. It's absolutely one of the best sheets around. The crust is amazing 😍 The sauce is delicious 😋 and the perfect amount. With a generous amount of cheese as well. You Won't be disappointed. Thanks again.

Scott R. Beckett

We order from this location alot. There sheet pizzas are some of the best around. I always order the double pepperoni with cheese. It's absolutely one of the best sheets around. The crust is amazing 😍 The sauce is delicious 😋 and the perfect amount. With a generous amount of cheese as well. You Won't be disappointed. Thanks again.

Pizza has been just ok from here. Recently got a slice and was shocked that it was $7.00. Size of slice has decreased over the past couple years while the pricing has gone up. Save your funds and head down to Perri's. Slice is significantly larger for $5.00.

Not a huge fan of the sauce used in the pasta dishes. Also, the bread to meat ratio on the subs was about 3:1. We had chicken finger subs but I think the girl answering the phone forgot to ask if we wanted any mail oil or blue cheese on them as they were on the dryer side. The subs could have also used a little bit more lettuce onions tomatoes etc. the sub rolls themselves are delicious they are clearly Wegmans sub rolls which are absolutely phenomenal. The same sub rolls were used for the cheesy mozzarella bread which was also phenomenal. The stuffed shells were good however felt like they were missing a bit of a creamy flavor or a cheesy flavor the stuffing felt a little on the dry side but the shell noodles themselves were nice and thick and big and cooked to the perfect density. The chicken parm was fantastic. Again, though, the sauce almost tasted burnt. I prefer a little sweeter of a sauce, but overall it was quite tastey!

I have gone here several times. I am a fan of their pizza with the old fashioned pepperoni. But the lose stars on their fish fry. We got it twice in the last couple months. In both cases a take out. The first time they forgot the roll and tarter sauce. I was already home so I just ignored it and luckily I had stuff to make my own at home. The food was pretty good. We took a second shot at it. This time I actually paid a dollar or whatever it was to get extra tarter sauce figuring this way they couldn't forget. Well, the remembered the regular order of tarter but didn't put the extra in the bag. Not only that but no coleslaw. We got the roll but no coleslaw. Again, I was already home but I was pretty aggravated. I called and explained both instances... all I got was....we can send someone out to you in 10 or 15 minutes with it. The fish was already almost room temperature and I just hung up. Honestly, they should have refunded my credit card for at least a portion of my order. I am not looking for free food.....but I was just very disappointed in the food/store/customer service.

Hanz Fritz

Not a huge fan of the sauce used in the pasta dishes. Also, the bread to meat ratio on the subs was about 3:1. We had chicken finger subs but I think the girl answering the phone forgot to ask if we wanted any mail oil or blue cheese on them as they were on the dryer side. The subs could have also used a little bit more lettuce onions tomatoes etc. the sub rolls themselves are delicious they are clearly Wegmans sub rolls which are absolutely phenomenal. The same sub rolls were used for the cheesy mozzarella bread which was also phenomenal. The stuffed shells were good however felt like they were missing a bit of a creamy flavor or a cheesy flavor the stuffing felt a little on the dry side but the shell noodles themselves were nice and thick and big and cooked to the perfect density. The chicken parm was fantastic. Again, though, the sauce almost tasted burnt. I prefer a little sweeter of a sauce, but overall it was quite tastey!

Chris M

Pizza has been just ok from here. Recently got a slice and was shocked that it was $7.00. Size of slice has decreased over the past couple years while the pricing has gone up. Save your funds and head down to Perri's. Slice is significantly larger for $5.00.

B Dart

I have gone here several times. I am a fan of their pizza with the old fashioned pepperoni. But the lose stars on their fish fry. We got it twice in the last couple months. In both cases a take out. The first time they forgot the roll and tarter sauce. I was already home so I just ignored it and luckily I had stuff to make my own at home. The food was pretty good. We took a second shot at it. This time I actually paid a dollar or whatever it was to get extra tarter sauce figuring this way they couldn't forget. Well, the remembered the regular order of tarter but didn't put the extra in the bag. Not only that but no coleslaw. We got the roll but no coleslaw. Again, I was already home but I was pretty aggravated. I called and explained both instances... all I got was....we can send someone out to you in 10 or 15 minutes with it. The fish was already almost room temperature and I just hung up. Honestly, they should have refunded my credit card for at least a portion of my order. I am not looking for free food.....but I was just very disappointed in the food/store/customer service.

I have no quarrel with the food, which is always good, but getting too expensive. It's $18.95 now for a 12" (medium) white pizza! Then there's the ever increasing delivery charge (currently $3.50 + tax = $3.78), which is a pure profit grab. They are sure to remind you that the driver does not share in this exorbitant charge, so make sure you tip the driver appropriately. Such arrogance! I used to be a loyal customer. My delivery orders were routinely in the $40 range. But I've had enough. There are plenty of other pizza places to choose from. And that's what I'm doing.

We ordered pizza from your Penfield location and needless to say, we were very disappointed. The pizza looked like it had been sitting around under the warming lights for 10-15 mins. We specifically asked for our 20 wings well done and they weren’t at all. We had pizza and wings from Salvatore’s last weekend for a party and it was great, so we wanted to try again. Definitely not worth the $30 we paid.

We ordered three things ... First the thin thin pizza says its on wheat dough ... it was a wheat tortilla gross! It should say that in the description. The second thing was the fish fry. We ordered extra tarter sauce and PAID for it. When we picked up our order we were told no tarter sauce. I would have expected a call so we could have the option of changing our order. Especially since we ordered extra. I don't know about you, but I don't eat a fish fry without tarter sauce, so it went in the garbage. The third was the garbage plate was ok. That's the only reason this gets 2 stars and not 1.

I've always been happy with the food here, but last time I got a pizza it was very disappointing. The cheese was burned. They were out of pepperoni, which I thought was rediculous, so I got sausage. There were maybe 4-5 pieces of sausage on a sheet pizza. The wings were ok, not great. Very expensive, very disappointed.

Annette Ballone

I've always been happy with the food here, but last time I got a pizza it was very disappointing. The cheese was burned. They were out of pepperoni, which I thought was rediculous, so I got sausage. There were maybe 4-5 pieces of sausage on a sheet pizza. The wings were ok, not great. Very expensive, very disappointed.

Sarah T

We ordered three things ... First the thin thin pizza says its on wheat dough ... it was a wheat tortilla gross! It should say that in the description. The second thing was the fish fry. We ordered extra tarter sauce and PAID for it. When we picked up our order we were told no tarter sauce. I would have expected a call so we could have the option of changing our order. Especially since we ordered extra. I don't know about you, but I don't eat a fish fry without tarter sauce, so it went in the garbage. The third was the garbage plate was ok. That's the only reason this gets 2 stars and not 1.

Bri DeLorenzo

We ordered pizza from your Penfield location and needless to say, we were very disappointed. The pizza looked like it had been sitting around under the warming lights for 10-15 mins. We specifically asked for our 20 wings well done and they weren’t at all. We had pizza and wings from Salvatore’s last weekend for a party and it was great, so we wanted to try again. Definitely not worth the $30 we paid.

Terry P

I have no quarrel with the food, which is always good, but getting too expensive. It's $18.95 now for a 12" (medium) white pizza! Then there's the ever increasing delivery charge (currently $3.50 + tax = $3.78), which is a pure profit grab. They are sure to remind you that the driver does not share in this exorbitant charge, so make sure you tip the driver appropriately. Such arrogance! I used to be a loyal customer. My delivery orders were routinely in the $40 range. But I've had enough. There are plenty of other pizza places to choose from. And that's what I'm doing.

We order from here ALL. THE TIME!! Ordered an eggplant parm sub. Had it delivered. It legit looks like it caught on fire!! Burned to a crisp. So I called and was told I could bring it back and they would re-make it. Or she (the so called manager Makenzie) would give me 1/2….HALF CREDIT for another one!!! What???? I need to bring it back?? I just paid how much to have it delivered??!! Very rude, zero customer service. Never going back there!! Im just glad not all the locations treat customers like this. Need to add This is the Penfield location

Kristi P

We order from here ALL. THE TIME!! Ordered an eggplant parm sub. Had it delivered. It legit looks like it caught on fire!! Burned to a crisp. So I called and was told I could bring it back and they would re-make it. Or she (the so called manager Makenzie) would give me 1/2….HALF CREDIT for another one!!! What???? I need to bring it back?? I just paid how much to have it delivered??!! Very rude, zero customer service. Never going back there!! Im just glad not all the locations treat customers like this. Need to add This is the Penfield location

Service sucked....walked in to people staring blankly at you like you interrupted their day, then gaslight you that you are wrong about the poor quality of a dish you order frequently because it is the only thing you like there.....no thanks. Going out to eat is a treat for us and the mood of the employees effects the quality of the food and the experience. This is longer a place where we want to come. Hope they figure it out because it used to be better.

Didn't deliver part of our order, manager had the nerve to argue with me about a refund. Disgusting customer service, don't waste your time and money.

No napkins. I'm sitting eating in their restaurant with pizza grease on my face fingers, and the answer is "we don't have napkins at this location".

I ordered through Instacart... was told the order was received, being worked on. I waited 1.5hrs and checked back and was told the order was refunded with no other explanation. I won't be ordering again any time soon

If I could rate negative stars I would! This was our third time getting food that was absolutely disgusting, the wings were soggy and tasted like old oil, the pizza was burnt. When spending 70$ on wings and pizza you would expect that it would be edible.

Apparently the want-to-be manager felt very confident to yell at a nurse practitioner about what she ordered and what she received. He spoke to her like a toddler. Was rude and disrespectful and I will never be back. Everyone deserves respect especially health care workers they were short-staffed before the pandemic and it's worse now. Some people are on call and have to Tell patient's families just difficult news. You should have done the right thing. You should just hand it over the blue cheese How much did it cost you a a quarter? You should have credited her account card and gave it to her for free after the way you treated her I watched the whole thing.

Austin

No napkins. I'm sitting eating in their restaurant with pizza grease on my face fingers, and the answer is "we don't have napkins at this location".

Annmarie Lent

I ordered through Instacart... was told the order was received, being worked on. I waited 1.5hrs and checked back and was told the order was refunded with no other explanation. I won't be ordering again any time soon

Mel Mel

Didn't deliver part of our order, manager had the nerve to argue with me about a refund. Disgusting customer service, don't waste your time and money.

Sarah Falkides

If I could rate negative stars I would! This was our third time getting food that was absolutely disgusting, the wings were soggy and tasted like old oil, the pizza was burnt. When spending 70$ on wings and pizza you would expect that it would be edible.

Melissa Chandler

Service sucked....walked in to people staring blankly at you like you interrupted their day, then gaslight you that you are wrong about the poor quality of a dish you order frequently because it is the only thing you like there.....no thanks. Going out to eat is a treat for us and the mood of the employees effects the quality of the food and the experience. This is longer a place where we want to come. Hope they figure it out because it used to be better.

Joanna

Apparently the want-to-be manager felt very confident to yell at a nurse practitioner about what she ordered and what she received. He spoke to her like a toddler. Was rude and disrespectful and I will never be back. Everyone deserves respect especially health care workers they were short-staffed before the pandemic and it's worse now. Some people are on call and have to Tell patient's families just difficult news. You should have done the right thing. You should just hand it over the blue cheese How much did it cost you a a quarter? You should have credited her account card and gave it to her for free after the way you treated her I watched the whole thing.