Ashton Dunsworth

Visiting for work. The best sandwich I've ever had the chance to eat! Even the left overs were awesome reheated!! Wish yall shipped to Oklahoma!!!

Matt Sawyer

Sandwich was as advertised. We split the Antipasto salad & the Greg Dezio hot sub. Only comment would be that i wish the chicken cutlet was a little hotter but flavor and crunch was great! Will go again

Jon Clough

Capone’s is the real deal! Bryan and his staff were extremely hospitable and genuinely enthusiastic about their product, which made the experience even better. The hustle and bustle inside this place is real, and you can immediately tell it’s because the food is worth it. I ordered a pepperoni slice, and it turned out to be a massive slice cut into half for only $5.50. The pizza is as good as it gets—crispy, cheesy, and full of flavor. Hands down, one of the best pizza spots in the area. Highly recommend

Scott Mercier

We did it and it boy was it worth it. The pizza was incredible too as I had to try the pizza with ricotta and hot honey, ham and pepperoni. It was decadent and really special I really loved it. This is really a great spot for us here in Penfield I 100% recommend.

+1

Brad Martin

I had the most amazing experience today. I wanted a sandwich and spicy Italians are always my favorite so I decided to stop in at Capone’s. I can’t tell you how amazing the spicy Italian grinder was. The perfect amount of heat and the meat was fresh. I’m glad I left the Best for last. Next time I visit I need the 12 inch. I wanted to say thanks to the folks at Capone’s amazing food and amazing people. This is my main spot for a hoagie when I’m in Rochester NY!

Mark Monclova

Absolutely great food and service. I will be going back asap. I ordered chicken finger plate over French fries and macaroni salad covered in country sweet sauce 😋

J S

Stopped in here for the first time the other day and we got a 12” roast beef sub. Absolutely amazing!! So much meat on the most delicious bread! We each ate a half of it and wow were we full!! The au juice to dunk the sub in was very tasty. No need to add any salt or pepper to any of it. Really loved it. Came back the next day (today) to try out the pizza! For the price of the pizza, you get so much! Nothing about it tasted cheap! Mozzarella cheese, spices, the toppings and especially the crust was so delicious. Glad we stopped in here for our visit up this way! Highly recommend. Superb.

Robine jayne

I found this pizza/sub place on social media TT - Eat local and he was absolutely correct! The chicken Milanese sandwich is a 10/10 Mac salad was fresh. Definitely stop in and try this small place. You will not be disappointed and don’t forget to try the chicken Milanese sandwich….. it’s fantastic. Keep up the great work Capones -the foodie lady

Ryan Jackson

I’m just happy. I’ve waited to write this review until after I tried more than one thing. After my first experience (chicken cutlet tray), I wanted to review immediately, but had to wait for my golden rule of 3. I recently moved here, coming from a place where we grew up on chicken cutlets sammies, legit-good pizza, and good dough. Chicken cutlet and broccoli rabe was your first meal as a child. Capones does it right. The chicken cutlet caesar sammie is a must. Don’t overthink this one. Absolute flavor town. Easily top rec. The stuffed meatball vodka Sammie was good. Capones seeded rolls are great as well- I’d recommend adding to every Sammie. Your basic vodka meatball. Still quality and flavorful. The Za. Finally. A place that checks the box. This place is easily my top pizza/sub place locally-now. Keep that ish up, Capones Looking forward to exploring the rest of the menu.

Asia Williams

Usually love this place but ordered through doordash and the cutlet was stale and seemed to be reheated. Pieces were very thin and hard to chew.

Makaila Barclay

The food was fresh, and hot! We ordered grilled wings, philly cheese steak, and the chicken riggie pasta. The wings were amazing! The steak sub was flavorful and the bread was so soft. Seasoned to perfection. The chicken riggie was different, spicy, but tasty. We would definitely return.

Mike Graz

Love this place. Worth the hype . We had 2 six inc subs. 1 vodka chicken parm and 1 black truffle steak and cheese. Both were big for six inches and were superb.

+12

Samuel Sweazy

Service was good but the food was subpar. I got a meatball sub and it literally had what seemed like a teaspoon of sauce on the whole thing. My wife said her chicken milanese sub wasn't good either. Lacking flavor and dry but somehow soggy. $50 for 2 subs and fries. We were stoked to try it but sadly very disappointed.