Patrick O'Shaughnessy

First time stopping here in downtown Penn Yan and we were not disappointed! What a cool little place to enjoy some coffee. We stopped in mid afternoon and there were just a few people chilling out on laptops. Very comfortable seating and clean. The coffee was awesome and enjoyable. Highly recommend a stop when in the area.

greg Hobart

Wonderful coffee. Beautiful interior. Haven't had their breakfast, but it looks delicious, and the pastries are spot on. They usually have a gluten-concious item as well if you're not celiac.

Chelsea Novak

Husband and I stopped in at the recommendation of our Airbnb host, and we are glad we did! The coffee shop itself is beautiful, plenty of seating for us on a Wednesday morning. Definitely gives off a masculine/ Joanna Gaines kind of aesthetic. Lattes were great and not overly sweet, the whipped feta bagel and sudsy bagel were both yummy (we split them!), and we took a Boston cream croissant with us to enjoy later (delicious!)

Nicholas Giobbi

Great coffee and even better pastry for breakfast. The girls behind the desk are kind and the service is quick despite the pace being pretty busy. Lots of places to sit. I works drive for a while just to get to Penn Yan to get their pour over coffee and the savory scones. Also have to recommend the croissants. The bagels are very good and toasted with cream cheese are fantastic too. Can’t recommend this place highly enough.

Adam Nichols

Don't pass up this gem on Main Street. We could have missed it if we were not paying attention. We could see it was a popular place as soon as we opened the door on this Sunday morning. The line was to the door, and the wait was about 20 minutes. The seats were packed inside and out. By the time we placed our order, some tables were available. The BEC on a butter croissant was delicious. The dark coffee was wonderful. The chocolate croissant was buttery with the perfect amount of chocolate to it.

+2

Huy Nguyen

The best coffee shop in town. The atmosphere is super relaxing here. They also have plenty of table and seating. A lot of outlets here as well so you can get some work done. The food and drinks are really good. Highly recommend stopping by Amity whenever you are in Penn Yan

+1

Annie Makepeace

High quality coffee beans, pastries and delicious breakfast options. Friends enjoyed the bagel with avocado and fig jam. I had a cinnamon macaron that was pretty incredible. Not too many vegetarian/vegan food options though.

poisoned_record

Camping in Keuka Lake State Park. Decided to go out for coffee and a light breakfast in the morning. I got the raspberry and cream croissant and it was the best croissant I've ever had 10/10. I got a hot chocolate but my friend got a latte with maple brown sugar syrup and it was sooooo good! They have quite a few food options and all of them sounded so good it was hard to choose. Next time I come back I will be trying the lemony sniket waffle. Atmosphere was homey, and service was fast and efficient. Overall, really good coffee shop!

Jennifer “Jen” Maltba

A ‘must add to the itinerary’ if visiting the Finger Lakes. Come for the coffee, stay for the breakfast. The egg & cheese croissant and the breakfast bowl are both fresh and delicious!! The space is lovely, and busy because of how great it is.

Sven “Chloe” Klingen

Such an adorable place! I loved my iced lavender latte and my parents loved their iced mochas! Their espresso is really good, it’s bold but not too bitter! I also got the chocolate croissant which was really buttery I loved it! The atmosphere is really nice lots of seating options even during Covid. The food and beverages were a little pricey but understandably so cause the quality was really good! The baristas were so nice and laughed at my jokes which I think made the coffee taste even better :D. Overall adorable and I hope to go back!

Gianna Mantegna

I'm not a coffee drinker, so I can't speak to the quality of the coffee. However, I ordered an earl grey that ended up tasting more like hot water and milk (even after letting it steep for 10 minutes). The other tea I had was slightly better, but it seems weird that with such a huge bag of tea that the flavor would take a while to get flavor. We also got a few pastries, but the only one that I liked was the croissant. Thats not to say everything was bad. My friend liked the coffee and the atmosphere was nice. Overall, I wouldnt come back though