Jack W Perry

Best shop in the county. Great staff, quality coffee and ingredients. Good snacks too including goods from Balthazar. Every town should have an Indy coffee store. Not on the menu board - but ask for “Megan’s drink.” - dirty chai (green tea - 1 scoop; espresso - 2 shots; light foam; oat milk). If you like whole bean for home, I suggest Black Cow Blend, Mingus Java, or Mud (hard to find). Although seating can be limited (less than 10 tables), if you go in the morning, there are numerous outside tables from nearby restaurants that you can sit at and enjoy your caffeine.. New remodel. Place looks great.

Gaetano Lombardo

My absolute favorite place to get coffee. Even though there are 8 coffee places within about 250 feet of each other near my office in the city, I'd rather leave home early so can get my coffee here. Plus staff is very friendly.

Sydney D.

We’ve been customers of the Black Cow for over a decade and are taking a moment to applaud Michelle, the owner, for going above and behind today for us in a pinch in a large coffee order. The café has been beautifully redone inside — it feels even more fresh and welcoming. Whether you are looking work for a few hours, catch up with a friend, or sit outside with a dog after walking around town, the Black Cow in Pleasantville is the go-to coffee spot in the area. There are plenty of coffee varieties to choose from, and you can even grab beans to take home. Always a great local spot with even better people.

Ethan Realander

Rolling Suds Power Washing is based right here in Westchester, and whenever we’re in Pleasantville we always make a stop at The Black Cow Coffee Company. This Pleasantville coffee shop is truly a local gem, with the best fresh-brewed coffee, lattes, and espresso in Westchester County. The baristas are friendly, knowledgeable, and the service is consistently excellent. Whether you’re looking for high-quality coffee beans to take home, a cozy spot to enjoy a cappuccino, or just the best coffee in Pleasantville, The Black Cow Coffee Company delivers every time. The atmosphere is warm, welcoming, and perfect for relaxing, working, or meeting friends. Their pastries and baked goods pair perfectly with the coffee and make this the go-to Pleasantville café for breakfast or an afternoon pick-me-up. If you’re searching for a Pleasantville coffee shop with great ambiance, delicious coffee, and a true community feel, The Black Cow Coffee Company is hands-down the best choice. Highly recommend this Westchester coffee shop to anyone who loves authentic, expertly crafted coffee.

Rebel Radio

Love the cafè in Phelps and came here for my first time, the smell alone was divine but the beverages themselves were even better!!

Besnik Nokaj

The only minor downside was the lack of outdoor seating, which would’ve been nice for enjoying my latte in the fresh air. Still, the indoor space was cozy enough to make up for it. Black Cow Coffee Company is a gem in Pleasantville, especially vibrant in fall and spring when the village feels extra charming. I highly recommend stopping by for a drink and some beans to take home. I give it 4.5 out of 5 stars for its excellent coffee and friendly atmosphere.

+1

John Davis

Great little cafe with locally roasted espresso pulled on a Faema (respect).

Christine Ashour

It’s the perfect local coffeeshop. We’ve gotten quite familiar with them due to renovating our kitchen😅so thank goodness for not only their coffee/chai but their excellent baked goods (danishes and muffins are our favorites). There is often a line especially on weekends but it moves promptly and besides it is a nice friendly atmosphere so no complaints about waiting. So much better buying local than the chain *ahem* down the street

Ramachandra Vishnubhatta

Visited this cafe 3-4 times in the last year and have loved their coffee and bakery items every time. Most recently had their Mocha with Oat milk and brownies. My mocha got over sooner than I wanted :), will come back here for more!

Lahiru Subasinghe

Stopped by to grab a coffee while passing through the Pleasenville area. It’s a small coffee shop with a very friendly staff who are always wearing a smile. I tried their Cow Whip, and it was absolutely delicious! They also have a great selection of baked items. Worth the visit.