Becca S

We went here for the first time, and it was amazing all around. The person who took the orders was helpful on making the pizza just the way we wanted, and was very patient. The food tasted great, and they were fast to bring it to the table! Blake even helped us get the pizza slices cut a little smaller for our young girls. We will definitely be going back again.

Vonelle Atwell

Food was absolutely amazing, ordered the Chicken Parmesan, the Mama Mia, and mozzarella sticks, both pizzas were amazing, and perfectly cooked, and the mozzarella sticks were perfectly crispy. The cashier, Eli, was extremely helpful and helped us decide on our appetizer without making us feel rushed. The store is extremely clean, and managers were super attentive and checked on us. Overall an amazing experience!

Roy Alicea

When it comes to good pizza and a selection of fine suds, Tony C's can't be beat. Led by frontman Michael (Mike), who was everywhere doing everything, the place was run like a well oiled machine. He made our experience joyful. His recommendation of pizzas to our liking, easy. While my wife is a Margarita pizza 🍕 lover, I am an old fashioned "just cheese please" Bronx guy. She said "why don't you try something different, you're always ordering the same thing" to which I replied... "Anything other than a cheese pizza isn't a Pizza!" So much for standing my ground 🙂‍↔️. She ordered me to order a Prosciutto infused pizza while she stuck with her usual margarita pizza. Oh well, let's hope it's a decent pie. Bang! It was delicious. Good taste and a 12" that was more than enough for me. We also had a Caesar salad that was a knockout. Good pizza and Mike was always making sure we were happy and well fed. Tony C's is a great place for families and large groups. Their tables are picnic size park tables, Comfortable and spacious. Oh, they have Gelato!!!

+2

Richard Leauvano

The food was all delicious! We had a Cesar salad, lemon pepper wings, mama Mia pizza and a butterfinger gelato… DID NOT DISAPPOINT!

+1

Path Welch

Meatball Sub Goals at Tony C’s Tony C’s knows how to do comfort food right! I ordered takeout and had the meatball sub, and it was everything you want—meaty, flavorful, and served on a perfectly toasty bun. The crispy fries didn’t last long (I blame my taste buds), and the house salad came with Italian dressing and a piece of garlic bread—because why not live your best carb life? Solid 5/5. I’d come back just for the bread… but let’s be honest, I’m getting the whole thing again.

kristin graham

We tried Tony C’s today and we loved it. The pizza was great. The mozzarella sticks are huge and really good. I had a side cesar salad and it was fabulous, really fresh and the croutons were so good, crunchy but not rock hard. The garlic knot was soft and buttery. We loved the atmosphere. Lots of room to accommodate a larger party. The staff was so friendly and gave us a little run down on the place since it was our first time. We will definitely be back!

+2

Gabz

Tried out Tony C's spontaneously one day and had a great time overall! The service was friendly and nice. It felt super clean inside. There was a lot of space to sit and I really loved the tables. I personally loved the toasted ravioli! I enjoyed the crunch and flavor. The pizza was good, but it didn't wow me. It felt a bit soggy from all the oil and it was a bit salty to my liking, but we really loved the crust. I definitely recommend giving this place a try!

Graham Stone

The pizza was excellent, we asked for extra mushrooms and they delivered extra mushrooms, it was delicious. It was also very nice to peruse a list of draft beers from local and out of state micro breweries at very reasonable prices. I chose a pint of Fat Tire. The only reason they don’t get five stars is because of the noise. The vast dining room seems to amplify the sounds around and it was impossible to have a conversation across the table. Some of this can be attributed to the time of day, it was one pm on a Sunday afternoon when all the kids soccer teams are celebrating after their morning games.

Nelida Safrit

First time eating here. The place was pretty full on a Friday evening. We ordered 4 pizzas, wings and few drinks. The Wings were excellent. The Margherita pizza was not good. They add olive oil after it’s cooked and it drips everywhere. The chicken Parmesan pizza was excellent. The Mama Mia pizza was excellent and the plain cheese was fine. Beer was very good. Juicy IPA and a Hazy IPA. Service was excellent. Our drinks and pizza came out in a timely manner. Go before 6 for happy hour. We missed it by 10 minutes!

+2

Yifat Cohen

My kid saw the pictures on doorDash and asked to come here for his birthday. The place looked really nice and the service was great. Sadly, the food wasn't. The wings were really dry and the pizza had no flavor. I don't know if it just the lack of salt in the dough or something missing in the marinera, but it wasn't tasty at all. The jalapeños were fresh and spicy (VERY spicy, so careful with those) but over all it was disappointing and definitely not worth $70.

+12

achelle foster

My kiddos took me here for mother's day and I really liked it.. This time for my son's birthday, we ordered food to go and was a bit disappointed.. pizza was good, but the appetizers were a let down.. Calamari were soggy and too much fried batter vs Calamari itself.. fried mozzy were just ok as well.. Eating in the restaurant is perhaps the way to go.. eat your food as you get it, specifically fried stuff..

+1

Stephanie Rozalia

We were disappointed, unfortunately. After looking at the pictures in the reviews, I thought I had picked a good spot for pizza. We aren't from here so we didn't know what kind of place this was. There was no flavor in any of the three pizzas we ordered. The best thing we ate was the fried ravioli. We've had pizza all over the states and I guess that has spoiled us. This was a quick dive into some mediocre food, nothing special or anything to rave about. Pictures can be deceiving on this one. I wouldn't recommend if you're looking for great pizza.

+8

Albert Casella

Normally we enjoy this place. However, recently there has been a lot of skimping. Here is an example - we paid extra to add ingredients and hardly got any… this is not worth the $30+ for a medium pizza, take your business elsewhere