American Eitel

When exploring around the seaport stop in for a quick bite to eat at Little Italy Pizzeria and Deli. Plenty of choices and the crispiest crusts of all the pizzas in NYC. Excellent. There is a also a nice inside area to sit and eat. No issues. Great pizza.

J. Mortola

Simply awesome, loved their CRUST, so many pizzas to choose from, i went with a slice of the vodka pie and they didnt disappoint... the cheese was very good, sauce was just as i expected... will visit again..

+2

Evie Hixenbaugh

Really some of the best pizza I have had the chicken parm pizza slice was a 10. This place may have a line but the employees are on a good system and I wasn’t waiting long. Will recommend will be back lol

Abhishek Bhati (Abhishek)

If you’re craving authentic New York-style pizza, look no further than Little Italy Pizza! Located in the heart of New York, this pizzeria delivers everything you’d expect from a classic slice and more. The crust is perfectly thin and crispy, yet has just the right amount of chewiness to hold up the generous toppings. Whether you’re a fan of a simple, cheesy Margherita or love piling on toppings like pepperoni and veggies, each slice is packed with flavor. The sauce is tangy, the cheese is gooey, and the fresh ingredients take it to the next level. One of the things I loved most is the welcoming, no-frills vibe of the place. It’s bustling with locals and tourists alike, and the staff is always friendly and quick with your order. Plus, they have an amazing variety – from classic pies to specialty options like white pizza or Grandma’s slice. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite on-the-go or sitting down for a casual meal, Little Italy Pizza never disappoints. If you’re a pizza lover in NYC, this place should be at the top of your list!

+2

Yulia Larin

Very friendly and kind people working in this pizzeria. Always fast, polite and respectful. Pizza is thin and crispy! Big choice. Love to take couple slices to go and eat by the pier 17 looking at the water and bridges 🌉 thank you for being open so late so we can get food after crazy party night 🥳🍕

Malcolm Jamal King

One of the best slices of pizza in the city. The Margherita Pizza was a perfect blend of gooey cheese and rich marinara. I don’t normally write reviews for spots. But this spot is a banger. 😊😋

Weltenbummler

Good service, paid 10,87$ for a Sicilian and a plain slice. You had opportunities to sit down and the slices very delicious.

Karel Kvita

Average pizza for low price. 2 slices + soda for 9$

+5

Frank

The pizza is made to perfection paper thin and crunchy full of flavor with each bite i highly do recommend stopping by for a slice of heaven.

+1

Nico Samneil Salado

Love their pizza compared to rosa’s pizza near penn station. They also got seating but tight spacing between tables. Their drink are fountain which is a plus. High chair not available. Credit/debit card could be used. No parking.

+1

Candice Tucker

I just ordered from here using Uber Eats. I wanted something cheap and quick. I regret this decision very much. I ordered a vodka slice which was dried out but ok. I also ordered a chicken ricotta slice that went straight into the trash. For starters, the crust was soggy and fell apart like a wet paper bag when I picked it up. There was also no discernible ricotta or chicken on it. I asked for spinach added… not realizing it was reconstituted frozen spinach that had just been thawed and thrown on there. This is unacceptable. How this place even got past 4 stars is beyond me. Never again. Domino’s would’ve been a better choice. And cheaper too.

Pizza is amazing!! But now this is the second time I’ve been called a name in a different language, my bf is bilingual and can’t understand what they saying and called them out for commenting on my appearance, no amount of yummy pizza is worth that lack of self respect

Corey Pisapia

Sadly, big time fan moving on here. Recently found that this location hides receipts, and doesn’t give refunds when orders are made wrong. I’ve been going there for six years and with one night of mean attitudes and shady answers regarding tips and receipts, I’ll be avoiding this business moving forward. Would’ve been a $10.00 refund. They also asked me to bring the old pizza back the next day. So here’s the proof I’ll be returning it in the box tomorrow.