Good pizza at a good price ready in under a half hour. Owner was friendly and proud of his establishment.

Absolutely the best pizza and spaghetti! Had a thin crust 3 meat. It was very good! Will be back !

Great service, great prices, great pizza! What a hidden gem! Don’t pass it up!

The best pizzas in Golden Triangle. Love this quaint little place. I've heard the pasta dishes are great also. I always get pizzas.

Good pizza.

Amazing food and very nice people

The most outrageously, phenomenal place to grab a homemade pizza for family dinner, lunch or munch..FYI..THEY HAVE MORE THAN JST PIZZA..#GOTTATRYITALL

Best pizza in southeast Texas and friendly people, eat it once and you are a customer for life

They go above and beyond for our Company. They have really good pizza too....I suggest getting the butter crust

Best pizza (especially the supreme combo on butter crust) and best muffeleta supreme ever! Love this place!

THE Best Muffuletta. BEST Pizza. Great family owned and operated business.

They are awesome and friendly and have great service and pizza! Well done goodfella's

Great pizza and great service! A great experience!

Friendly service, great pizza!

Very good pizza, large variety to choose from. We'll be back for sure !!

Eat here usually every weekend butter crust are two beautiful words that belong with each other.

Pizza was perfectly delicious! Plenty of toppings and cheese and the best buttery crust I've ever had. Very friendly staff and cozy dining area.

Awesome food. Everyone was friendly!!! Thanks

I've been going here my entire life it is the only pizza I will eat, They out pizza the hut ,They are little Ceasas Brutus, Dominoes falls before them in a line. Pepperoni black olives and bacon bits extra cheese light sauce 🫡

Absolutely amazing pizza, I have a gluten problem and They went out of their way to create a off menu item for my dietary restrictions. Would come back again, and again.

This pizza place is a staple in our tiny town for a reason! If you haven't tried it, do! They never disappoint.

Great family owned restaurant -- Chain pizza dosen't even begin to compare. Buttercrust is amazing. Been eating here for 20 years and it never disappoints.

Best pizza I've had in years. Worth the drive.

I’m so glad we stopped by and saw this place!! It was clean, the staff was friendly, and the food was delicious!!

Goodfella's came highly recommended. Pizza was fantastic. Owner was great. We will definitely be back again. Thank you for a great dinner.

Been going here since I was a kid 20 years ago. It’s still the best pizza in SE Texas.

Very good pizza, love the speciality pies. Service could be a little warmer, but overall great and would come back

Great pizza place. Owner is in there making most of the sauces in house. This place is definitely a must try

Very good pizza. Always visit here when we come to town.

Excellent place! Great pizza. Very happy to find it open on Sunday evening.

Service great!!! FOOD EXCELLENT!! WILL DRIVE FROM HARDIN COUNTY TO EAT HERE OFTEN! I WOULD RATE FOOD.. SERVICE...AND CLEANLINESS 💯!

Great pizza and cheese bread. We got a combo pizza and a pepperoni. Both were packed with toppings .

Quick Service, low price, and absolutely delicious. I had the Spaghetti and Meatballs soooo good! Cute little dining room too. Highly Recommend!

Finally stop in this place; pizza is very good and can be customized to one’s liking I was expecting with the name some Mobster movie posters, but the walls are bare

I was driving through and I read the reviews !! And I had to try the pizza …. Super good and the crust nice and yummy.

Goodfellas knocked it out of the park with this one! Thin crust, extra pep, extra bacon, sausage, well done. Mmph it was tasty!

Always a joy! Taco Pizza(one of my favorite) Butter crust....Cake, pizza, muffalettas, drinks, balloons, family, and fun!

Very tasty pizza you can tell dough and ingredients are very fresh owner and staff are very kind

Great pizza and prices. We had the butter crust. I highly recommend stopping here if you are in the Sour Lake area and need a bite to eat.

Loved the butter crust pizza but it took longer than normal to get a pizza when no one else was dining in

Best pizza in town get butter crust omg you'll LOVE IT ❤️

Our volleyball team decided to try this place going home from a game. We looked the reviews and they were great honestly looking at the building I wasn't sure. Once you step inside it's a very homey feel. The owners were so nice 30 minutes till close and they said they would stay open for us. We got a jumbo pepperoni, cheese bread and a salad it was all delicious. The garlic butter is so good too definitely try that when you go.

Best pizza hands down you will ever get in your life!!!!! Everything is truly fresh ingredients and amazing staff!!! Definitely reccomend!!!

I don't care where you live you need to drive out to Sour Lake and get some of this pizza! We have been told to do it for a year and finally did it... seriously mind blowingly good pizza. I couldn't believe how much flavor it had and the crust was so perfect thin but yet crispy and the crust was almost a little flaky the toppings were on point and big fat slices!

Small place with an old feel. Some of the best pizza I've ever had. We ordered a meat lover's style pizza (goodfellas has another name for it) with a butter crust. The crust was light and crunchy. Not like thin crust crunchy, just a subtle crunch to let you know it was cooked to perfection.

Pizza was absolutely amazing! It was piping hot, fresh, and delicious!! Passing through heading home to Baton Rouge and found this hidden gem! The jalapeno ranch was top notch.

Great atmosphere, delicious pizza

Best pizza so delicious. Great service and attention to quality is amazing. 👏

We aren't regulars at this restaurant but that's only because we live 300 miles away. Whenever we visit my stepson, we always plan on getting a pizza from Goodfella's. Great crust, perfect proportions of toppings, and a great price. If you are ever in Sour Lake and want a pizza, THIS is the place!

The food is good and the owners are so nice. They have the best pizza in town.

Best Pizza in SE Texas.

The owner was awesome, he recommended the pizza for first time customers it was the best I have had in years well worth the drive to go back again

This is some of the best pizza I have ever had! The butter crust supreme dipped in their jalapeno ranch is soooo good! The people are super nice too. Absolutely recommend 👍

Best pizza, and great service. Owner recognizes when he has long time customers and makes a point to thank them, or do nice gestures. good location, fair prices.

Great local family owned business w great service & even better food!

The BEAT pizza I have EVER eaten!!!! And very nice people!!!

A nice delightful little pizzeria! It has that family-owned charm. The pizza was delicious! It's great to travel around and taste different pizzas. This has got plenty of cheese and the sauces has a tiny sweetness to it. I crust was crunchy, about two times as thick as thin crust, Best of both worlds! I can't wait to go back and try other things on their menu.

What's not to love about this little place? It's quaint and clean. There's a little bouquet of fresh flowers on each table which instantly let me know these people care about their business. We ordered a thin crust multiple topping pizza. When it arrived at the table, I asked I asked the owner if we had received special treatment because it was our first time there. He told me that the pizzas come loaded just like the one he served us, every time. The pizza was delicious! Sour Lake is probably out of the way for most people but that doesn't matter. Go get you some of the best pizza you've probably ever had! Great service. Great food.

An absolute gem from the moment you walk in! While traveling through the area, I decided to stop by and was welcomed by a warm, friendly atmosphere that made me feel right at home. The staff was super attentive and genuinely passionate about ensuring every guest had a great experience. Now, let’s talk about the food—it was outstanding! They offer three types of crusts: thin, original, and butter. Each crust strikes the perfect balance of crispy, flavorful, or buttery, all loaded with fresh toppings and gooey, melty cheese. Whether you're craving a classic hearty meat lover's pizza or one of their specialty creations, like the Taco Pizza, you can't go wrong. The sauce has a rich, homemade taste sets it apart from the average pizzeria. Beyond the pizza, the rest of the menu is equally impressive. They serve bold pasta dishes, flavorful sandwiches, and delicious desserts in generous portions without sacrificing quality. Prices are reasonable, especially considering the quality and portion sizes. It’s clear they prioritize giving customers a fantastic meal at an excellent price. Whether grabbing a quick slice, enjoying a sit-down dinner with family, or picking up takeout, Goodfella’s is a place you’ll want to return to again and again. I highly recommend it!

Pretty good pizza, we had the thin crust and it was very good.. the reason I didn't give 5 stars, was because our salad was a little old. But, it was, and if we were back in the area, I'd stop for a bite.

Traveling north from Port Bolivar, we decided to stop at Goodfella's, and we were not disappointed!! The man who took our order was friendly. There were fresh flowers on all the tables that smelled lovely. My husband and I shared a medium butter crust white pizza with chicken. It was so good and cheesy!! We will definitely stop here again on our next trip south to the beach.

This place has the best homemade pizza that ive ever had the pleasure of eating. The place is clean and smells great! The pizza came out of the oven to the table. I cant say enough good stuff about it!! 7-17-22 im back and this awsome place is still exactly as it was!! Thank you guys so much for the great food and super service! The restroom is very clean also...

This little Gem of place has the best service! The owner is super sweet and the pizza looks amazing! Come and Support this business!!

Wide selection of pizza toppings, friendly service, clean, and some of the best small town pizza around. If you're passing through or new to town, definitely stop by and give them a try. Also, get the ranch!!!

A group of my friends went there for my b day after Bible Study and it was so good we had a s supreme pizza and the owner made me a apple pizza…

What a Gem! This guy knows Mozzarella 😋. The freshest ingredients! The bread ,warm and pillowy. Everything was wonderful even the salad! Fresh ,Fresh,Fresh!

Bob Franks

A nice delightful little pizzeria! It has that family-owned charm. The pizza was delicious! It's great to travel around and taste different pizzas. This has got plenty of cheese and the sauces has a tiny sweetness to it. I crust was crunchy, about two times as thick as thin crust, Best of both worlds! I can't wait to go back and try other things on their menu.

Sue Katzcradul

What's not to love about this little place? It's quaint and clean. There's a little bouquet of fresh flowers on each table which instantly let me know these people care about their business. We ordered a thin crust multiple topping pizza. When it arrived at the table, I asked I asked the owner if we had received special treatment because it was our first time there. He told me that the pizzas come loaded just like the one he served us, every time. The pizza was delicious! Sour Lake is probably out of the way for most people but that doesn't matter. Go get you some of the best pizza you've probably ever had! Great service. Great food.

The Maldonado’s

An absolute gem from the moment you walk in! While traveling through the area, I decided to stop by and was welcomed by a warm, friendly atmosphere that made me feel right at home. The staff was super attentive and genuinely passionate about ensuring every guest had a great experience. Now, let’s talk about the food—it was outstanding! They offer three types of crusts: thin, original, and butter. Each crust strikes the perfect balance of crispy, flavorful, or buttery, all loaded with fresh toppings and gooey, melty cheese. Whether you're craving a classic hearty meat lover's pizza or one of their specialty creations, like the Taco Pizza, you can't go wrong. The sauce has a rich, homemade taste sets it apart from the average pizzeria. Beyond the pizza, the rest of the menu is equally impressive. They serve bold pasta dishes, flavorful sandwiches, and delicious desserts in generous portions without sacrificing quality. Prices are reasonable, especially considering the quality and portion sizes. It’s clear they prioritize giving customers a fantastic meal at an excellent price. Whether grabbing a quick slice, enjoying a sit-down dinner with family, or picking up takeout, Goodfella’s is a place you’ll want to return to again and again. I highly recommend it!

JOHNJOHN “Spooki Boi” Montelongo

Pretty good pizza, we had the thin crust and it was very good.. the reason I didn't give 5 stars, was because our salad was a little old. But, it was, and if we were back in the area, I'd stop for a bite.

Anna Craig

Traveling north from Port Bolivar, we decided to stop at Goodfella's, and we were not disappointed!! The man who took our order was friendly. There were fresh flowers on all the tables that smelled lovely. My husband and I shared a medium butter crust white pizza with chicken. It was so good and cheesy!! We will definitely stop here again on our next trip south to the beach.

Ron Benoit

This place has the best homemade pizza that ive ever had the pleasure of eating. The place is clean and smells great! The pizza came out of the oven to the table. I cant say enough good stuff about it!! 7-17-22 im back and this awsome place is still exactly as it was!! Thank you guys so much for the great food and super service! The restroom is very clean also...

Catherine Fleetwood

This little Gem of place has the best service! The owner is super sweet and the pizza looks amazing! Come and Support this business!!

red beard

Wide selection of pizza toppings, friendly service, clean, and some of the best small town pizza around. If you're passing through or new to town, definitely stop by and give them a try. Also, get the ranch!!!

Believe in new beginnings

A group of my friends went there for my b day after Bible Study and it was so good we had a s supreme pizza and the owner made me a apple pizza…

BOHO

What a Gem! This guy knows Mozzarella 😋. The freshest ingredients! The bread ,warm and pillowy. Everything was wonderful even the salad! Fresh ,Fresh,Fresh!

This place is truly a hidden gem with amazing food. The Atmosphere, Food, and Service are above top notch. This place belongs with the best in the major cities. My family and I love there butter crust pizza.

Amazing pizza! The owner (I'm assuming) and his staff were very friendly and helpful. Will definitely visit again!

Warm atmosphere very mom and pop vibes. My husband and I had the pizza and it was by far some of the best pizza I have eaten. Prices where fair and people where nice. Definitely going back. I think I have found my new pizza place.

Im not one to wrote about my food. This pizza was amazing i wish i would have taken a picture of it. It was super cheesey and every bite was as good as the last. That garlic butter sauce is to die for!

First time eating at Goodfellas in Sour Lake, TX. Pizza was excellent-home made! Hot ham sandwich was incredible! Salad was basic but was very fresh. Loved the fresh flowers on tables. Service was great. Extremely friendly staff. I would give this restaurant 4 thumbs up if I had extra thumbs. Thank you Goodfellas! Keep up the delicious food!! 🥰

Great food super helpful and nice people even went out of there way to help my husband thank you so much

Kelli Wiggins

The BEAT pizza I have EVER eaten!!!! And very nice people!!!

Shawna Baker

Great food super helpful and nice people even went out of there way to help my husband thank you so much

Travis “Taz” Carpenter

Great local family owned business w great service & even better food!

Kira

Warm atmosphere very mom and pop vibes. My husband and I had the pizza and it was by far some of the best pizza I have eaten. Prices where fair and people where nice. Definitely going back. I think I have found my new pizza place.

james scott

Im not one to wrote about my food. This pizza was amazing i wish i would have taken a picture of it. It was super cheesey and every bite was as good as the last. That garlic butter sauce is to die for!

Belinda Hinojosa

First time eating at Goodfellas in Sour Lake, TX. Pizza was excellent-home made! Hot ham sandwich was incredible! Salad was basic but was very fresh. Loved the fresh flowers on tables. Service was great. Extremely friendly staff. I would give this restaurant 4 thumbs up if I had extra thumbs. Thank you Goodfellas! Keep up the delicious food!! 🥰

James Sharpe

This place is truly a hidden gem with amazing food. The Atmosphere, Food, and Service are above top notch. This place belongs with the best in the major cities. My family and I love there butter crust pizza.

Love the pizza, a little worried the ceiling is going to fall on me though.

Good pizza, they aren’t a firestone but it’s amazing for the area, expect to pay for refills, Staff is a little cold natured, but nice place to get a slice of pizza

Fast service, easy ordering and friendly staff. Pizza was a little dry, will make sure to request extra sauce next time.

Butter crust pizza is amazing! Cheese bread is great. Calzones, spaghetti, and dessert pizza is awesome too.

Great owner and staff, pizza and gyro excellent.

Pizza was delicious. The canned drink situation seemed odd. Great customer service.

It's a small venue with big flavor. I love love love their Muffalettas, and the pizza is good as well. Everything is made from scratch. And everything is clean and tidy. It's a nice place to stop by.

Nice little pizza place, pizza dough has flavor. This place isn't your cardboard tasting corner store pizza place.

We recently made the journey from Houston to Goodfellas restaurant. It was worth the drive as we found the food to be very tasty and meet our expectations. We shared both a muffaletta and a pepperoni pizza and both were top-notch. We highly recommend you stop by when in the area.

Its a decent little Italian place sitting on the outskirts of town. There menu has originality with the foods they prepare. I did try two dishes on 2 separate occasions and the Taco salad pizza looks awesome but has little to no flavor.. it was disappointing I do plan on trying it again in hopes that it was a fluke. 11.02.23 I've been back 2 more times 2nd time I tried there meatball sandwich very tasty. 3rd time I got the 18 inch pie with ham and pineapple. It was ok hot and fresh but the pizza sauce is bland needs some added flavor. Over all I like this place

Nextstopahead

We recently made the journey from Houston to Goodfellas restaurant. It was worth the drive as we found the food to be very tasty and meet our expectations. We shared both a muffaletta and a pepperoni pizza and both were top-notch. We highly recommend you stop by when in the area.

tommy Kohut

Its a decent little Italian place sitting on the outskirts of town. There menu has originality with the foods they prepare. I did try two dishes on 2 separate occasions and the Taco salad pizza looks awesome but has little to no flavor.. it was disappointing I do plan on trying it again in hopes that it was a fluke. 11.02.23 I've been back 2 more times 2nd time I tried there meatball sandwich very tasty. 3rd time I got the 18 inch pie with ham and pineapple. It was ok hot and fresh but the pizza sauce is bland needs some added flavor. Over all I like this place

Amazing pizza, best in the area, make sure you eat it hot, much better hot, don't let it cool down. Been eating here for over 30 years and as a local on a weekly basis. Don't be afraid to try some of the specialty pizzas, or other items on the menu, the mufulata is better than the ones you will find in Beaumont and will feed two or more. Get a desert pizza!!

Reduced from 5 stars from my review from 2 years prior. Went yesterday and the pizza was overcooked. The entire crust on the bottom was crunchy and much of the cheese was burned solid brown. This store is almost 2 hours from home so its disappointing to say this.

Really wanted to love this small town pizzeria. We came out 3 times to try it. Good stuff is worth the trek. We excitedly got here when they were open. Staff is super friendly. Fresh flowers really cute little place. We tried the spaghetti with meat sauce and meatballs and a pepperoni buttercrust pizza. The spaghetti had loads of wonderful flavor nice amount of garlic and cheese inside it also came with 2 breadsticks. My personal preference is a good ratio of sauce and pasta. This could use a bit more meat sauce. The pizza, half of it was good. The sauce was great, loads of pepperoni. Honestly, far more pepperoni than anywhere else I've been. The butter crust was delicious. I usually like a thinner crust but this was good. Very tasty. The only problem was 1/2 of it almoat had no cheese on it at all. Nobody wants a slice without cheese. So half will have to be doctored at home or thrown out and I hate the thought of wasting it. Would we drive 40 mins to have it again. Sadly. Truly very sad to say, No. But if I ever do happen by here again I would try again and I will order with extra cheese on the pizza and extra sauce on the spagetti. The price was fantastic. I really want this little place to thrive. It has the right recipes to do so. Give em a try I believe they are worth a shot.

Valorie Life is a highway

Really wanted to love this small town pizzeria. We came out 3 times to try it. Good stuff is worth the trek. We excitedly got here when they were open. Staff is super friendly. Fresh flowers really cute little place. We tried the spaghetti with meat sauce and meatballs and a pepperoni buttercrust pizza. The spaghetti had loads of wonderful flavor nice amount of garlic and cheese inside it also came with 2 breadsticks. My personal preference is a good ratio of sauce and pasta. This could use a bit more meat sauce. The pizza, half of it was good. The sauce was great, loads of pepperoni. Honestly, far more pepperoni than anywhere else I've been. The butter crust was delicious. I usually like a thinner crust but this was good. Very tasty. The only problem was 1/2 of it almoat had no cheese on it at all. Nobody wants a slice without cheese. So half will have to be doctored at home or thrown out and I hate the thought of wasting it. Would we drive 40 mins to have it again. Sadly. Truly very sad to say, No. But if I ever do happen by here again I would try again and I will order with extra cheese on the pizza and extra sauce on the spagetti. The price was fantastic. I really want this little place to thrive. It has the right recipes to do so. Give em a try I believe they are worth a shot.

Was told our pizza would be ready in 25 to 30 minutes and after we got there had to wait another 24 minutes

Sandwiches are over priced would of been better off going to subway. Why would anyone put lettuce on meatballs sub never ask just wouldof expect Peppers not lettuce

Bad, bad, bad pizza. The real Goodfellas would’ve (insert bad joke) put a hit out on the guy who made this pizza. Easily comparable to the Huntz Brothers gas station pizza. The ingredients were sub par quality. The dough was terribly chewy and the crust was actually inedible. We bought two specialty pizzas and threw them both away. I could’ve taken cash from my pocket and thrown it to the ground and walked away and it would’ve been put to better use than the Goodfellas Pizza went spent it on. You’ll know good pizza after you’ve had pizza this bad.

Phone number does not work. Called several times and once someone answered but then hung up and blocked my call. Pizza looked good from the pic but no way to call ahead for a yo go order

i’m sorry this food was dried out. We ordered two big pizzas one Zumbo and one with onions and bacon bits. It was nasty. No flavor to it. Never will eat here again. Disgusting for almost $60 worth and we don’t even live out here.