Karissa Breuer

Cayuga Lake Creamery was one of our vendors at my wedding this past July and it was definitely one of the highlights of our day! We opted for a full sundae station so people could choose flavors and customize what they wanted. The owners were wonderful to work with and made everything so easy and straightforward even when we wanted to change up the flavors. On the night of our wedding, I went for the Sea Salt Caramel and it was some of the most satisfyingly creamy and delicious ice cream I have ever had! My dad used to take me to their Interlaken location so it also had the nostalgia factor but somehow it tasted even better than I remembered. People were raving about it! My husband and I stayed in Ithaca the week after and made a point to go to their location in the Dewitt Mall as well and it was well worth it. Cayuga Lake Creamery is some of the best ice cream around!

Hurcombbaby

Love the ice cream here . Picked up my container ( 2.5 gallons) of Purple Cow . Its cost effective to buy in bulk. They also sell 6 quart containers. Make sure you get on their rewards program.

Sarah Drumheller

Decent variety of flavors. Hours of operation change unexpectedly. Service is slow and often poor, as in you might need to open the service window and call out to get someone's attention to get served. Or, if you and a friend order at the same time, your order might come out in some strange mashup and you will have to ask to have it remade. It is a nice thing to have in such a small town.

Lauren Alfano

I’ve been coming to this place on vacation since I was a kid. We used to go every night during our week long lake trip. It’s always had a very nostalgic place in my heart. Coming back after many years was unfortunately not what I remembered. To start off it was extremely expensive. It was $17 for my husband and I to get two single scoops in a cone. Which is bad enough, but then the gave us the wrong waffle cone without sprinkles (which we paid $2 for) They did fix it however it seems like they are struggling with distracted/unmotivated staff.

Andrew VanBortel

Brought my 3 childrens for Father's Day this year. We've gotten ice cream here many times before, but this time we got burgers (one order of fries) a vanilla shake, and then waffle cones (for those of us who didn't get a shake). The burgers were tasty, and personally I love the home-churned ice cream, but the price! is what keeps CLC from getting that 5th star. Definitely five star service and cleanliness though.

Farhan Fuad Abir

If you are craving for ice creams on the way, it can be good stop. The flavors are okay; nothing special.

Ornwara Tritrakarn

The size is crazy! I wouldn't expect kiddie size to be this huge. But well, considering its price ($5.62), I guess it makes sense! This "no doze," coffee with expresso-coated chocolate bits flavour was great! It was unsurprisingly a little too sweet for my liking. But the expresso-coated chocolate bits were so good. They add interesting texture to the ice-cream. The waffle cone was delicious too. Services is okay but they don't allow dogs inside. We could sit outside today because it wasn't too cold. But if you come here on a really cold day (which are coming soon), you probably want to keep you dog in the car.

Carrie Jeanne

The service itself was fine, the staff were welcoming and friendly but the prices and quality left much to be desired- $8.25 for a single scoop of blueberry cheesecake ice cream that had zero blueberry flavor in a rubbery, stale waffle cone. Very disappointing.

Mary Chatz

We stopped here for an ice cream after our dinner on a Sunday night. It was just before closing. The icecrean was just OK... it didn't taste like homemade and I think it was overpriced.

+2

Mary L White

Their ice cream is pretty good. But their staffing is inconsistent. On Wednesday evening 7/23/25 we checked the website and it said they were open to 9pm. So we drove up there, arrived just after 8:30, but well before 9 we thought. The person in the store refused to serve us, said that they had everything cleaned up and put away. This behavior is, at the least, offensive. This is not my idea of good business practice. We will not be going back there at any time of the day or evening.