Order pick up. Although sat at rhe bar for happy hour dinks and my fav magaritas Love it

Great little unassuming hidden local gem. Came here by accident looking for another place and was happy it happened. Drinks were made with fresh squeezed juices and the food felt authentic. Met the family that owns and runs the restaurant who were very accommodating. Would definitely recommend!

Fantastic menu!! Covers everything and everyone!! So reasonably priced, especially in these hard times. Awesome food!! Golden gem in Staten Island. Met a couple from San Antonio who said it was the best Mexican food they have had in NYC. WHAT AN ENDORSEMENT!!

Ron Abenante

Want to extend our most sincere compliments to the owners and the entire staff of Piccolinos for their hosting of a wonderful holiday party last night. From start to finish, the staff was incredibly professional, courteous and attentive to a large ( and sometimes challenging) group. The food was excellent in every regard and served promptly and professionally by a relatively small staff. There was excellent entertainment provided as well ( thank you Teresa🙏) and a good time was had by all!⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Susan Young

Excellent dinner from start to finish! The salmon with the lemon brandy sauce was superb as was the fillet of sole francaise. The Zucchini stick appetizer was cooked perfectly and the cheesecake was so fresh and light. It was amazing. Everything down to the cappuccino was perfection. Our server Enzo was excellent and the singer was a lot of fun. Can’t wait to come back!

Jim Cantwell

Great night out with a large group. Service, Food and Drinks were excellent. Never rushed and food wad delivered in a timely fashion. Well worth the money 👍

Ellen Gottfried

Tucked into an unassuming strip mall, Piccolino's serves excellent food and has attentive service. My husband and I ordered from the luncheon specials menu, and each of the three courses was delicious, well presented and generous. This is a great restaurant and you will be happy you came here for a meal.

Jaxx

10/10 hidden gem! Went for my 45th birthday with my family and we were blown away with everything, what an experience! Food , next level. Service, top tier! Atmosphere, quaint and cozy! They even had live entertainment. What a pleasure to be there, can’t wait to go back. Thank you Piccolino’s for an excellent night.

Robby Fitz

I’ve been coming here for years but I hosted my son’s baptism in their back room last night. This place really knows how to take care of you. The food is fantastic, the staff is awesome, and everything is timed just right so your guests always have something hot and tasty in front of them. Highly recommend for pretty much anything. I’ve had romantic dates with the wife here, I’ve come for family dinners, and now I can say I’ve hosted a party here.

Elizabeth Bracker

The food here is delicious!! We got the Polo Martine and Fettuccine Alfredo. We ended up having leftovers and switching dishes. Both dishes were flavorful. We will order again.

Brigid Le Minez

We had a fantastic meal in this authentic Italian restaurant and look forward to returning.

Kathleen W

My family & I had dinner here for the first time on a Saturday night in October. I can’t believe I never heard of this place before! I’ve been missing a lot! My family felt the same! The food was absolutely superb! Service was great. Ambience was really nice, especially with the two very talented singers performing that night. I took home leftovers & enjoyed them the next night. We will definitely be back for our next event! In my opinion this is the best Italian restaurant on the island! A+++++++

Dani Scarcella

Just had my son’s communion in the outdoor room and it was perfect. They let me set up / decorate the entire room the way I wanted, were fine with me having a large balloon arch with a hoop and entertainers for the kid. The food was amazing and the unlimited sangria/wine was a good choice! My family is still talking about it. The staff was accomodating, even with 2 other parties going on at the same time. They had heaters to warm the room up once it got cold. 10/10. Highly recommend!

Ekaterina Sitnikova

Incredibly delicious and beautiful 💖 Wonderful outside tables with heaters, music and Christmas decorations (we had a dog with us). Thank you so much for our dinner and top-notch service!

Thomas P Smith NY REAL ESTATE

HIDDEN GEM! Located in the heart of great kills town Staten Island NY tucked away in the corner of a parking lot. Great service, great portions, and outstanding food. I put this place in top 5 on the island. Food is always cooked fresh and the combination of how they put it together just work. Sometimes this place doesn’t have a seat available so call and check.we always go big here cause food is so good but you can get your money’s worth for sure.

+9

david stein

Excellent italian food. We had a party of 6. Everyone enjoyed. I cose from the prix fixe menu. Penne ala vodka as an app, chicken marsala for the main and canoli for desert. Others had fish and chicken parm for their meals.

Ladi Dre

Beautiful atmosphere. Amazing food. Strong drinks. Only one waiter though, yet somehow he made it work, but still would say need more waiters.

+2

Michelle Hernandez

Great service. Amazing food. Great atmosphere! Plus live music by amazing musicians on Friday Nights. This place is truly an unknown gem in Staten Island!

The Cubano sandwich was incredibly tasty. Highly recommend it. Also really liked the Iguana tacos. Rest of the tacos were normal Mexican flare. We had a pitcher of the passion fruit margarita. It was good.

I'd seen this place around for a while now and it is quite big, with an outdoor space adjacent to the lot behind the next door lim service building. They had recently done up their exterior. The interior remains festive and lit with loud music and televisions showing sports, usually. It's a convenient location near the train stop and also right off Amboy. I came for a bite later at night after work and there were only two waiters running the floors. It wasn't empty and there were perhaps two louder parties, one at the bar and one at the tables. So service felt a little sparse. The food was mediocre but priced reasonably for the portions. It will fill you up. The gambas de ajillo were served lukewarm on a plate, contrary to how they would usually be served in hot oil. The pork skin quesadilla was filled abundantly with boiled pork skin. Do not order this if you are expecting a crunchy chicharron. The meat was well flavored, but the tortilla used was very thick. It held together well, though, and was expectedly filling. The sangria they have was a bit lacking in much punch of flavor. Overall, not a bad place to satisfy some cravings.

The only reason for 4 stars is there’s a funky mold smell at this place. But other than that, food and service is great and the best rice and BEANS I’ve had it’s delicious and taste so good from other Mexican restaurants I’ve eaten. This place is kind of a hidden gem and I’ve been wanting to go here but, every-time I see it from outside it is not inviting at all and or doesn’t look like it’s open or shady not sure why it’s like that. But once your inside, WOW! Finally went in this time around so very happy that I did. I just wish the smell improves but ones your inside, I guess you’ll get used it. I love that they have outdoor too. Btw, they only have 4 parking spot and could be double parking if you have two cars with your friend but, someone parked right in front of me and I wouldn’t be able to get out if the one next to me didn’t move but, it worked out lol. Overall, affordable and very good food loved it!

Very nice Mexican restaurant. It has a varied menu, very good service and prices are reasonable.

Roxy Ruiz

Food is great, all 3 plates order was fabulous!!! The presentation definitely was great. Atmosphere is very nice. Services is not the best. The place was not busy, 3 tables plus use and we felt forgotten. I order the unlimited drinks and just to get a refill took for every. So if you are not in a hurry, go for it!

Analia Gerard

The food is the star here. Everything is just delicious and plentiful. My husband ordered the prix fixe osso bucco and mussels. Yum. I had barolo meat, which was stacked with yummy veggie layers. Had leftovers today and I swear, it’s even better. Here, you get plenty of bang for the buck. The hard part is parking, but there is municipal across the street - very convenient. And, the shopping plaza plus the leftover pandemic outdoor add on is not very welcoming, especially on a rainy day. Nevertheless, we loved it here and can’t wait to come back again.

Elizabeth Matteo

This is the second time dining here. We ordered from the prefix menu with the main entree being chicken cutlet parm and a pork chop with hot peppers. The chicken cutlet parm was just okay but the pork chop with hot peppers was excellent. We also had house salad, mussels fra diavolo and spaghetti aioli which were all delicious. Staff were attentive and pleasant. The only thing that bothered me was the ceiling tiles which look like they need to be replaced at some point. Parking is also Limited. I would definitely go back again.

Katie Angelova

The food is excellent here. Drinks are reasonably priced. However, it tends to get crowded on the weekends, and even with a reservation, you may get seated in a less than ideal spot.

I got the chicken enchilada, comes with rice and beans. My friend got grilled fish, also came with rice and beans. The sangria was tasty but we needed an extra shot in it to make it work. The food was fresh but too bland. The atmosphere is nice. We sat outside

Party of 14 for my brothers birthday dinner at 6pm. Didn’t want to ruin my appetite so I didn’t eat all day looking forward to eat here. Arrived and quickly ordered the mezcal margarita and the best part of the evening. Margarita gets 4 stars. We ordered the calamari, chips and guacamole as starter. Calamari was bland and was like chewing on fried flour bitters. The guac needed salt,lime, and cilantro.cause it was also bland. When a Mexican restaurant can’t get the guac right says a lot about their food and a warning of what’s to come or expect. I ordered the shrimp fajita and to be honest it was decent after I added some salt cause it lacked flavor. Looking around the table and other families expression of their food they were not impressed. This establishment is a solid 3 stars but they lost another star for their service. One element I noticed here is that service, the waiter and servers were kids. I asked one of them how old he was he was and he said 16. I respect and commend kids wanting to work and establishments giving them the opportunity, but not on a Saturday night. How much experience can a 16 year have when asked for recommendations, not that I did. There were other staff that were older walking around from table to table kind off supervising. Not a place that left me wanting to come back.

Patrick Laine

I’ve been a few times now and haven’t been satisfied. Tried giving it the benefit of the doubt ordering a few different things but everything tastes bland that I’ve had. Numerous italian restaurants on the island are better than this

I went here with my family recently, and the experience was honestly disappointing from start to finish. We were seated quickly, but it went downhill after that. Our server seemed more interested in chatting with coworkers than taking care of our table. We had to ask multiple times just to get water refills, and when the food finally came out, one of the orders was wrong. Instead of apologizing, the server gave us an attitude like it was our fault. My parents were shocked at how unprofessional it was, it made the whole meal uncomfortable. Definitely not somewhere I’d bring family again. The staff clearly don’t care about the customers. Save your money and go literally anywhere else.