Spicy Pizza

Deniz Tunc

I'm a kid, and this place is where my favorite cake is made; Tres Leches cake, which not even my parents can recreate due to its' taste. If you haven't gone here yet, you haven't fully lived.

Amy Laemmerhirt

Always so tasty, fresh and fast. The guys that work there are super nice. I’ve only ever gotten the cheese pizza by the slice, but it’s so consistently good I haven’t branched out yet.

Marcia Lewis

Best pizza ever, it’s our to go pizza place. Their marinara sauce is very addicting where you can finish the whole pizza in one sitting. Their portion sizes are worth what you pay for.

Nikki

I looove this place. I'm obsessed with their calzones. They're absolutely LOADED with cheese and so delicious. The staff is really friendly and efficient, and their pizza is reliably tasty!

Henry J

I can't say enough good things about this place. It's my go to whenever I'm in the neighborhood. It blows my mind that they even remember my typical orders when they may only see me once every week or two at best due to my busy schedule(granted I've been coming here for 10 years now) . I can barely remember what I had for dinner a week ago and despite the hundreds of customers they get somehow remember my order. I love the vibe from the whole crew, just your average joes making some neighborhood pizza.

Robert Bennett

Damn good slice of pizza. Antipasto salad, while not the best I've had, was above average. Garlic 'knots' were great. All of the above, with 2 big slices and a glass-bottle coke was $18.

4.6/5 rating. Food in spicy pizza is very good. I wouldn’t say fully Italian cuisine but it’s still good and the service is good!

Thin gummy crust under the topping. Crust edge is fairly crispy and chewy, with a good flavor. Overcooked bottom, combined with undercooked top. Adequate coverage of cheese and sauce. And okay slice, but nothing to look forward to. I'll give it an 84.

Michelle

4.6/5 rating. Food in spicy pizza is very good. I wouldn’t say fully Italian cuisine but it’s still good and the service is good!

Gary Wilson

Thin gummy crust under the topping. Crust edge is fairly crispy and chewy, with a good flavor. Overcooked bottom, combined with undercooked top. Adequate coverage of cheese and sauce. And okay slice, but nothing to look forward to. I'll give it an 84.

The pastas need a little more flavor, a little on the bland side. Pizza is fine, service is good. Staff friendly . Phone goes on the blink sometimes,no one picks up? The chicken wrap is nice.

David Mahon

The pastas need a little more flavor, a little on the bland side. Pizza is fine, service is good. Staff friendly . Phone goes on the blink sometimes,no one picks up? The chicken wrap is nice.

Had an OK experience with this one. Ordered through seamless for lunch while i was working from home. Meatball parm hero was bland - meatballs were not tasty - they reminded me of a grade school school lunch. The sauce tasted processed and not homemade. You can buy sauce in a jar that tastes 1000% better. I actually put some alla vodka sauce of my own on this that I had in my fridge to revive it - did not do the trick. Pepperoni Calzone was pretty good...didn't come with marinara to dip in...not sure if that was a mistake or if they just don't give you anything to dip the calzone into...maybe that was a blessing in disguise considering the sauce that came on the meatball parm hero, but a quick marinara should really be served with calzone...if it's tasty. I rated it 3 stars because it was priced reasonably, showed up on time, and didn't entirely drop the ball in terms of quality. I've grown to learn the hard lesson that in an urban area, restaurants that say the deliver to your address don't always, and sometimes leave you hanging for 10-60minutes thinking your food is being prepared/delivered when it is actually being cancelled by the restaurant because they don't feel like delivering to you...though they make seamless's customer service break the news to you and offer you seamless bucks...like you even want to use the service knowing how irresponsible many of the restaurants featured actually are. ANYWAY, this wasn't the case with Spicy Pizza, they are reliable, and to me at this point, that's half the battle.

Local go to place when in the area. Not great pizza, but very good burgers, fries and wraps! Great prices, fast service.

Kelly Paulsen

Had an OK experience with this one. Ordered through seamless for lunch while i was working from home. Meatball parm hero was bland - meatballs were not tasty - they reminded me of a grade school school lunch. The sauce tasted processed and not homemade. You can buy sauce in a jar that tastes 1000% better. I actually put some alla vodka sauce of my own on this that I had in my fridge to revive it - did not do the trick. Pepperoni Calzone was pretty good...didn't come with marinara to dip in...not sure if that was a mistake or if they just don't give you anything to dip the calzone into...maybe that was a blessing in disguise considering the sauce that came on the meatball parm hero, but a quick marinara should really be served with calzone...if it's tasty. I rated it 3 stars because it was priced reasonably, showed up on time, and didn't entirely drop the ball in terms of quality. I've grown to learn the hard lesson that in an urban area, restaurants that say the deliver to your address don't always, and sometimes leave you hanging for 10-60minutes thinking your food is being prepared/delivered when it is actually being cancelled by the restaurant because they don't feel like delivering to you...though they make seamless's customer service break the news to you and offer you seamless bucks...like you even want to use the service knowing how irresponsible many of the restaurants featured actually are. ANYWAY, this wasn't the case with Spicy Pizza, they are reliable, and to me at this point, that's half the battle.

Lynne Patterson

Local go to place when in the area. Not great pizza, but very good burgers, fries and wraps! Great prices, fast service.

So here’s the issue, the pizza is good and it’s only two blocks away. Been here since I was in elementary. I tell my boyfriend every time how much I appreciate them never over charging and the sauce Is great. I usually get the pizza to go but today my boyfriend and I decided to eat there figured it’s cold out and it was just two slices and a soda. He gave them his card which they kept trying to charge only to find out they were out of paper and so it wasn’t printing. He then said it was declined so I gave them my card. So as we get to the store next door to pick up some groceries we realize we both have been charged. We go back and tell them and the short skinny guy who did the transaction sits there acting lost. We show them look we both were charged and he said no the first payment was declined. Mind you it’s still pending so my bf and I leave and figured tomorrow when it clears. Then we got home it was cleared and we call back and explain that we come there regularly and this is just not good business he says come back, then when he goes back they act like we must have made a mistake with the proof on out bank transactions. SMH. And not to mention My bf tips them every time!! I can’t believe over this we have to find a different place in the neighborhood. Pls be aware if you pay with card to check your transactions it seems to be a problem here. Or just pay cash.

Most pizza places are hit or miss, sometimes it's very good. Other times sause is too sweet, cheese is too chewy or falling off the slice, bottom seemingly dead dough.

Kalaya Sky

So here’s the issue, the pizza is good and it’s only two blocks away. Been here since I was in elementary. I tell my boyfriend every time how much I appreciate them never over charging and the sauce Is great. I usually get the pizza to go but today my boyfriend and I decided to eat there figured it’s cold out and it was just two slices and a soda. He gave them his card which they kept trying to charge only to find out they were out of paper and so it wasn’t printing. He then said it was declined so I gave them my card. So as we get to the store next door to pick up some groceries we realize we both have been charged. We go back and tell them and the short skinny guy who did the transaction sits there acting lost. We show them look we both were charged and he said no the first payment was declined. Mind you it’s still pending so my bf and I leave and figured tomorrow when it clears. Then we got home it was cleared and we call back and explain that we come there regularly and this is just not good business he says come back, then when he goes back they act like we must have made a mistake with the proof on out bank transactions. SMH. And not to mention My bf tips them every time!! I can’t believe over this we have to find a different place in the neighborhood. Pls be aware if you pay with card to check your transactions it seems to be a problem here. Or just pay cash.

Debbie Curry

Most pizza places are hit or miss, sometimes it's very good. Other times sause is too sweet, cheese is too chewy or falling off the slice, bottom seemingly dead dough.

This place is garbage ! Please don’t go there !. They denied me service the other day because I walked in with my “registered by the state service dog”. Which is completely illegal for them to deny me service because of my dog and my medical condition. Called the police on them but i just decided to not bother and left. Lost a good customer $$$$$.

For about the last week I've been ordering a large pepperoni pizza from Spicy Pizza. My son has been craving Pizza. And it was delivered quickly, the price was within reason. And he liked the pizza. Last night I decided to order pasta with the pizza. Since we had had such a good experience. Okay this was not a good experience. It was delivered on time, great. The pizza was good. But, the pasta was disgusting. I ordered spaghetti with meat sauce. Extra sauce. I guess there was something extra with the sauce but it appeared to be all water. And the sauce had a sickly sweet taste. I only saw two tiny little chunks of meat. So, tonight I was getting ready to order a pizza again because he's on a pizza frenzy. And I complained about the pasta and Asked speak to the supervisor. This person on the phone wanted to know why I didn't call immediately and complain. He wanted to know what time I ordered the food. I told him around 7:00 p.m. I didn't realize I had to call immediately to complain.The food is still in my refrigerator I could give it to them right now. The person I spoke to was insulting and rude. They never even asked what was the matter with the pasta. They just got extremely aggressive on the phone. So, I told him I'd been ordering pizza on almost a daily basis. And I just wouldn't be ordering from them anymore if this was the way they wanted to behave. It's a shame because my son really liked the pizza

DO NOT eat here. This pizzeria conducts illegal fraudulent activity. On two separate occasions they have waited until the last days of the month to slide in fraudulent charges on my credit card so that it clears for them in time. I kindly went back to the pizzeria and asked for a void, they refused to refund me for charges I didn’t make. As a result I had to order a new credit card. There are too many good pizzerias in NYC to waste your time at a place that will collect your credit card number and steal your money.

Delivery wise, pretty quick and nice person. Food wise, it's worst food of the year for me. The pizza was burnt and the amount of salt in the sausage was insane. The pasta was hard and chicken tasted like rubber, I had food poisoning be later that evening. This place needs a serious hygiene review but what a bad experience.

Second time in a row I placed an order over the phone and when I showed up in the exact time frame they gave me, they did not make it. Thus, making me wait an additional 20 minutes. They’re always looking at each other clueless, completely spaced out and have no clue I even ordered. I ordered a third time a very simple single order and the skinny guy with glasses was like uhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh what do you want? A few times before actually understanding what I wanted. Which was weird cause I was ordering straight from THEIR menu.

Anthony Fraietta

DO NOT eat here. This pizzeria conducts illegal fraudulent activity. On two separate occasions they have waited until the last days of the month to slide in fraudulent charges on my credit card so that it clears for them in time. I kindly went back to the pizzeria and asked for a void, they refused to refund me for charges I didn’t make. As a result I had to order a new credit card. There are too many good pizzerias in NYC to waste your time at a place that will collect your credit card number and steal your money.

Maureen Ramgattie

Second time in a row I placed an order over the phone and when I showed up in the exact time frame they gave me, they did not make it. Thus, making me wait an additional 20 minutes. They’re always looking at each other clueless, completely spaced out and have no clue I even ordered. I ordered a third time a very simple single order and the skinny guy with glasses was like uhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh what do you want? A few times before actually understanding what I wanted. Which was weird cause I was ordering straight from THEIR menu.

Lisa Bradshaw

For about the last week I've been ordering a large pepperoni pizza from Spicy Pizza. My son has been craving Pizza. And it was delivered quickly, the price was within reason. And he liked the pizza. Last night I decided to order pasta with the pizza. Since we had had such a good experience. Okay this was not a good experience. It was delivered on time, great. The pizza was good. But, the pasta was disgusting. I ordered spaghetti with meat sauce. Extra sauce. I guess there was something extra with the sauce but it appeared to be all water. And the sauce had a sickly sweet taste. I only saw two tiny little chunks of meat. So, tonight I was getting ready to order a pizza again because he's on a pizza frenzy. And I complained about the pasta and Asked speak to the supervisor. This person on the phone wanted to know why I didn't call immediately and complain. He wanted to know what time I ordered the food. I told him around 7:00 p.m. I didn't realize I had to call immediately to complain.The food is still in my refrigerator I could give it to them right now. The person I spoke to was insulting and rude. They never even asked what was the matter with the pasta. They just got extremely aggressive on the phone. So, I told him I'd been ordering pizza on almost a daily basis. And I just wouldn't be ordering from them anymore if this was the way they wanted to behave. It's a shame because my son really liked the pizza

Javier Ruiz

This place is garbage ! Please don’t go there !. They denied me service the other day because I walked in with my “registered by the state service dog”. Which is completely illegal for them to deny me service because of my dog and my medical condition. Called the police on them but i just decided to not bother and left. Lost a good customer $$$$$.

Jay Singh

Delivery wise, pretty quick and nice person. Food wise, it's worst food of the year for me. The pizza was burnt and the amount of salt in the sausage was insane. The pasta was hard and chicken tasted like rubber, I had food poisoning be later that evening. This place needs a serious hygiene review but what a bad experience.