Fatman's Pizza
Pizza · Tonawanda
Sobre Fatman's Pizza
Fatman's Pizza in Tonawanda is a local favorite known for its consistently delicious food and friendly service. We offer a welcoming atmosphere for lunch, dinner, or a late-night bite, with options for dine-in, takeout, delivery, and curbside pickup. Our menu features comfort food classics, with a s...
Fatman's Pizza in Tonawanda is a local favorite known for its consistently delicious food and friendly service. We offer a welcoming atmosphere for lunch, dinner, or a late-night bite, with options for dine-in, takeout, delivery, and curbside pickup. Our menu features comfort food classics, with a special emphasis on our signature pizzas. Customers rave about the flavorful pizzas with a thick, yet crunchy crust, and the option to customize with a sweeter sauce. Don't miss the popular cup and char pepperoni and the innovative monthly specials. Many appreciate the wheelchair accessible entrance and parking.
Què diuen els clients de Fatman's Pizza
Fatman's Pizza is known for its thick-crust pizza with sweet sauce and generous toppings like cup & char pepperoni. The stinger subs and stuffed Hungarian peppers are also popular. Service is generally fast and friendly, though parking can be tricky.
Plats populars
Ideal per a
Tip: The sauce is sweeter than most, so it's recommended if you like sweet sauce. Pre-ordering take out is a good idea.
Services
Què veure a prop
Dades de Wikidata
Preguntes freqüents sobre Fatman's Pizza
Opinions de Fatman's Pizza Tonawanda
Fat Mans being a locally owned pizzeria provides excellent food with a very warm atmosphere when you go in. They pay close attention to the customer and their needs. I have always had a great experience there.
Ordered subs. Takeout. Asked for veg on the side. Subs were great. Everything, except meat & cheese was on the side so ladies could help themselves. Delivery was early. Thank you.
Always a great experience. I appreciate the creative specials every month. I continue to look forward to see what they come up with next! Highly recommend.
Food and service is always the best! I’ve never had a complaint in all the years I’ve been dealing with them.
Love the pizza the price got 2 large 3 days ago 1/3/2026 both eaten in 6 hours definitely, the sauce and cheese are my favorite
We did take out while on vacation, BEST PIZZA EVER! HONEY DRIZZLE SRIRACHA PIZZA IVE EVER HAD 💯!! FOOD AND SERVICE WERE BOTH AMAZING! THANK YOU!
Fatman’s Is consistently the best! Friendly service, amazing food, and each food item better than the next. The sauce is sweeter so would 10/10 always recommend if that’s what you’re looking for. Wings are crispy and the sauce is perfect. Also, the bleu cheese …. Chefs kiss
Jeff and Crew always make sure that your experience, and your taste buds, are well catered too! Fat Man’s is a staple of our family and will be for years to come! The monthly specials also give a big added bonus to make sure you never feel like you’re chosing “the same old” even with such a large menu!
I pre-ordered take out and the food was ready for pick up on time. The food was still hot when we got it home. We'll definitely order again.
**Another edit - tried the chicken finger calzone, and it did NOT disappoint! Made with the blue cheese inside is definitely the proper way. Thank you to the chef from last night (12/9/25)! That hit every craving for me, best of both worlds! First time trying this place, not going to be the last! We had a hankering for some calzones, and this dude brought some of the best I've had. The dough was cooked perfectly to my preference, slathered with an exquisite garlic oil. The ratio of mozzarella to ricotta was perfect! The pepperoni is top shelf, and has a great bite. Sautéed onions are next level! Everything seemed fresh, everything was undeniably delicious. Only critique is that a couple of the calzones needed better topping distribution, the corner pieces were mostly cheese. Not an issue, will definitely be back. Update! Been back several times, never a disappointment. They even made an off-menu fried bologna calzone, it was amazing! Can't go wrong with FatMans!
Great pizza and subs. Their pizza crust and sauce is top notch. Only negative is getting in and out of parking lot.
Fantastic!! Stopped in before Bills game and was greeted immediately by friendly staff. The pizza was perfectly prepared with delicious cup & char pepperoni. Highly Recommended!!
Great stinger subs and if you like spicy food try their stuffed Hungarian peppers. A big portion and it was excellent
We got the poor man's lasagna Pizza and let me just say it was absolutely amazing 👏 Definitely ordering again!
Fast and friendly service, good prices, and the pizza was fantastic! The sauce is a little sweeter than most which we loved. We’ll be back!
Great pizza and service!! Pizza has a thick but crunchy crust. We got pepperoni and mushrooms. The pep is crispy, and the mushrooms are large and fresh. The garlic marinara sauce is excellent and there's a perfect amount of cheese also. The 2 fellas behind the counter were extremely friendly and even offered up a spatula so we could serve our pizza (it's a to go place but we ate at the inside table as we live out of the area). Highly recommended!!
HANDS DOWN the absolute very BEST pizza on the PLANET!!! Buried in the Buffalo snow? Healing a broken heart? Want a break from the endless tire of working away behind the stove for a few days? Do you want to have a baby without actually having a baby? ¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿? Order a meatlover tray from Fatman's Pizza. Lived in Chicago for 3 years and had all the deep dish my heart wanted or could physically handle. Also lived near Toronto, D.C., and been to Italy... there is no better, fully loaded, belly stuffing, and craving satisfying meat lover pizza than a FULL TRAY MEATLOVER pizza from Fatman's. Tips on sauce/topping choices: The women (and men) in my life "love love love" Fatman's sweet marinara sauce, and I'd be letting you down if I didn't also say that their standard tomato marinara is one of the best marinara sauces around. Don't order extra sauce or toppings... it's called Fatman's pizza for a reason! I am not exaggerating when I say that a full tray weighs more than my 3.5 year old boy... Just do yourself a favor and indulge. Give your tummy one of the greatest gifts that you can give it, and do not look back (definitely do not look at the scale). You'll thank me for this review, later. You're welcome, I'm just a vessel in God's plans for you.
Ordered this today for the second time and we got a large cheese and pep well done with sweet sauce, extra sauce and extra cheese. Pizza was flavorful and made to our specifications. We also ordered some Cajun Honey butter bbq wings and honey BBQ fingers as well. The blue cheese it came with was amazing. The wings blew me away as I usually don't expect so much from pizzeria wings but they really over delivered in terms of quality and flavor. They could be larger would be my only complaint but they were cooked perfectly once again to our specifications of extra crispy. Fries were crispy and the fingers were a hit as well. Very impressed and we will be ordering from them again! Loved the amount of variety and specifications available to all of their food on the menu and it really stood out how well they listened to those specifications!
Sauce was amazing. Pizza was very good like the option of adding something on the crust got the garlic crust. Very good. Loved the wide variety of sauces for the wings. The bacon barbecue was very good. The only thing I felt weird about was my extra toppings that I ordered were added on after the pizza was cooked. But I definitely will order again And recommend
I picked up a pizza yesterday and it was very overcooked. The sauce was so dry and the cheese was burnt. I usually have great pizza when I order. I’m not sure what happened yesterday?
Have to say overrated. Turkey sub very good. Pizza crust and sauce decent, sausage hard and fatty, pepperoni average bland taste or undercooked. BBQ chicken fingers, sauce very food, fingers themselves fatty, not tender, fries dried out or greasy tinge. They seem to get part of the meals right, the other parts not great. Wish I could say otherwise. I tried it years ago and it did not change or what reviews say is not accurate. Subs I would give a high mark, everything else mediocre. Not what you want to spend $50 on being honest.
We have ordered without incident many times ,but.,we ordered a sheet & 50 wings . The pizza sauce was very sweet ,too sweet for alot of people that were here and the horseradish mustard wings tasted like they were straight up hot dog yellow mustard , ended up in the trash, def didn't impress family from out of state.
This is my first time trying this place. I ordered 1/2 tray half cheese ,half cheese/pepperoni and 30 wings 1/2 honey bbq and 1/2 garlic parm. My first impression, not overly impressed since half the pizza was burnt. I do like the overall taste of the dough ( although a little dry because it was over cooked), the crust had a nice crunch too it though. The cheese has a nice flavor and not too salty like some places can be. The sauce is a sweet sauce, which I liked alot ( I really only like sweeter sauces). Also the pepperoni's were very nice ,small cup n char but not too thick cut. Overall very good pizza, even though it was burnt. I would definitely try them again. I didn't bother to try to call to notify them that it was burnt. I'm sure they would have replaced it. We were hungry and just wanted to eat, plus it's like 15 minutes from my house. The chicken wings were pretty good and cooked crispy like I asked. The honey bbq was very good, it had a different flavor to it that I have never had before. The garlic Parm had a nice flavor to them. However with some of the wings, the sections were not sperated at all. Also my wife says the blue cheese was the best she has had.
Inicia sessió per deixar una ressenya
Inicia sessióElimina anuncis i gestiona el menú
Explora la teva zona
Pho 54
Break'n Eggs Creperie
Dancing Chopsticks
Blue Bull Tavern
Rachel's Mediterranean
Remington Tavern
Audubon North
ICHA Cafe
Naan-Tastic
Tea Leaf Cafe
11 Fotos
Explora les fotos de Fatman's Pizza
Informació sobre Fatman's Pizza
Com arribar
2712 Niagara Falls Blvd, Tonawanda Town, NY 14150
Destacats
Serveis
Opcions de Menjador
Informació del Restaurant
Comoditats
El Barri
Ubicació
2712 Niagara Falls Blvd, Tonawanda Town, NY 14150
📍 Explorar el Barri
park in the United States of America
Jocs
🎮 Guanya Punts Mentre Explores!
Juga a Find Me i canvia punts per descomptes a Fatman's Pizza i altres restaurants
Guanya Punts a Fatman's Pizza!
Juga a Find Me i canvia recompenses aquí
Guanya punts extra i canvia'ls per recompenses de Fatman's Pizza
🏆 Recompenses de Fatman's Pizza
Descompte 10%
A Fatman's Pizza
Aperitiu Gratis
A la teva propera visita
Taula VIP
Experiència premium
per canviar recompenses i guanyar punts
📋 Com funcionen les recompenses?
Juga a Find Me
Cada 100 punts de score = 1 punt de recompensa
Acumula Punts
Els workers obtenen 2x punts per partida
Canvia Recompenses
Descomptes, menjar gratis i experiències VIP
És teu? Reclama'l GRATIS!
Elimina anuncis i gestiona el menú