Jason Scott

Great pizza and be warned, the spicy sauce isn't playing. Great curated beer list as well. Easy place to just relax with friends

Clayton G

Amazing pizza place and cocktail bar = 2 in 1 with outstanding service and atmosphere. Their pizza is delicious and their cocktail menu is fresh and original seasonal varieties. They always take great care of you here.

Lauren Dykes

I am traveling for work alone and wanted a place that felt relaxed but cozy and offered good food off the beaten path. The pizza was amazing, atmosphere was perfect and the touch of VHS table markers was so nostalgic. Thanks for making this out of towner feel invited and full!

Destiney Smith

One of the best pizza places around the area. Super chill atmosphere and great food!

Kelly Miller

The atmosphere and vibe are great! The pizza and salad were wonderful. The pizza is made in a wood fired oven. There are no wait staff. You order at the bar.

+7

Sarah Potter

Great local pizza joint. Flavorful dough, great homemade meatballs. Quick and friendly service (you order at the bar and then find a seat). Easy spot to grab a bite for a solo traveler or with a group of friends. Also dont skip out on the homemade ranch or red sauce.

Karl Ellis

I would put 6 stars… but google won’t let me. Great food, great service and a rock star owner (literally). This place gets busy, so come early. Small bar available for those just wanting a drink and a slice… also great for families to come and dine. The interior design is very interesting to view, bringing a bit of life into this historic building. The owner is super friendly and the staff all were on point to help. We will be back!

FriedChicken

Passing by and found this great spot for pizza. Building is from 1867 and the developer turn the old fire station into a pizzeria. Very good pizza, bottom has a good char from the oven. Pizza sauce taste like their own recipe/homemade, and it has plenty of sauce and cheese on the pie. Sauce might have too much water in it because ingredients slide off pretty easy once you pick up a slice, other than that no complaints. There is a bar and a couple of TV that you can enjoy your food and the game at the same time. Excellent place to bring friends and family

+1

Nicholas Henderson

Fireside Pizza is an absolute gem housed in a beautifully restored old fire station. The historic charm of the building with its brick façade and garage-style doors adds a unique, cozy ambiance that perfectly complements the dining experience. The outdoor picnic tables offer a casual, inviting vibe that's hard to beat. Now, onto the food—it's phenomenal! The pizza comes with the perfect balance of crispy, slightly charred crust and gooey, melted cheese. Each slice is loaded with flavor, making it clear they take pride in their craft. The calzone is golden-baked to perfection, stuffed with fresh ingredients, and paired with a delicious marinara that adds just the right amount of zest. If you’re in the mood for authentic, wood-fired pizza served in a one-of-a-kind setting, Fireside Pizza is the place to be. Highly recommend for both the atmosphere and the top-notch food!

Alison Zickuhr

Friends of ours invited us to go support this restaurant and we are so glad they did! It’s a beautiful building with interesting history and that’s just the beginning! They were friendly from the minute we walked in! You order at the bar and sit wherever you want! We had the The Meats Pizza added mushrooms and onions. And I think the salad was a House Salad (husband ordered it for me). You would think the salad would be just basic. But it was incredible and the server was correct, small is perfect to share! The ham, eggs, onion were cut perfectly so every bite was delicious! The cheese bread ROCKED! Our friend said if the pizza is as good as the bread it will be incredible……all TRUE! I don’t know what pizza they ordered, but it looked great and I stole a piece of ham….oh my perfect!!! You will not be disappointed if you take the time to go and try this restaurant. We will definitely return!!

Amy Dunlea

I am in the neighborhood every Thursday to volunteer for LaSoupe, and finally decided to stop in to order lunch pizzas to go. Love the atmosphere of the place. The staff is so friendly. I ordered a make your own pizza with red sauce, and a white pizza with additions. Here are my thoughts: 1) The dough is fantastic 2) The amount of toppings are great 3) The red sauce is tomatoey but very salty, combine that with pepperoni and the result is a salt bomb 4) The white pizza cheese combo is the fabulous and a generous amount for cheesy goodness. 5) The wood-fire cook on the pizzas was perfect! This may sound dorky, but we keep a record of all of the pizza places we try all over the city, and this place belongs in the top 3 for sure.

Lisa Valera

Stopped at this restaurant by chance and truly enjoyed it! I had a Cesar salad and was able to try the white and pesto pizzas.. everything was delicious! The beer and wine selection is adequate. The decor and ambiance of the restaurant suits the theme. I love that they use old VHS boxes as the table numbers. It’s definitely worth a try!

+3

I selected this restaurant basically at random from my phone while approaching Cincinnati on my way home to northern Indiana. I was in the mood for pizza and wanted a local pizza shop and after pulling up choices, I selected this one. I ordered a pepperoni pizza and cheese bread. The cheese bread is a 10 inch thin crust pizza without tomato sauce but with parmesan cheese sprinkled over the surface along with Italian seasoning. It was served with a nice tasting marinara dipping sauce. The 14" hand tossed pizza was loaded with pepperoni and had an adequate amount of sauce and cheese. It was far from the worst pizza I've had, but nothing I would make a special trip to enjoy. Service is cordial, but there is limited interaction with staff as your order is taken at the counter and it's self service for drinks and everything else afterward. There was a nice young woman roaming the floor, cleaning tables and keeping the dining area very clean. Atmosphere was very casual and tame, with low noise level. Unique place. Food is not disappointing.

Ordered delivery. Can’t explain what a mistake this was. I can accept delivery is a gamble. What I can’t quite get myself to be philosophical about is when you call about not getting food you paid for and you get push back. No. I’m done with this kinda thing. This food is nowhere near worth it. I knew better and I ordered anyway. Just don’t do it. Go in and eat the overpriced mediocre pizza at least it’s not Papa Johns. Go for the face time with your friends and family. But don’t order delivery. Edit: I just saw the side of the box: too small to fail. that is super funny. I’d say too small to manage basic competence. Unfortunately. In a market this size maybe they think they get a pass, like I said, not being Papa John’s..