New York Pizzeria

Best pizza around! This is as close as you can get to real New York/New Jersey pizza. Recommended!!! *Chicken parm and eggplant parm sandwiches would be great additions to the menu.

been going here since 1994. LOVE THIS PIZZA. . hasn't change a bit except they dont have the street fighter 2 arcade anymore but the quality if the pizza is exactly the same...PHENOMENAL. 🔥🔥🔥

The best pizza in the area! I've been buying my pizza at NY Pizzeria for many years and it remains the same great tasting pizza. The NY special is delicious and the antipasto salad is always fresh!

First, Pizza is Authentically delicious. Unlike other fast food pizza restaurant here the ambiance and set up are very classic. Staff are professional and price of the pizza is reasonable.

Love the atmosphere. The pizza is the best.

I have been eating here since they opened. Came here after baseball, & soccer games as a kid. I usually order over the phone, and by the time I get there to eat my pizza is ready in 15min. I give this place 5 stars!

Special place for the Gen X who lived in this area. NYP is not about the food but about memories and years of satisfying eatings while growing up. This is a sacred spot for Walnut longtimers. You can't let this place ever go.

The location is great, right next to Vons supermarket. The pizza tastes amazing, especially when it's freshly baked, with the perfect combination of color, aroma, and flavor. The ingredients are plentiful and very fresh, and the baking process is quick. We ordered the signature New York-style pizza, as well as a half-and-half pizza. Our kids also had lasagna, and they said it was 'so delicious' that they finished the whole large portion. I highly recommend this restaurant, and all the staff are very friendly!

Nice spot to grab pizza, beer and watch a game!

I've been coming here since I was a kid If you're looking for real real delicious pizza this is the place to come to this is authentic you're gonna get it wonderful sandwiches Hey they even give you plates napkins crushed peppers and parmesan ...

Sooo yummy! Reminds me of getting pizza as a kid in NYC! The house made tomato sauce is delicious!

Jessica Payne

Sooo yummy! Reminds me of getting pizza as a kid in NYC! The house made tomato sauce is delicious!

AG

The location is great, right next to Vons supermarket. The pizza tastes amazing, especially when it's freshly baked, with the perfect combination of color, aroma, and flavor. The ingredients are plentiful and very fresh, and the baking process is quick. We ordered the signature New York-style pizza, as well as a half-and-half pizza. Our kids also had lasagna, and they said it was 'so delicious' that they finished the whole large portion. I highly recommend this restaurant, and all the staff are very friendly!

Dream Rentals

Nice spot to grab pizza, beer and watch a game!

Matthew Gonzalez

I've been coming here since I was a kid If you're looking for real real delicious pizza this is the place to come to this is authentic you're gonna get it wonderful sandwiches Hey they even give you plates napkins crushed peppers and parmesan ...

The pictures don’t do the food justice. Pizza here is so delicious. It’s oily but it’s like a bomb oily and the slices are always so good. Definitely wait to bite it, it’s always super hot but it’s so delicious. This is my go to pizza. Definitely recommend

Best comparable slice to new York convenience pizza you can get. Cannot beat Mondays 11.99 large pie special. Monday Night Football, pizza and nice folks always a good time here.

Best Pizza in Walnut/La Puente area

Loved the pizza here. Great New York style crust with quality toppings and didn't skimp on them. Pricing was quite reasonable. We also ordered the potato wedges and they were delicious too. Definitely plan on coming back to try some of their pasta dishes as well.

Well the pizza dough was okay. The pepperoni looked and tasted raw . IT didn't have that good quality of pizza but overall it was just okay.. The customer service was good . But I was looking for that New York Pizza taste. Someone recommended me to this place..

I felt like I was in New York. The ambiance, the staff, the fresh hand made outstanding flavor, fully cooked / Not dry, Not under cooked, perfect blend flavor of dough, wow! My first bite was incredible, never tasted a Pizza like this. I almost cried of appreciation of this Amazing Pizza! Thank you❤️🌹

We love the pizza here. It's always hot, made with the right amount ingredients, and its delicious!

This is a fantastic spot with reasonable prices, consistent quality and prompt service. Be sure to check out this place if you're craving something Italian while you're in Walnut!

Been coming here since I was a small child. They added some new paint and new tables but it is the same place I remember. The employees are friendly, it is always packed (especially mondays when they run a special) but everyone is in a good mood and having fun. The food is delicious whether you get a sandwich, salad or pizza (you should try the New York Special). Parking is easy and so is finding a place to sit.

Tommy Gun

Best Pizza in Walnut/La Puente area

Letitia Boas

We love the pizza here. It's always hot, made with the right amount ingredients, and its delicious!

Shawn Dunn

This is a fantastic spot with reasonable prices, consistent quality and prompt service. Be sure to check out this place if you're craving something Italian while you're in Walnut!

Linda Hernandez

I felt like I was in New York. The ambiance, the staff, the fresh hand made outstanding flavor, fully cooked / Not dry, Not under cooked, perfect blend flavor of dough, wow! My first bite was incredible, never tasted a Pizza like this. I almost cried of appreciation of this Amazing Pizza! Thank you❤️🌹

Aaron Bright

Been coming here since I was a small child. They added some new paint and new tables but it is the same place I remember. The employees are friendly, it is always packed (especially mondays when they run a special) but everyone is in a good mood and having fun. The food is delicious whether you get a sandwich, salad or pizza (you should try the New York Special). Parking is easy and so is finding a place to sit.

Ulisses Rodriguez

The pictures don’t do the food justice. Pizza here is so delicious. It’s oily but it’s like a bomb oily and the slices are always so good. Definitely wait to bite it, it’s always super hot but it’s so delicious. This is my go to pizza. Definitely recommend

Kelly K

Best comparable slice to new York convenience pizza you can get. Cannot beat Mondays 11.99 large pie special. Monday Night Football, pizza and nice folks always a good time here.

James Carriere

Loved the pizza here. Great New York style crust with quality toppings and didn't skimp on them. Pricing was quite reasonable. We also ordered the potato wedges and they were delicious too. Definitely plan on coming back to try some of their pasta dishes as well.

Had their pepperoni pizza with mushrooms. It was good. We also had their meatball sandwich which I give a two thumbs up. The bread was very fresh. The fries were on the spicy side but tasty. They have a big screen tv and for sports fans they had a hockey game on.

Good pizza and great sandwiches... try the pastrami! Large screen TV to watch the game. This place is a popular hang out for the locals for years. Good place for large groups and team parties. Interior is nothing fancy that's why I gave 4 stars instead of 5.

The kids and I had just a pizza which was quite good. I am from N.Y. and it was close but the slice were not soft enough. Hard to explain but in N.Y. you are supposed to be able to fold the slice all the way without hearing the crunching. Overall, it was good and I would go back again.

Great place ta have a beer eat tasty pizza and watch a game

Being from Pennsylvania I know what the real pie taste like. So many places in CA they advertise they're selling NY pizza. If you get thin crust to where you can fold up w/ lots of cheese it's not NY. I can't give it a 5 but it's so close.

The special on Monday is pretty great. 10 bucks for a large pizza with two toppings. Their pies are quality and they do have a 70+ t.v. for football and most major sports.

A Walnut staple. I always glad to stop in when I am back in my home town.

Ordering to go from that nostalgic pizza place was a delightful experience. Even though I couldn't enjoy the ambiance on-site, the staff made sure to package everything with care. The pizza, carefully placed in a classic-style box, retained its warmth and aroma during the journey home.

Great, low key place. Came here a lot when I was a really little kid, so it's pretty dope to come here as an adult and get pitchers, haha. Solid food and chill, unassuming interior. It's been around for so long for a reason, y'all...

The pizza was good. I was really impressed by the time they took to make it, very fast 5/5. Friendly staff. I ordered a beef and mushroom, it was good but it could be better. Definitely will come back and try other combination though.

Enrique DC-

The pizza was good. I was really impressed by the time they took to make it, very fast 5/5. Friendly staff. I ordered a beef and mushroom, it was good but it could be better. Definitely will come back and try other combination though.

Cesar Garcia Patino

Ordering to go from that nostalgic pizza place was a delightful experience. Even though I couldn't enjoy the ambiance on-site, the staff made sure to package everything with care. The pizza, carefully placed in a classic-style box, retained its warmth and aroma during the journey home.

Smevin Bravis

Great, low key place. Came here a lot when I was a really little kid, so it's pretty dope to come here as an adult and get pitchers, haha. Solid food and chill, unassuming interior. It's been around for so long for a reason, y'all...

emily ito

Had their pepperoni pizza with mushrooms. It was good. We also had their meatball sandwich which I give a two thumbs up. The bread was very fresh. The fries were on the spicy side but tasty. They have a big screen tv and for sports fans they had a hockey game on.

Pizza was overpriced. And tasted only so-so. I wouldn't go back. The workers barely speak English. They put my order on the pick up station and it was still on a burning hot plate. They sat there and watched me struggle trying to pick it up without getting burned for a good 2 minutes before offering to help me.

Decent pizza here. Not enough sodium for my taste, but that's ok. Good atmosphere. The technology, TV's and sound, etc.are kind of old and outdated. Reminds me of a pizzeria that I used to go to with my baseball team during Little League in the 90's. There is one central TV that has whatever the big game is on at the time. But if you do not want to see that one then you are out of luck.

Location was alright. The pizza was good. I had pepperoni. Pass on their garlic bread and cheese bread. It's pretty much just toast. The wings are alright nothing amazing. To me the experience was very average.

It gets pretty crowded here Monday nights. 9.99$ for a large pizza. 9.99$ for a pitcher of beer. Crowd is mostly regulars, long time residents of Walnut. 2 HDTVs. 1 huge HDTV and 1 small on on the other side of the restaurant. Feels like everyone knows each other at this Pizzeria. If you just want to come for a cold beer that's fine. No pressure to order food.

margaret juang

It gets pretty crowded here Monday nights. 9.99$ for a large pizza. 9.99$ for a pitcher of beer. Crowd is mostly regulars, long time residents of Walnut. 2 HDTVs. 1 huge HDTV and 1 small on on the other side of the restaurant. Feels like everyone knows each other at this Pizzeria. If you just want to come for a cold beer that's fine. No pressure to order food.

This place is good their food was good we got a pizza and some wings. The only reason for 2 stars and not 5 stars is they call you for your food and the metal pizza tray is placed on was so hot I burned my hand well my finger tips anyways. This is not ok its the next day and my finger tips still hurt. How do you give out food on extramly hot trays?

May 2023. I’m a many years customer. I picked up my pizza, opened the box at home and was disappointed. Tiny sausage looked like crumbs and the pepperoni was dime size. What happened??????

Bought a BBQ beef sandwich to go. Sooooo disappointed! Ive been buying food from here over 25 years and this is the first time ive been disappointed in their BBQ beef sandwich! Definitely NOT the same! Bread is like a small thin breakfast roll and they left out the provolone cheese. Yet still charged me $10. WTH NOT okay and NOT happy 🤨

Janine Hernandez

Bought a BBQ beef sandwich to go. Sooooo disappointed! Ive been buying food from here over 25 years and this is the first time ive been disappointed in their BBQ beef sandwich! Definitely NOT the same! Bread is like a small thin breakfast roll and they left out the provolone cheese. Yet still charged me $10. WTH NOT okay and NOT happy 🤨

I rarely write bad reviews but I have no idea how people think this pizza is good. Some of the worst I have ever had. Especially since I paid $25 for a 12 inch. Super thick crust, cheese isn’t good, no flavor. Dominos or Pizza Hut is way better.

It was our first time having dinner at New York Pizzeria. The food was really good , you could taste the quality. Unfortunately their service is horrible. The employees Make you feel unwelcome and gives you the sense that you are bugging them.

Over 30 minutes for one pizza?! It's bad enough you use canned ingredients in your pizza, but not having the customer service (CS) sense to tell the customer that there may be a wait time is unacceptable. And don't get me started on the garbage CS. I didn't choose to be a middle-aged pizza cashier, you did. Part owner? The other owners should be ashamed. First and last visit (08.04.2024). WILL NEVER RETURN. Waste your money here or spend it somewhere better.

Belen Rojas

It was our first time having dinner at New York Pizzeria. The food was really good , you could taste the quality. Unfortunately their service is horrible. The employees Make you feel unwelcome and gives you the sense that you are bugging them.

Diego Carbajal

Over 30 minutes for one pizza?! It's bad enough you use canned ingredients in your pizza, but not having the customer service (CS) sense to tell the customer that there may be a wait time is unacceptable. And don't get me started on the garbage CS. I didn't choose to be a middle-aged pizza cashier, you did. Part owner? The other owners should be ashamed. First and last visit (08.04.2024). WILL NEVER RETURN. Waste your money here or spend it somewhere better.