Marco Zojer

Probably my favourite bagel spot while we were in NYC. We had a cream cheese and Salmon bagel and the pastrami, sauerkraut and cheese bagel. Both were phenomenal, I dont know why this place is not higher rated, 10 out of 10!

Cara Zuraski

Best gluten free bagel. Actually achieved “squishy fluff” texture. They have gluten free plain bagel and everything bagels. Enter on BROADWAY, not 29th St. (google maps was directing me to Milk Bar)

Mya Zepp

Fantastic shop to stop at if your visiting NY and want great bagels and fantastic customer service. The man who was checking us out (I didn’t catch his name) was so kind throughout our entire experience. On top of the great customer service the bagels were amazing. I tried the Boca and loved it.

Gonzalo Avila

Amazing bagels here!! We had a pepperoni pizza bagel which was super good and a Combo bagel, that had a lot of ham, pepperoni and other stuff, and it was excellent. Both options we chose were extremely tasty, I recommend them both. The only negative point is that is a bit expensive and the seating is awkward, the place is doesn't really invite you to stay.

Carin Rudich

Overstuffed bagel! This location happens to be hidden in the Ace Hotel. It’s nice since you have the option of eating in the beautiful hotel lobby. I ordered the Salmon Classic and a coffee, only able to finish half. The taste was great, the price wasn’t. Inflation clearly is winning. The counter help was super friendly. FYI. They sell day old bagels at a discount already packaged.

Emily Boudreaux

Good bagel sandwiches. They have chicken sausage patties which i enjoyed. Kinda stingy with their cream cheese but it wasn’t too bad. They do need more varieties in cream cheese though

Robert Young

🥯 heard about this bagel spot and decided I’d give it a try. The bagels were more breast than I like but not bad. They were fresh and the price seems to be the going “normal” these days. The staff was attentive and greeted me as I came in which was nice. They were friendly and offered assistance and to order when I was ready. It’s a nice spot. Next time I’ll try the coffee! Overall good bagel spot just not a heavier bready guy.

+3

David Ryan

I really, really, really love bagels so I wanted to really, really, really love this place. Unfortunately it did not meet my expectations. I ordered a BEC on a sesame bagel (which was burnt) and it was just OK. I also order 6 bagels and my overall review is the bagels are smaller than most bagels I’ve tried, they were not as airy and fluffy as I prefer and there was no wow factor. They have a few locations so they must be doing something right. The shop was clean and the service was outstanding.

I typically love black seed but this location doesn’t have a griddle so the bacon and eggs are made differently. They also burn their bagels often unfortunately.

Michelle C

Ordered a toasted bagel. Received a gummy non-toasted bagel. Appreciate the GF options but would appreciate more order accuracy. Also the cream cheese schmear for $1.75 was lacking. Would expect more.

Emily

The scallion cream cheese was strangely bitter and overly sour. I’ve never had a bad bagel before, so this shocked me. The texture of the bagel was good though, not rubbery. Not as big or as much cream cheese as other places. Tables were dirty. Nice workers.

Kari K

One of the lousiest salmon bagels ever. Thinnest of the thin slices of salmon, one layer, for the money $14.95 absolutely ridiculous. I could barely taste any lox in the set. Laziest crowd ever behind the counter helped zero.

What a joke. $16 for a small bagel with literally 1 slice of smoked salmon. Either the owner is directing them to do that, or the workers have decided to do that for other reasons. Either way, no thanks. Sadly so, it was a good bagel. And all this in addition to ordering 1 item and getting my order 100% wrong.

Join

This morning, I went to buy a bagel. I entered the store at 10 AM to place my order and waited for 10 minutes without being served. So, I went somewhere else to order coffee. When I returned to pick up my bagel, they told me there had been a mistake. Throughout this process, I was dissatisfied—the employee didn’t even offer a sincere apology, just said one word: "mistake." As I opened my bagel, it looked just like in the picture—the food was made so poorly that it was completely unappetizing and killed any desire to eat it. I spent time waiting and paid money, yet I didn’t even receive an apology. The food was carelessly prepared, and I am extremely angry about this. Such an attitude and such poor quality are absolutely unacceptable.

+2