Sneek

Absolutely loved it here. Desserts were bomb and the atmosphere makes you want to hang out and relax. Can't wait to go back.

Eshika Patel

straight out of an old school movie. the whole menu sounds so good it took me awhile to settle on a chai flavored ice cream float. we also got a chocolate egg cream (get this, it has no egg nor cream, it's actually flavored soda) both items were so good, the employees are also super nice and welcoming. definitu an awesome community spot, it got super busy at 10pm on a Monday night they have rotating ice cream flavors but vanilla and chocolate are permanent.

Melanie Mengüş

This place is like stepping back in time. I visited from the UK during my trip. I was so excited to try authentic and vintage drinks. And I wasn’t disappointed at all. The ambiance was unique with a vintage decor, an open kitchen where you can watch them prepare the drinks, cosy tables and even board games to play. I had a hot chocolate because it was cold outside and my husband tried the authentic NY eggcream which was delicious too. We also shared a whoppie pie which was very good. Our experience was amazing and I already can’t wait to visit again. Next time I hope the weather will be hotter so I can have a root beer float because it looks delicious!

+1

Noé DUARTE

AMAZING AMAZING. First, the place is simply remarkable. The objects all around, the history, the atmosphere. They are worth the visit. As for the desserts themselves … they are crazy good. I recommend the BQE, which was delicious. The staff is super nice as well. I have to come back !

+3

This is my second time here, but both times, I really enjoyed the food, the service, and the vibe. I was looking forward to coming back, and this time I even got to bring a friend. It's a cozy little…

This is my second time here, but both times, I really enjoyed the food, the service, and the vibe. I was looking forward to coming back, and this time I even got to bring a friend. It's a cozy litt…

This is my second time here, but both times, I really enjoyed the food, the service, and the vibe. I was looking forward to coming back, and this time I even got to bring a friend. It's a cozy litt…

What a cute relic unlike anything in Manhattan that has been built for instagram, this has a much more authentic feel. The dessert menu is endless and the service was quick and fun. Line when we go…

What a cute relic unlike anything in Manhattan that has been built for instagram, this has a much more authentic feel. The dessert menu is endless and the service was quick and fun. Line when we go…

Very cute place. It's fun for a kitchy moment when you want ice cream. This spot is more about the place than the dessert (nothing you haven't tasted before if you've had a sundae, milkshake, etc.)

Very cute place. It's fun for a kitchy moment when you want ice cream. This spot is more about the place than the dessert (nothing you haven't tasted before if you've had a sundae, milkshake, etc.)

This is a great spot. It has maintained the nostalgic feel and look of days gone bye, while creating a vibe that is inviting and current. But most important, the ice cream sundaes and floats and sc…

The whole experience at Brooklyn Farmacy is 5/5 stars, ice cream alone is 4/5. I love taking my toddler for ice cream and sitting at the counter watching the soda jerks at work. She loves watching …

Love the ambiance more than anything great for coming alone or with others ice cream is better in person than through Uber eats. Heath bar with caramel no pb is great

Food: This dessert shop is excellent! The menu has a variety of desserts including ice, creams, sundaes, milkshakes, ice cream, floats, frozen hot chocolate, hot chocolate, other frozen treats, a…

Had the chocolate fudge brownie sundae and it was really good. The brownie was yummy and the service was fast. Would happily return

Had the chocolate fudge brownie sundae and it was really good. The brownie was yummy and the service was fast. Would happily return

Brooklyn Farmacy wasn’t just a place we stopped for milkshakes — it became the soul of our trip. We were visiting from Manchester, UK, and I actually started planning this adventure all the way back …

What a cute place!!! This is an old pharmacy turned into a soda/ice cream fountain, and it is just so charming! They have a huge selection of sundaes, floats, and anything you could want, I ordered…

What a cute place!!! This is an old pharmacy turned into a soda/ice cream fountain, and it is just so charming! They have a huge selection of sundaes, floats, and anything you could want, I ordered…

Wow- the milkshakes are really something else. Great atmosphere, very good service and reasonable value for the money

Wow- the milkshakes are really something else. Great atmosphere, very good service and reasonable value for the money

Wow- the milkshakes are really something else. Great atmosphere, very good service and reasonable value for the money

Such a cool atmosphere here, modelled after an old school soda shop….so unique. We had milkshakes which were amazing (and massive). Staff were helpful about gluten free options and there were quite…

Such a cool atmosphere here, modelled after an old school soda shop….so unique. We had milkshakes which were amazing (and massive). Staff were helpful about gluten free options and there were qui…

Such a cool atmosphere here, modelled after an old school soda shop….so unique. We had milkshakes which were amazing (and massive). Staff were helpful about gluten free options and there were quite…

We had our desserts delivered from Brooklyn Farmacy. My peanut butter sundae was terrific: the ice cream was excellent. Delivery was quick too.

We had our desserts delivered from Brooklyn Farmacy. My peanut butter sundae was terrific: the ice cream was excellent. Delivery was quick too.

We had our desserts delivered from Brooklyn Farmacy. My peanut butter sundae was terrific: the ice cream was excellent. Delivery was quick too.

We spent the day in New York letting our feet take us wherever they led us. That meant walking over the Brooklyn Bridge and ending up at the Brooklyn Farmacy & soda Fountain. We were hot when we wa…

the nostalgic ny decor makes it the cutest date spot. their housemade fudge is soso good. i preferred my partner’s sundae over my egg cream! i also had a great prior experience with their hot cocoa.

Space Dandy

Vear lovely ice cream shop, great to bring the family or a date. Prices are on the higher end but the portion are great to share. Definitely would come back to try more of the menu. The staff were very nice and outdoor seating spaces is available. Cash and credit are both accepted. Parking in the area is very limited but available depending on the time. 08/2025

Vincent Pham

Very cute spot in the neighborhood. Consider it a wonderful spot to stop by during an evening walk through the brownstone neighborhoods in order to catch the sunset. 2 soda floats and tip will put you over $20 so in terms of value, a customer could do better. Nevertheless, our drinks (orange creamsicle and roaring 20s) were great tasting and provided the cool on a summer day.

Steve mannino

Had a great experience, but a few thoughts that made this experience not a 5 star (should be a 4.5). Enjoyed the Take Five a lot. Love the peanut butter, caramel, and pretzel combo (it's insanely good), but feel the Sundae deserves 2 scoops of ice cream (yes, going forward I can add it). My guest loved the BQE. The marshmallow was fantastic, chocolate ice-cream, perfect. The only issue we had was that the whipped cream was over whipped.

Laura

Cute dessert shop. Pretty ample seating and lots of cute decor. I think the floats were a bit over priced for what they were but I loved the frozen hot chocolate milkshake. It had a toasted marshmallow top. Everyone agreed it was the best thing we ordered out of 3 floats and the one shake. I wouldn’t go out of my way to come here but it was a very cute location and we were able to chat and have dessert after dinner :) so if you’re in the area and like shakes/floats try it

Patricia Caguana

The atmosphere of this place is just amazing. It’s more about the experience than the flavors. Don’t get me wrong; I enjoy the desserts, but they were perhaps a bit too sweet. I will definitely try them again, but this time I’ll share. What I love about this place is that it feels like you’re stuck in time. They have preserved many original elements, so you really get the whole experience. I understand this place is famous for its soda, and I didn’t try that this time. I believe I need to come back and update you on that. The bathroom was spotless, and I loved the pictures that tell the story of the place. I also need to mention the Affogato; it was really good! However, next time I will definitely share it because it was too much for me, and I consider myself someone who loves desserts and has no problem finishing one on my own. If you’re visiting New York or live here and haven’t had the chance to visit this place, I highly recommend that you do. It’s amazing!

+11

cute space, no wait this past Sunday at 530 (super bowl) Enjoyed the excellent cookie and cream shake / Affogato. \n\nUnfortunately, the employee at the register was a complete turn off. He barely ma…

I was today year's old when I realized we had a genuine, bonafide, legitimate soda fountain in Far From Subway-land, Brooklyn. Gee-willikers! \n\nThe setting was as Grease meets Archie Comics as one …

cute space, no wait this past Sunday at 530 (super bowl) Enjoyed the excellent cookie and cream shake / Affogato. \n\nUnfortunately, the employee at the register was a complete turn off. He barel…

I was today year's old when I realized we had a genuine, bonafide, legitimate soda fountain in Far From Subway-land, Brooklyn. Gee-willikers! \n\nThe setting was as Grease meets Archie Comics as on…

God forbid if they let sit down and order instead I had to wait... and wait for a group of people who couldn't make up their minds. Before they finally left, no wait they came back because th…

A blast from the past! I loved the old-fashioned decor, but was disappointed that my stool by the counter didn't spin as the stools when I was a child did!I had a cherry coke and it was excellent. …

Cute spot! You have to go atleast 1x! Stopped in to try an all Vanilla Coke float - it was very good! They had plenty of ice cream options and drinks! ambience is super old school and staff was sup…

The ambience of this place is super cute and cozy and is the perfect date spot or place to spend with friends and family. You order at the front and there's a few tables and seating on the counter.…

Patty May

This place is known for the sundae and that’s exactly why I came . I arrived at 9:30 and got served , . For a whopping $17, I could have received a little more ice cream . I’d say my ice cream was good minus the huge logs of pretzels they dumped in. Was it worth the $17 probly not , you don’t have to get a sundae they have other ice cream options . I love the traditional look to the interior. They have indoor seating and outside seating . As well as they sell merch for the brand itself , and slices of cake .

Stopped by for a quick bite of something sweet. The options are very clear. The ice cream was good, I would have just loved to see more flavor options. I went with a few friends who all loved their…

Fantastic environment. Great ambience! Had a banana malt. It was excellent. A must visit when in Brooklyn. Great menu. Good selection

The staff could not be more unwelcoming. Not a hello, welcome, how can I help you. Nothing. All staff were on their phone.\nNot a thank you, have a good evening nothing. They totally ignored us. …

Black people beware. It's still 1956 in there. My sister and I took our children here very excited to try all the things on the menu. We patiently waited while the cashier carefully explained every…

The staff could not be more unwelcoming. Not a hello, welcome, how can I help you. Nothing. All staff were on their phone. Not a thank you, have a good evening nothing. They totally ignored us. The …

The staff could not be more unwelcoming. Not a hello, welcome, how can I help you. Nothing. All staff were on their phone. Not a thank you, have a good evening nothing. They totally ignored us. …

Tom Fry

I'm a longtime Cobble Hill resident and have visited Brooklyn Farmacy dozens of times over the years, almost always with positive experiences. Unfortunately, my visit this evening was disappointing. After waiting 25 minutes for a milkshake—while watching customers who ordered after me receive theirs—I politely asked about my order. The response from one staff member, Justin, was unexpectedly harsh: he loudly told me I would "just have to wait" and that I wasn't the only customer. It was the first time I've been spoken to that way at any food establishment. Jannie from the Farmacy witnessed the exchange. I asked for a refund and to speak with a manager, but none was on duty. Jannie, handled the situation professionally—processing my refund quickly and providing contact information for management. To be clear, this review reflects the customer service experience (i.e. no one should be treated the way I was treated by the Farmacy staffer).. I have no complaints about the food or the space itself.

Nada Abdalla

I arrived at your location at 9:30 PM after driving 25 minutes, based on the map and the sign on the door stating that the store closes at 10:00 PM. I had also tried calling since 9:00 PM, but no one answered the phone. When I politely asked if I could please get one hot chocolate, I was told rudely that the store was already closed at 9:30. This was confusing and disappointing, especially since the posted hours indicated otherwise

Alf

Overall love this place..but there's one reason I'm writing this as a 1 star. The cakes... The cakes are too expensive for the less than adequate quality. The cakes are 1.5-2.5/5 on average, but never exceeding 2.75/5. The way I ran this is 1 point per these 5 categories: - moistness -.25 - flavor -.5 - texture -.5 - freshness -.25 - value -.25 -------------------- Total : 1.75