Isaac Martin

Incredible pub atmosphere and one of the best pints in the city. The food is what is expected in a pub setting, heavy salty carbs that will keep you drinking. That being said, they all taste incredible and I will never complain about another Guinness at Hartley’s.

Tom DeSantis

Classic style pub pouring great Guinness pours. Perfect spot for date night if you want to look like you really know the neighborhood, bc this is one of those "if ya know ya know" kinda spots. And I'm glad I was introduced to it.

Charlie Adler

Love this spot. The Guinness tap is well looked after and produces one of the best pints in town. I can't say enough good things about the friendly staff. And the food menu is great to boot. Hoping to be back many more times.

Brennan Hall

Hartley's has fantastic pours of Guinness and a constantly buzzing energy. Highly recommend stopping in if you're nearby. Sometimes it can be a touch hard to find a spot to sit if you have multiple people, and I still haven't been able to grab an outside table yet, but that popularity only speaks to the quality.

Olivia N

Overall rating: 5 I love this spot. I’ve been here a few times, with friends, with dates, by myself. I love it! It can be a little crammed on popular days, but it gives me the homey feeling every time. I recently found out they play blue grass on Mondays and it’s so fun. I love folksy music. The salad was surprisingly very good. The bartenders are so nice and I really just enjoy this place so much. Highly recommend if you live in the folksy, hippy, chill energy.

K Olson

Only good things to say about Hartley’s. The bartender was so nice, service was great, the drinks were made with care and the food was amaaaazing. We got the popcorn with Irish cheddar (most generous portion I’ve ever seen at a bar), roasted carrots and parsnips (wow), hartley’s toastie and the house-spiced beef sandwich. The sandwiches are all made on their house-made soda bread. The space itself is on the smaller side and very cozy, and they have some tables outside for seating as well. Will definitely return.

Casey Dahl

Great Guinness and really good food. For food I highly recommend the toastie, although it’s a bit pricey for what you get. As for atmosphere, it just has that “it” vibe that makes you want to come back, which we will be soon!

+1

wendy case

It was pretty good. We stopped by on a Mon thinking it wouldn't be too crowded lol. Wrong! Packed. Don't be in a hurry if it's crowded. The beer was good. The food was good not over the top crazy but good. Looks definitely to be a place where the locals gather which is fun.

Ben Mattson

Classic Irish pub. Loud and boisterous with perfect pints of Guinness.

Richard Salmon

Decent spot nice vibes, Irish pub style for transplants and regulars. Drinks are solid no need to get fancy with your order. More an off night haunt than a happy hour destination.

Matt Meany

Small but clean, sharp looking Irish pub. 8 beers on tap, a hand full of cans, a bunch of cocktails and a small food menu. They have a coat rack when you walk in, which I think is a nice touch. Not that I assumed it wouldn't clean, but I was impressed by how neat and sharp the whole place is. It is dim lit but there is a big window in the front that lets in some natural light. They have a picnic table o it front but I am not sure about taking any food or beer out there.

Jennie Shih

you don't HAVE to try the sandwich lol it's alright, sauce is pretty good but i wouldn't get a sandwich just for the sauce (aside from me being allergic to it), it also took about half an hour but the servers are very nice