I took my Wife for her Birthday Dinner.. the ambience during Christmas was beautiful!.. let me start with the waitstaff.. professional, attentive, really made us feel special!.. a beautiful setting of an old House.. the visual atmosphere of the place was very relaxing.. started off with Clams Oreganatta .. top necks.. came out perfect!.. had some perfectly prepared Old Fashioned Bourbon cocktails to start, followed by my main course ..Veal Marsala.. tender!.. the sauce was beyond compare and a generous portion!.. My Wife had Eggplant Parmesan ( Her favorite).. I sampled some and it was cooked perfectly and generous portions.. overall my experience there was above expectations.. I don’t write reviews really, but this place deserves it for the pride in their business and attention to every detail.. it’s been around since the 50s I think.. but a little known secret because a lot of local older residents frequent there.. it’s located in an non obtrusive spot right off Montauk Hwy in Hampton Bays.. try it!.. you won’t be disappointed.. and the prices are extremely reasonable!.. you almost say “ what?” When you get the bill… you’d spend the same at an Applebees or Fridays for a night out.. total gem

Just E!

This place is amazing! This was my first time going here for my mother-in-laws birthday and it was the best restaurant experience I've had in a very long time. Service was amazing! Food was phenomenal, I eat more then I've had in so long I had a good baby lol. And my mother in law is in a wheel chair and they were wonderful at accommodating her! Would recommend many to go there. Still be coming back soon!

Thomas McCarthy

Amazing food and amazing service This is a real hidden spot. It a very home feel restaurant with absolutely killer food.

Sandy and Thomas Malek

My husband and I went out to a restaurant down the street on our first night of our honeymoon and the service was HORRIBLE that we had to leave so at like 8:30 PM we strolled into the closest place that was opened which waa open which was Villa Paul. Immediately greeted by Patty and told her the story, she took such good care of us. She gave us food recommendations, spoiled us with amazing servings of bread, and even packed up our leftovers at the end of the night. We had the clams casino, calamari, garlic bread, surf and turf, duck with cherrry sauce, pasta and had a couple desserts to go. Everything was AMAZING!!! This place is a hidden gem

Robert Salmaggi

Like dinner at Nonna's house! Always a Pleasure- Delicious Food & Drinks, Great Friendly Service.. can't wait to go Again and I was just there last night! A happy customer for DECADES!!

+1

paty brady

Their dishes are delicious, one of my favorite appetizers there, are the bake clams. As a main dish their prime rib is one of the best, cook to perfection. They have an ample selection of drinks from wines to cocktails. They have a private room, great for company parties. We have attended different events at that private room. Overall we enjoy this restaurant, totally recommend it.

lisa krieg

The Villa Paul has always been my favorite restaurant. For years, since I was young my family and I have had Birthdays, Graduations, Memorials, and both Bridal and Baby Showers there. They have never disappointed. Eveything is always great. The staff and chefs are wonderful and Jim is always beyond accommodating. Great Place!

Christine Zay

I recently hosted a celebration of life luncheon at Villa Paul. They were super accommodating and understanding. I wasn’t sure what time the funeral services would be completed and so we arrived very early en mass at the restaurant. We were greeted graciously and welcomed to come in as they set up. The food at Villa Paul never disappoints and was plentiful and delicious. The service was professional, polite and very helpful. I highly recommend

Frank Morgano

This place has history, dating way back to 1804. Villa Paul is old school and takes me back decades. Super cozy, wonderful staff, and excellent food. We had the homemade ravioli, the filet mignon, and for dessert, tartufo. Delizioso!!

Up To Speed Detailing

My girlfriend and I went here for the first time on a Wednesday. From making the reservation to getting there, to sitting down, to the service was Great. We go places and care for customer service and Villa Paul went above and beyond our expectations.