Ordered from here twice in the last 2 days. Lunch was a little pricey but breakfast was a great price. Food was yummy with good portions both times. However, this review is mostly for their customer service. We had an issue with the order yesterday, BUT when I went in to order today, not only did they go above and beyond to make it right, but they instantly recognized me. That kinda experience is everything 🙌🏼

Great food, had the Jackson's favorite, chicken cutlet was delicious homemade and fresh. Definitely would get that sandwich again, the coleslaw with the cutlet was outstanding. Very fast and friendly service.

I had the absolute pleasure of trying the Brie and Beef sandwich... I will be coming back soon with friends. Keep up the great work!!!

There's nothing worse than traveling and getting a bad sandwich, but this place is easily a 10/10. The chicken cutlet is home made and super thin which is honestly the only way to eat it. If you have a thing for sandwiches this is your place.

Ordered an Italian hero, and it came out fast, large, and delicious. Friendly staff, and the hero had a large amount of meat, fresh veggies, great roll (like seriously!) and just overall excellent. Definitely will be back.

I’ve been coming here since the middle of September 2024. Their breakfast sandwich was the only thing I could keep down during my first trimester and I have had their food for lunch through out my entire pregnancy. Makes me happy and keeps baby happy. The workers are always kind and the food is ALWAYS delicious. 10/10 favorite spot. HIGHLY RECOMMEND.

As someone who grew up and always lived in New Paltz, I’ve always been a big fan of Russo’s. I do want to make it clear that this place is NOT Russo’s, and never will replace or beat Russo’s. NEVER!! However, the Pickled Pig is a wonderful deli, of exceptional standards, quality, and service. For starters, their hours are AMAZING! Open 7 days a week, and early. And they’re super reliable. Great place to get breakfast on the run. Or lunch if you’re in a time crunch. The time it takes to get your meal is also very quick. That however, does not bring down the quality. Everything is made fresh, especially all the chicken cutlets are fried to order. It’s actually really good. Another thing I’d like to point out is that the prices are very reasonable, especially considering the quality. Better bring cash though, cause it’s a little bit more if you pay via card. I’ve personally found myself become a regular customer, going there multiple times a week for breakfast and lunch. It’s the combination of quality, convenience, and pricing. Totally worth it. Thanks a lot Pickled Pig, really grateful to have you in our town!

I just had the best breakfast burrito ever! Delicious food, quality ingredients, quick service, and great prices. Love this place!

This deli is hands down the best deli in the area. I haven’t had a bad meal here. Wherever they source their bread products from they should never change it - the sandwich rolls and bagels are great. Generous portions especially for the already extremely reasonable prices. The staff, including the owner, are all extremely friendly whenever I go in with my family and i like that they have a comfortable area for seating too. This place is a gem and I hope it never changes!

One of the best Delis I have ever been to. Super nice staff, fast, and so delicious. I’ve been here about 30-40 times and have never had a bad experience or bad sandwich. Cutlets are incredible, so do yourself a favor and get a sandwich

Came here from Chicago, so used to italian deli type places. This was sooo good. We came during a big rush, so it was really busy and crowded. But we only had to wait like 10 mins. The guy working (I'm assuming the owner or manager- he seemed to know everyone) was very apologetic and kept checking on us. Now for the food. Oh lawd this food was good. I got the pesto caprese and it did not disappoint. They did not skimp on ingredients and the portions were huge. So delicious. I can't wait to try again when we visit again.

Our new spot to get a delicious and VERY reasonable breakfast or lunch. Always served just as ordered by a friendly server. Fresh,hot, and delicious always!!

Mary Hennelly

Our new spot to get a delicious and VERY reasonable breakfast or lunch. Always served just as ordered by a friendly server. Fresh,hot, and delicious always!!

Carson Haun

One of the best Delis I have ever been to. Super nice staff, fast, and so delicious. I’ve been here about 30-40 times and have never had a bad experience or bad sandwich. Cutlets are incredible, so do yourself a favor and get a sandwich

Jennifer M

This deli is hands down the best deli in the area. I haven’t had a bad meal here. Wherever they source their bread products from they should never change it - the sandwich rolls and bagels are great. Generous portions especially for the already extremely reasonable prices. The staff, including the owner, are all extremely friendly whenever I go in with my family and i like that they have a comfortable area for seating too. This place is a gem and I hope it never changes!

Miley Massed

I had the absolute pleasure of trying the Brie and Beef sandwich... I will be coming back soon with friends. Keep up the great work!!!

Cecil B demented

They have the best breakfast game in town!! We order from them all the time food is amazing!! When door dash didn’t get our whole order they delivered the rest of it themselves you have to try their French toast sticks there amazing!!

Giovanna Lauria

Best deli in New Paltz. Very friendly staff. Gluten free roll option for sandwiches, great food, fresh hot & iced coffee. Outdoor & indoor seating.

Jenny Camerini

Came here from Chicago, so used to italian deli type places. This was sooo good. We came during a big rush, so it was really busy and crowded. But we only had to wait like 10 mins. The guy working (I'm assuming the owner or manager- he seemed to know everyone) was very apologetic and kept checking on us. Now for the food. Oh lawd this food was good. I got the pesto caprese and it did not disappoint. They did not skimp on ingredients and the portions were huge. So delicious. I can't wait to try again when we visit again.

loganD

Great food, had the Jackson's favorite, chicken cutlet was delicious homemade and fresh. Definitely would get that sandwich again, the coleslaw with the cutlet was outstanding. Very fast and friendly service.

Yvonne LaForge

I just had the best breakfast burrito ever! Delicious food, quality ingredients, quick service, and great prices. Love this place!

Anthony Deponte

There's nothing worse than traveling and getting a bad sandwich, but this place is easily a 10/10. The chicken cutlet is home made and super thin which is honestly the only way to eat it. If you have a thing for sandwiches this is your place.

Carolyn Boyce

We are so glad we found this deli while visiting from out of town! We had the Luca and Pastrami Reuben, both were delicious. I’m sure you can’t go wrong no matter what sandwich you order. We put in an online pickup order and everything was packed securely and ready to go in 20 min. Highly recommend!

brian baker

Ordered an Italian hero, and it came out fast, large, and delicious. Friendly staff, and the hero had a large amount of meat, fresh veggies, great roll (like seriously!) and just overall excellent. Definitely will be back.

Alex Malamet

This is the best and most consistent deli in New paltz. They will lake you a sandwhich exactly how you like it. Never get an order wrong. Best flavors of chips and drinks. Very nice staff that will take your order over the phone.

Aylin R

Ordered from here twice in the last 2 days. Lunch was a little pricey but breakfast was a great price. Food was yummy with good portions both times. However, this review is mostly for their customer service. We had an issue with the order yesterday, BUT when I went in to order today, not only did they go above and beyond to make it right, but they instantly recognized me. That kinda experience is everything 🙌🏼

Brandi Vanorden

I’ve been coming here since the middle of September 2024. Their breakfast sandwich was the only thing I could keep down during my first trimester and I have had their food for lunch through out my entire pregnancy. Makes me happy and keeps baby happy. The workers are always kind and the food is ALWAYS delicious. 10/10 favorite spot. HIGHLY RECOMMEND.

Grisha Yashayev

As someone who grew up and always lived in New Paltz, I’ve always been a big fan of Russo’s. I do want to make it clear that this place is NOT Russo’s, and never will replace or beat Russo’s. NEVER!! However, the Pickled Pig is a wonderful deli, of exceptional standards, quality, and service. For starters, their hours are AMAZING! Open 7 days a week, and early. And they’re super reliable. Great place to get breakfast on the run. Or lunch if you’re in a time crunch. The time it takes to get your meal is also very quick. That however, does not bring down the quality. Everything is made fresh, especially all the chicken cutlets are fried to order. It’s actually really good. Another thing I’d like to point out is that the prices are very reasonable, especially considering the quality. Better bring cash though, cause it’s a little bit more if you pay via card. I’ve personally found myself become a regular customer, going there multiple times a week for breakfast and lunch. It’s the combination of quality, convenience, and pricing. Totally worth it. Thanks a lot Pickled Pig, really grateful to have you in our town!

2 subs, 1 soda, 1 monster, shared bag of chips. - $44+ Captive customers (college), or greed? They were NOT $14 sandwiches. Too much for locals. I tried them once, never again.

Scott Grey

2 subs, 1 soda, 1 monster, shared bag of chips. - $44+ Captive customers (college), or greed? They were NOT $14 sandwiches. Too much for locals. I tried them once, never again.