LaRustica

My favorite pizza spot in Carnegie Hill. Nice ppl inside . Good crispy pizza too

The nicest people in the only pizza shop open after 10 PM on the upper East side

Dudes there are great. Probably one of the best slices on the upper east side.

Pizza 10/10 customers service was great I will be back!

My family and I have been ordering from La Rustica for years and the quality of this delicious pizza has always been top notch. As a lifelong New Yorker, who has tried many pizza establishments, this is by far my favorite, hands down. I don’t know what their secret is, but in addition to the fresh ingredients, the crust is to die for. My personal favorite is the Bianca all-white pizza and the Margherita. And the owner, Alex, is a true gentleman, and offers excellent customer service. AND they are open until 4am Thurs, Fri, and Sat (2am on other nights). Could not recommend La Rustica more!

The guys in there are amazing and always so nice! The service is fast and the pizza is great!

Beatriz Colunga

Great pizza 🍕 and great staff!! I recommended 🙌Ahmed is cool

Lauren Arborio

The nicest people in the only pizza shop open after 10 PM on the upper East side

Luke Blumberg

Pizza is great and service is quick. Highly recommend.

Leonise Merile

Pizza 10/10 customers service was great I will be back!

Elizabeth Sweeney Benzon

The guys in there are amazing and always so nice! The service is fast and the pizza is great!

Saman Reza

Dudes there are great. Probably one of the best slices on the upper east side.

Oscar Marchi

My favorite pizza spot in Carnegie Hill. Nice ppl inside . Good crispy pizza too

Tatiana Somers

My family and I have been ordering from La Rustica for years and the quality of this delicious pizza has always been top notch. As a lifelong New Yorker, who has tried many pizza establishments, this is by far my favorite, hands down. I don’t know what their secret is, but in addition to the fresh ingredients, the crust is to die for. My personal favorite is the Bianca all-white pizza and the Margherita. And the owner, Alex, is a true gentleman, and offers excellent customer service. AND they are open until 4am Thurs, Fri, and Sat (2am on other nights). Could not recommend La Rustica more!

I got a large Bianca pizza added mushrooms, spinach, and jalapeño. The pizza was quite nice. The flavor was good, and the combination of mozzarella and ricotta cheese was very nice. The pie was thin and crispy just the way I liked it. They gave a good amount of spinach, but a bit cringy with mushrooms for $6 dollars worth if you ask me. The jalapeño they used was pickled. I was surprised when I picked up the pizza, because I smelled a sour flavor. It actually tasted very good. It was a good pizza.

Bradley C

I got a large Bianca pizza added mushrooms, spinach, and jalapeño. The pizza was quite nice. The flavor was good, and the combination of mozzarella and ricotta cheese was very nice. The pie was thin and crispy just the way I liked it. They gave a good amount of spinach, but a bit cringy with mushrooms for $6 dollars worth if you ask me. The jalapeño they used was pickled. I was surprised when I picked up the pizza, because I smelled a sour flavor. It actually tasted very good. It was a good pizza.

Okay pizza, but can do better in NYC. We got the food delivered and it was okay, not bad but not great either. Garlic cheese bread was visually not appealing but had a great flavor. Pizza was fine and the salads were not as advertised (missing several listed ingredients in the menu).

Emily Spott

Okay pizza, but can do better in NYC. We got the food delivered and it was okay, not bad but not great either. Garlic cheese bread was visually not appealing but had a great flavor. Pizza was fine and the salads were not as advertised (missing several listed ingredients in the menu).

I'm giving only two stars because after 50 bucks all I could eat was the chicken wings. The calamari was burnt old tasting and dry and the pizza was embarrassing. I tried a slice and almost threw up. My dog didn't even like it. Throw that sad excuse for calamari away

Brianna Kelly

I'm giving only two stars because after 50 bucks all I could eat was the chicken wings. The calamari was burnt old tasting and dry and the pizza was embarrassing. I tried a slice and almost threw up. My dog didn't even like it. Throw that sad excuse for calamari away

I recently moved to NYC on the same block as La Rustica. I’d ordered from them before on Slice and thought it was great pizza. I walked in tonight and ordered a pizza - they charged me $30 (vs. $18 advertised on Slice). When I confronted them, they became very awkward and refunded me $4 (still not what they advertised?) - it felt very dishonest that they’d tried to charge me so much more in case I didn’t notice. Loved the pizza but will not be my go-to - make sure you are careful to check what they charge you.

Alex Saralegui

I recently moved to NYC on the same block as La Rustica. I’d ordered from them before on Slice and thought it was great pizza. I walked in tonight and ordered a pizza - they charged me $30 (vs. $18 advertised on Slice). When I confronted them, they became very awkward and refunded me $4 (still not what they advertised?) - it felt very dishonest that they’d tried to charge me so much more in case I didn’t notice. Loved the pizza but will not be my go-to - make sure you are careful to check what they charge you.

Where do I begin with this hahahaha. Ordered a tricoloured pizza, received roadkill instead hahahahahaha $28 down the drain. Thank goodness for Grubhub refunding me.

Ansh S

Where do I begin with this hahahaha. Ordered a tricoloured pizza, received roadkill instead hahahahahaha $28 down the drain. Thank goodness for Grubhub refunding me.

Worst pizza ever a slice was 6$ and even worth 3 do not come not at all worth it . Not even worth all drunk need some food to live . I won’t eat ever again here

I order baked ziti with grilled chicken and it had almost no ziti in it and alot of meat to cover it up, there was some other type of meat mixed in with the Chicken that smelt like pork and I'm allergic to pork. I wish I had read the reviews before I ordered from here. BUYERS BEWARE!!!!

They sent me the wrong dessert, and charging $24 for a tiny pizza should be something you get jail time for. I tried to call and resolve it and no one answered and had no luck with Uber either. Never again, waste of money for bad food

Adi Meyerson

They sent me the wrong dessert, and charging $24 for a tiny pizza should be something you get jail time for. I tried to call and resolve it and no one answered and had no luck with Uber either. Never again, waste of money for bad food

UV

Worst pizza ever a slice was 6$ and even worth 3 do not come not at all worth it . Not even worth all drunk need some food to live . I won’t eat ever again here

I luv Jesus

I order baked ziti with grilled chicken and it had almost no ziti in it and alot of meat to cover it up, there was some other type of meat mixed in with the Chicken that smelt like pork and I'm allergic to pork. I wish I had read the reviews before I ordered from here. BUYERS BEWARE!!!!