Thomas Milom

I have to say if you're looking for NYC style pizza you can't go wrong here. Stopped in with my family for a quick slice and it was perfect. Expectations are always low on pizza, but I gotta say I really enjoyed my chicken ranch slice. Service people were awesome too.

Berat Onur Ersen

I have seen Sbarro pizzerias in other countries with better quality in service and cleanliness, regarding that this shop was a little bit of a disappointment. I might say this one is an average New York pizzeria with various types of pizzas. Price for a piece starts from ~6 dollars for the time being. I would suggest checking other pizzerias as well. You can find crazy number of places to have your pizza at Manhattan.

+2

Cédric (KDRIC)

Looking for a typical NYC slice of pizza ? Go there. The original new yorker italian restaurant in the 90's. Nowadays a bit expansive compared to new fast food which offer slices at only 0,99 dollars

+2

Christine C

It was decent pizza but too pricey for me. 5-6 dollars for a simple slice of pizza. Almost 3 bucks for a bottle of water. Super busy location today because of Thanksgiving. The restrooms weren't too clean. Over all, not a very pleasant visit.

+8

Dan Perez

In NYC since 1956, Sbarro pizza might just be more of a tourist trap pizza than what it is worth. At $9.12 for two slices without a drink this pizza location ranks as one of the costliest slices ($4.19 per slice) in NYC. Maybe you pay for the individual pizza boxes given per slice which is probably the best feature of the slice. The cheese slice I had was ok. Nothing great with a good sauce although it did have a decent flavor. The slice itself was more on the doughy side where it was not crispy on the bottom. Again this is another pizza location that the slice is very comparable to the slice a 2 Bros pizza (.99 pizza) but at 4X the cost. on a side note, this location was featured in an episode of the “Office” where Michael Scott refers to Sbarro as his “favorite New York pizza joint” and says “I’m gonna get me a New York slice”.

+9

TML

Typical pizza Joint located in the shadow of Madison Square Garden as such the prices are overly inflated. They sell specialty slices stuffed slices, calzones, pepperoni rolls, pasta, etc. The staff is not friendly at all it can also get a very busy especially during peak hours. If you absolutely need a slice have at it.

michael allen

Sbarro is not a true representative of New York Pizza it's got enough oil that if you tossed their pizza in the ocean there would have to be a environmental cleanup and the price for two slices and a water is almost $20 but that's the tourist trap area price. On the plus side the staff is friendly

John D

I feel horrible for the people who go here when they first get into NYC and think this is what New York pizza is. And it’s irrelevant that this place started In New York years ago, it’s turned into nothing more than expensive strip mall pizza. Terrible chain food that is overly expensive, thick, and inauthentic. A tourist trap, and still somehow does business despite better options on every block because tourists don’t know better and see “New York style pizza”

Shawn Hall

The worse pizza I've ever had in all my life is located here you can tell they don't care about cooking anymore because my pizza was overcooked and I hardly had any cheese on my pizza ! Or sauce . The place when I went was dirty and filled with flies it's like nobody cares anymore I'm surprised this place is open because the pizza isn't even good I rather spend $1.50 for a slice than to come back here to eat .

Sharys Vazquez

I order a cheese pizza and the slice came with a surprise. A piece of hair was in the cheese disgusting told the cook and said nothing not even money back or an apology. So if u coming to eat here’s it’s a nice place but look at your food carefully might find a surprise in there….