Marie Pavia

Tuttabella has consistently been a place to celebrate our special events. The atmosphere is lovely, the waitstaff is superb, and the food is elevated yet not pretentious.

+5

Jose Almejo

I was able to try Tutta Bella on a last minute dinner plan with some friends. Arriving for a 7:45pm dinner reservation showed the restaurant somewhat busy but still quiet enough where you can sit down and speak without raising your voice was a huge plus. Pictured are a cosmo, paper plane, the calamari, porter house dry aged steak for one, the chicken Marsala and chicken martini. For desserts we ordered the chocolate lava cake and strawberries. Everything was absolutely delicious. Service was friendly and even made me a specialty drink based on instructions I provided which was a nice touch. It’s a very elegant/casual restaurant if you’re looking for a good Italian meal. Parking can be limited so arrive earlier to get a spot in the lot.

+1

stacy derasmo

Had my daughters engagement party in the room upstairs 54 people, it was amazing!! The food delicious and a lot, the staff was amazing bright room with a balcony and photo wall. If your having a party it's the place Thank you everyone for making the day special!!

J.

We had my daughters bridal shower at Tutta Bella on Saturday. Words cannot express what an amazing job they did!!! Working with Granit the manager was such a pleasant experience. We were lucky enough to secure the private room they have!!! Amazing.. waiters Willy and Shack could not do enough to make me and my guests happy. The food was beyond delicious. Thank you Tutta Bellas and Leo for always making our parties so exceptional… highly recommend this restaurant for special occasion or a dinner with your family or loved one!!

I loved the ambience. Music was great too. I ordered Clams Casino and was very disappointed. Tasted dirty and had no toppings; no bread crumbs and no bacon. You can tell they did not put much effort into the clams. Husband ordered Shrimp cocktail, though they were not bad, we’ve had much better. They were unappetizing. After we finished our appetizers, we so as I’m writing this review and asked our waiter twice for our food, they keep saying they are very busy; not cool. Not inclined to come back and wait 30 minutes after appetizers for my dinner. Still waiting…Valentine’s Day has been ruined for us. I have to edit this review because of the excellent response the manager or maître d’ Kensey had when he found out our disappointment. He immediately came to our table and asked us what we were disappointed with and how he can fix it. He offered another dinner and it was cooked immediately. He came back with a Filet Mignon with mushrooms, potatoes and vegetables. They also comped our Lamb Chops dinner and our drinks. Thank you for your excellent customer care! We will visit again on a day they’re not so overwhelmed with business. BTW loved the free Valet Parking!

John The Barber

Tutta Bella was very nice. We liked it. We were there on New Years Eve with some friends. The food was very good no complaints there. We were on thier second floor, there were only 5 tables occupied. So there were a few empty tables. I wouldn't say it was busy there. Our waiter took our orders, food took a while, it was New Years Eve and they were busy on thier main floor I get that. But the night we were there service was not up to par. Our waiter wasn't very attentive. Not like thier other restaurant (Sergio's) in Pelham. It looked like he was busy with the other 2 tables he had. A little disappointing. But I must Stress the food was outstanding. Portions were not wimpy, some of us went home with food. Over all it was a good experiance.

My Umdnj

A comfortable venue with good service but the food was inconsistent. The mozzarella with greens and artichoke was exceptional, the fried calamari better than most. My main course was a pork chop, which could have been delicious but it was terribly over salted, as were the crispy potato chunks that accompanied it. I almost couldn’t finish it. The family style desserts included chopped up pieces of cheesecake, tiramisu, cannoli, and some type of flavorless hard cookie - none were worth the calories. I might give this place another try, but I certainly won’t rush back.

Jannatul Rumky

We had a nice experience. Food was ok, probably they may improve a bit Pasta, as it was average.

Louweeg

I have been there 2 times, we had a large group of people, around 25 people each time. We were situated upstairs with an outside balcony, it really is a great spot for a private party. Food was good considering the amount of people, bar service was great.

Eddy Vee

Food was delicious, except for the calamari that I didn’t expect to be from a bag. The crumbles and tiny pieces of excess chopped pieces of squid pointed to not being done by hand. The service was so-so. Maybe it was just early. I did notice that people around us were getting served the pickled olives and cheese plate while we did not. We asked about specials and were told that they don’t do any for lunch (2pm when we were there). Did enjoy the Cavatelli with sausage and broccoli rabe, and the Chicken Scarparello.

The service was excellent but the food was not good. The baked clams were tasteless. The veal parm and shrimp marinara pasta was in red spiced oil and definitely was not marinara sauce. This is not an authentic Italian restaurant.

Lily H

Came for lunch. Clientele was definitely boomer-heavy. Mediocre service and food. We waited 15 minutes after sitting down and had to ask for menus—bizarre. My boyfriend got sick after from his bolognese. My shrimp scampi was quite salty. The seafood pasta was not fresh. Would not recommend.

Its so sad to say that i was totally unsatisfied with this Italian restaurant. We decided to go for a birthday celebration on Sunday and the first problem started with the place we were supposed to eat . They notified us that it would be a small wine room but not at all that it was extremely cold . Second problem was the service, slow and unbothered people, the only thing they would ask a million times was if we wanted another bottle of wine. The third and biggest problem the food. I personally ordered filet mignon and it was horrible, don’t know what kind of meat was it but definitely not the one it was supposed to be. The waiter didn’t care at all why it was untouched by 2 people. Other food order (6 people ) nothing good or price matched . Very disappointed and definitely not going back or recommending it .