Smiley's Bagel & Co

I've become a regular at this place. The bagels are consistently fresh and delicious, the staff are friendly, the prices are fair, and there is parking.

Great place, bagels and egg sandwiches are outstanding, highly recommended.

Great service, prices, and quality of their food! Highly recommend Smileys bagels!

One of the few bagel stores that makes a great pumpernickel bagel get that lox and cream cheese some onions and capers, Good times!

Smiley is always in the store and true to his name always smiling. The bagels are always fresh and a good size. No tiny, skimpy bagels.

Awesome love it here! Nice area to sit and relax and have a bite to eat! Excellent well stocked deli with extensive selection. Bacon egg and cheese right on the money tasty fresh bagels too!

Great staff at this Bagel shop. They keep it moving even when they're extremely busy. In the process of preparing your order ,they are friendly, playful and courteous.

Extremely fast service, high quality food, friendly staff, it's clean,coffee and nitro are both great, good selection of drinks snacks and beer

Best place on the island for good food. They make a prime beef burger that is delicious. Also have good fries to be paired with it. Would definitely recommend this place.

We came back after we had sandwiches from here yesterday. That's how good it is. Huge meno of breakfast and lunch goodies. Big drinks coolers. Beer to go with your bagels and sundries of various sorts.

They have the best coffee anywhere in Staten Island. Also great people working there and 9 x out of 10 I'm a winner on their scratch offs

Friendly staff and good sandwiches made to order. They have a nice sitting area if you want to eat on site. There’s also convenient parking right in front.

Amazing hot roast beef sandwich , bagels are very good !! Great staff

Best tasting and looking bagels hands down.

ChungkingExpress1996

Friendly staff and good sandwiches made to order. They have a nice sitting area if you want to eat on site. There’s also convenient parking right in front.

B Balan

Amazing hot roast beef sandwich , bagels are very good !! Great staff

Nadeesha Lakmali

Best tasting and looking bagels hands down.

I was beside myself for a filling wonderful breakfast bagel. Thank you for a delicious meal.

Smileys has the best bagels and BEC around. Bagels are thick and fluffy, and BEC has the best ratios. When you ask for XC you get XC! A great price for a filling sandwich. Will always be my go to spot.

Bagels hot and fresh from the oven do you like when the butter melts into the chewy dough? Do you enjoy soft, fluffy cream cheese and the salty flavors of smoked salmon betwixt an "everything" variety? So much variety so much flavor. His the spot everytime.

Smileys is awesome! Workers are super friendly. Bacon egg and cheese on bagel was....according to my 6 year old nephew....."OFF THE CHARTS!" You will not be disappointed! Especially if u like crispy, well-done bacon on a dope bagel ;)

OUTSTANDING customer service! All the staff were friendly, courteous, extremely patient, and helpful. Avoiding the morning rush (there 9ish), my order was taken and filled in minutes. The self-serve coffee area had everything I needed and my bagel (baked onsite!) with cream cheese and bacon was *Mmm* delish...! The store was clean and bright... I'll definitely be going back again.

They have great tasting, hot, soft bagels!! I ordered a bacon, egg, and cheese on an everything bagel...Ahhh, let me tell you, I felt like I was biting into a piece of heaven. Yes, it may sound over the top, but when I'm here visiting Stateline Island, the first thing I want in the morning is exactly what I just told you. We don't get it that good upstate where I live!! You all are lucky!!! Enjoy!!!

I ordered bagels from them, and I have to say they tasted great and were a good size. The staff were very friendly and helpful.

Our favorite spot on the Island for bagels and sandwiches. Their customer service is top notch, always super friendly and our orders are always correct. Love this place!

Khris Garver

I was beside myself for a filling wonderful breakfast bagel. Thank you for a delicious meal.

Sandee

They have great tasting, hot, soft bagels!! I ordered a bacon, egg, and cheese on an everything bagel...Ahhh, let me tell you, I felt like I was biting into a piece of heaven. Yes, it may sound over the top, but when I'm here visiting Stateline Island, the first thing I want in the morning is exactly what I just told you. We don't get it that good upstate where I live!! You all are lucky!!! Enjoy!!!

Sebastian Wierzbicki

I ordered bagels from them, and I have to say they tasted great and were a good size. The staff were very friendly and helpful.

Jolene Perez

Our favorite spot on the Island for bagels and sandwiches. Their customer service is top notch, always super friendly and our orders are always correct. Love this place!

Anna Puchkoff

Smileys has the best bagels and BEC around. Bagels are thick and fluffy, and BEC has the best ratios. When you ask for XC you get XC! A great price for a filling sandwich. Will always be my go to spot.

Rachel Chaiken

OUTSTANDING customer service! All the staff were friendly, courteous, extremely patient, and helpful. Avoiding the morning rush (there 9ish), my order was taken and filled in minutes. The self-serve coffee area had everything I needed and my bagel (baked onsite!) with cream cheese and bacon was *Mmm* delish...! The store was clean and bright... I'll definitely be going back again.

Salina Itwaru

Bagels hot and fresh from the oven do you like when the butter melts into the chewy dough? Do you enjoy soft, fluffy cream cheese and the salty flavors of smoked salmon betwixt an "everything" variety? So much variety so much flavor. His the spot everytime.

Karen P

Smileys is awesome! Workers are super friendly. Bacon egg and cheese on bagel was....according to my 6 year old nephew....."OFF THE CHARTS!" You will not be disappointed! Especially if u like crispy, well-done bacon on a dope bagel ;)

Lunch hero's are good and reasonably priced. Egg sandwiches are good but expensive. The bagels aren't very good.

this store was recommended by a friend .good bagels.fresh most bagel stores have a bagel made somewhere else. this store makes them fresh. if it was just a little bit closer i would be there everyday

Another hidden gem.Brooklyn style bagels with assorted cream cheese selection.. The real deal is the Polish chef. James down kieblsa egg breakfast. Pierogies for lunch at a local deli. Did someone say Brighton Beach?? Nawh. Try Staten Island NY...

Smiley's is solid, it's clean and inviting inside, bagels are ok, overall probably a 7.2/10 for Staten island, won't let you down, I've been a few times, if you get the bagels toasted you'll have better luck. The owner is nice and usually close by if you have questions or concerns. Priced fairly well, as a matter of fact I might stop by here on my way back now that I'm thinking about it

Ultra Supremium

Smiley's is solid, it's clean and inviting inside, bagels are ok, overall probably a 7.2/10 for Staten island, won't let you down, I've been a few times, if you get the bagels toasted you'll have better luck. The owner is nice and usually close by if you have questions or concerns. Priced fairly well, as a matter of fact I might stop by here on my way back now that I'm thinking about it

Excellent bagels, great food. The only issue with this place is the $10 credit card minimum, a quick bagel and coffee in the morning is less than $10!

Thank you for reaching out to me I'll definitely give you guys another chance

Braulio Rachel

Thank you for reaching out to me I'll definitely give you guys another chance

I love the bagels, but the service could be better and their reward system on the Clover app is not giving free coffee anymore which is unfortunate because that’s the main reason why I started coming to this place I have over 200 pts but can even get a free small coffee…

This is the second time I went to smileys that I ordered a bagel with bacon and cream cheese and got the SMALLEST bit of cream cheese. This is so beyond cheap. Disappointed and won’t be coming back again.

Samantha Langis

This is the second time I went to smileys that I ordered a bagel with bacon and cream cheese and got the SMALLEST bit of cream cheese. This is so beyond cheap. Disappointed and won’t be coming back again.

I am not someone who writes negative reviews, and I usually do not take service complaints too seriously when I read them. This time I think it is worth paying attention. I stopped by Smiley’s today, grabbed a drink, and ordered a plain bagel. There were only two people in front of me, so I figured it would be quick. Instead, it turned into a really confusing experience. There is no clear line, no clear ordering spot, no pickup area, and everyone ends up huddled around the register trying to guess who is next. Even the employees seemed unsure. About five minutes into waiting, a guy walked in, ordered three plain bagels, cut through everyone, paid, and left before I even moved. Normally I would not care, but it showed how disorganized the place is. After that, every single customer was helped before me, even though I had been standing there the whole time. After waiting around 10 to 15 minutes, I finally asked about my order. The person at the register told me they had just sold the last plain bagels. I explained I placed my order before that customer even arrived and asked if the one I ordered had been placed aside for me. It had not. No solution was offered, so I handed back my drink and left. I have had decent experiences here before, but only when the place is empty. When it gets even a little busy, it feels like there is no system at all, and it ends up wasting your time. I am giving two stars because the food is good, but another experience like this would cause me to just take business elsewhere.

Michael Jacobsen

I am not someone who writes negative reviews, and I usually do not take service complaints too seriously when I read them. This time I think it is worth paying attention. I stopped by Smiley’s today, grabbed a drink, and ordered a plain bagel. There were only two people in front of me, so I figured it would be quick. Instead, it turned into a really confusing experience. There is no clear line, no clear ordering spot, no pickup area, and everyone ends up huddled around the register trying to guess who is next. Even the employees seemed unsure. About five minutes into waiting, a guy walked in, ordered three plain bagels, cut through everyone, paid, and left before I even moved. Normally I would not care, but it showed how disorganized the place is. After that, every single customer was helped before me, even though I had been standing there the whole time. After waiting around 10 to 15 minutes, I finally asked about my order. The person at the register told me they had just sold the last plain bagels. I explained I placed my order before that customer even arrived and asked if the one I ordered had been placed aside for me. It had not. No solution was offered, so I handed back my drink and left. I have had decent experiences here before, but only when the place is empty. When it gets even a little busy, it feels like there is no system at all, and it ends up wasting your time. I am giving two stars because the food is good, but another experience like this would cause me to just take business elsewhere.

Over Priced Is An Understatement… .75 Per Slice Of Cheese On My Sandwich. 1 Egg Sandwich and 1 Drink 13$.

Anyone ever have a bad experience with calling in a delivery with smileys bagels on victory blvd?? I did quite a few times. Every time I call I feel like I always have to repeat myself when giving in even the simplest order. Or even have to repeat myself when having to spell out my street address. Or they repeat themselves with “I can’t hear you”. I give in my order and it seems the girls answering the phone is always behind when I give my order and it makes me so impatient that I get discouraged and just hang up on them. Besides their good food I think whoever answers the phone could be a little better.

I don't how is the rest of the food, but I ordered salad and I couldn't eat it. Cherry tomatoes were sour like they were going bad, chicken tasted funky. The place looks very charming from outside but the ingredients aren't fresh.

Can't believe The Lox on a bagel they sent me

I live 3 blocks away. I ordered a salad and panini for lunch, see pictures. The salad was drowning in dressing and limp. The sandwich was soaking in mayo and even more limp then the salad. It took 1.5 hours to get to me. My wife ordered a garden salad and got a caesar salad, also drowning in dressing. She ordered a sandwich meal that is suppose to come with chips and a soda, neither of which arrived. When she called them up they yelled at her that it was a garden salad. They came and replaced the caesar with a garden salad, devoid of dressing. I guess its flood or famine when it comes to dressing. And for those of you that look at the picture and say " it couldn't have been that bad if you ate the whole sandwich" I didnt. I took the Turkey, rinsed it and gave a good portion of it to my dog. I will never order from them again.

Expired foods ! Today I bought some snack and a bread , that was expired! Cashier was excited and returned my cash ! Bad experience!

Riker MV

I live 3 blocks away. I ordered a salad and panini for lunch, see pictures. The salad was drowning in dressing and limp. The sandwich was soaking in mayo and even more limp then the salad. It took 1.5 hours to get to me. My wife ordered a garden salad and got a caesar salad, also drowning in dressing. She ordered a sandwich meal that is suppose to come with chips and a soda, neither of which arrived. When she called them up they yelled at her that it was a garden salad. They came and replaced the caesar with a garden salad, devoid of dressing. I guess its flood or famine when it comes to dressing. And for those of you that look at the picture and say " it couldn't have been that bad if you ate the whole sandwich" I didnt. I took the Turkey, rinsed it and gave a good portion of it to my dog. I will never order from them again.

Hemantha Jayasundara

Expired foods ! Today I bought some snack and a bread , that was expired! Cashier was excited and returned my cash ! Bad experience!

I had a small dispute with my order and kindly asked a question. Customer service at its finest, I was ignored and then walked away. Won’t be going back. Instead of going this direction for my bagels, I’ll drive the other way on victory and go to the other bagel store.

I asked for toasted bagels reminded him twice got home and they weren’t toasted .I should have known better and checked before I left the store bc it happened before. One of the bagels had grey/ blond hair in it . The chicken salad was just horrible .

I’m honestly appalled by their customer service. I came in requesting a turkey bacon, egg and cheese and when I got into the car, I took a bite and realized it was regular bacon. I go in explaining my situation and stating I can’t have bacon. They took the sandwich and saw that I took a bite into it and said this is your fault. You need to specify that you want turkey bacon. Instead of apologizing when I always say turkey bacon, as I don’t eat regular bacon for religious reasons they went ahead and said well there’s bacon all over the grill. I felt completely ridiculed and belittled. I hope you understand that you have customers from all different backgrounds and clearly Smiley Bagels is not inclusive to our Muslim community. Disgusting!!!

Alba Shahini

I’m honestly appalled by their customer service. I came in requesting a turkey bacon, egg and cheese and when I got into the car, I took a bite and realized it was regular bacon. I go in explaining my situation and stating I can’t have bacon. They took the sandwich and saw that I took a bite into it and said this is your fault. You need to specify that you want turkey bacon. Instead of apologizing when I always say turkey bacon, as I don’t eat regular bacon for religious reasons they went ahead and said well there’s bacon all over the grill. I felt completely ridiculed and belittled. I hope you understand that you have customers from all different backgrounds and clearly Smiley Bagels is not inclusive to our Muslim community. Disgusting!!!

Glenn

I had a small dispute with my order and kindly asked a question. Customer service at its finest, I was ignored and then walked away. Won’t be going back. Instead of going this direction for my bagels, I’ll drive the other way on victory and go to the other bagel store.

Noor Ali

I asked for toasted bagels reminded him twice got home and they weren’t toasted .I should have known better and checked before I left the store bc it happened before. One of the bagels had grey/ blond hair in it . The chicken salad was just horrible .