Tony’s New York Pizza

Logan Ellis

It’s amazing, I just came here for the first time since about 2010 (I moved away) this is still just as good and just as cost effective as ever. I got a massive slice of pepperoni pizza and a canned soda for $5.00. Honestly so stoked and surprised that these prices haven’t gone up with everything else. Keep it up guys!!!

queen alia (DarkShinigamiQueen)

Good cheese and tomatoes pizza. Excellent service. Quiet afternoon and good vibes.

Fast accurate delivery. Betty pleasant delivery people.

Pizza taste great! Get the antipasta salad. It is incredible! They have also sold us dough we take home to make our own. Always turns out amazing. Thank you Tony's

Still the best place to get pizza after many years. Quality has not dropped at all. Cheap prices and filling food is extremely helpful to your wallet. Everybody who works there is great, and nobody seems to dislike it. And no, despite what others say, they are not rude, and will not hang up on you if you ask for pickup or delivery. In my over 14 years of ordering over phone, they have always been friendly and patient with me while I describe my order. The only possible way I believe they would hang up on you is if you were being extremely rude and disorderly. You should come here to get your pizza fix.

The food is great, the prices are great and the customer service is great! I dont normally crave pizza but this place has had me craving pizza more often. Definitely try it out!

Absolutely the BEST Antipasta salad I have ever had. Everytime I order a pizza I gotta get the salad! I eat half of the salad in the car on the way home. My wife will kill me if I don't leave her at least half. True!... Pizza is incredible too!

Jill Alatorre

The food is great, the prices are great and the customer service is great! I dont normally crave pizza but this place has had me craving pizza more often. Definitely try it out!

Wade O

We've been enjoying Tony's since the 90s. The best!

David Brooke

Absolutely the BEST Antipasta salad I have ever had. Everytime I order a pizza I gotta get the salad! I eat half of the salad in the car on the way home. My wife will kill me if I don't leave her at least half. True!... Pizza is incredible too!

David Brooke

Pizza taste great! Get the antipasta salad. It is incredible! They have also sold us dough we take home to make our own. Always turns out amazing. Thank you Tony's

i am sicky

Still the best place to get pizza after many years. Quality has not dropped at all. Cheap prices and filling food is extremely helpful to your wallet. Everybody who works there is great, and nobody seems to dislike it. And no, despite what others say, they are not rude, and will not hang up on you if you ask for pickup or delivery. In my over 14 years of ordering over phone, they have always been friendly and patient with me while I describe my order. The only possible way I believe they would hang up on you is if you were being extremely rude and disorderly. You should come here to get your pizza fix.

The pizza is good, but not great. It’s a decent option if you don’t want to leave the Newbury Park area, however Ameci’s would be my first choice. I had a slice of pepperoni and a slice of Hawaiian in addition to a sub. They were all enjoyable. The sandwich was a bit light on meat and heavy on mayonnaise. Neither issue prevented me from eating and enjoying the sub though. The pizza is New York style. It wasn’t very memorable, which means it wasn’t so good I need to go back right away nor so bad I never want to go back. I’m pretty sure I’ll eat here again.

Michael Bailey

The pizza is good, but not great. It’s a decent option if you don’t want to leave the Newbury Park area, however Ameci’s would be my first choice. I had a slice of pepperoni and a slice of Hawaiian in addition to a sub. They were all enjoyable. The sandwich was a bit light on meat and heavy on mayonnaise. Neither issue prevented me from eating and enjoying the sub though. The pizza is New York style. It wasn’t very memorable, which means it wasn’t so good I need to go back right away nor so bad I never want to go back. I’m pretty sure I’ll eat here again.

I live "just up the hill" so Tony's is my default pizza place. I try to get there early in the week each week for a (double) slice. It's great that seating is now available, both outdoors (as it has been for some weeks) and indoors as well. The pizza is very consistent, and consistently good, which makes sense since there has been very little turnover in the "back of the house" staff for many years. The "front of the house" staff turns over a little more often, but I occasionally see the young women from the counter showing up years later as customers. The prices have amazingly stayed pretty consistent over the years as well. One other thing that has remained constant across many years is the ice tea dispenser. The "out of order" sign itself has faded, the silicone caulk that holds the dispenser down to the counter has yellowed, and there's no sign of any effort to repair it. Doesn't bother me; I drink Diet Coke.

Nice, friendly, clean place. Ordered "a slice" (which is really two) plus onions and meatballs as toppings. Good sauce. Generous servings (although the onions were placed cold and raw on top -- next time I'll ask for them to be placed under the meatball slices so that they cook.) Good crust, if a little undercooked.

We’ve been loyal customers of Tony’s Pizza for years and genuinely love your food — which is why I wanted to share some honest feedback about our order tonight. This is the first time we’ve ever had an experience like this, so I’m hoping it was simply an off night or a very busy evening. Unfortunately, every item in our order had an issue. The 6” meatball sub only had three meatballs inside, and the cannoli we ordered for dessert was burned. The cheese ravioli itself was fine, but the garlic bread that came with it was also badly burned. The biggest disappointment was the “Tony’s Sub.” It was completely drenched in oil — so much that it was dripping onto the floor when my son unwrapped it. The vegetables inside were cut into very large chunks that kept falling out of both ends, making it extremely messy and difficult to eat. He ultimately gave up and had to throw it away. We’re sharing this because we truly enjoy Tony’s Pizza and order often. The quality is usually excellent, which is why tonight’s experience surprised us. We wanted to bring it to your attention in case something went wrong in the kitchen, and we hope to see things back to the great standard we’re used to next time.We’ve been loyal customers of Tony’s Pizza for years and genuinely love your food — which is why I wanted to share some honest feedback about our order tonight. This is the first time we’ve ever had an experience like this, so I’m hoping it was simply an off night or a very busy evening. Unfortunately, every item in our order had an issue. The 6” meatball sub only had three meatballs inside, and the cannoli we ordered for dessert was burned. The cheese ravioli itself was fine, but the garlic bread that came with it was also badly burned. The biggest disappointment was the “Tony’s Sub.” It was completely drenched in oil — so much that it was dripping onto the floor when my son unwrapped it. The vegetables inside were cut into very large chunks that kept falling out of both ends, making it extremely messy and difficult to eat. He ultimately gave up and had to throw it away. We’re sharing this because we truly enjoy Tony’s Pizza and order often. The quality is usually excellent, which is why tonight’s experience surprised us. We wanted to bring it to your attention in case something went wrong in the kitchen, and we hope to see things back to the great standard we’re used to next time.

I visited a while ago. Cool local spot! My friend liked his pizza. I got the wings. The wings were unusually spicier than what you might expect from a place like this: hot sauce coating but then seasoned extra with some sort of pepper-type rub on top. I like spice and didn't mind the unique twist but if you are sensitive to heat or want the basic flavor you'd typically think of for a pizza spot wing, then I wouldn't recommend it. This place is pricey, but it is local.

Lyle Olson

I visited a while ago. Cool local spot! My friend liked his pizza. I got the wings. The wings were unusually spicier than what you might expect from a place like this: hot sauce coating but then seasoned extra with some sort of pepper-type rub on top. I like spice and didn't mind the unique twist but if you are sensitive to heat or want the basic flavor you'd typically think of for a pizza spot wing, then I wouldn't recommend it. This place is pricey, but it is local.

Steve Johnson

I live "just up the hill" so Tony's is my default pizza place. I try to get there early in the week each week for a (double) slice. It's great that seating is now available, both outdoors (as it has been for some weeks) and indoors as well. The pizza is very consistent, and consistently good, which makes sense since there has been very little turnover in the "back of the house" staff for many years. The "front of the house" staff turns over a little more often, but I occasionally see the young women from the counter showing up years later as customers. The prices have amazingly stayed pretty consistent over the years as well. One other thing that has remained constant across many years is the ice tea dispenser. The "out of order" sign itself has faded, the silicone caulk that holds the dispenser down to the counter has yellowed, and there's no sign of any effort to repair it. Doesn't bother me; I drink Diet Coke.

Bill Weber

Nice, friendly, clean place. Ordered "a slice" (which is really two) plus onions and meatballs as toppings. Good sauce. Generous servings (although the onions were placed cold and raw on top -- next time I'll ask for them to be placed under the meatball slices so that they cook.) Good crust, if a little undercooked.

The pizza is mediocre. Additionally, I called my order in about 3 hours in advance for a family get-together (3 pizzas and 12 wings) and when I got there, they made me wait an additional 20 minutes after being told it would be ready in an additional 10. They charge for ranch with the wings and despite being assured twice that the ranch was in the bag, I had to again go and ask for my ranch when it wasn't. The bbq sauce on the wings was almost black in color so no one even touched them and the hot wings were not much more appetizing.

Jacob

The pizza is mediocre. Additionally, I called my order in about 3 hours in advance for a family get-together (3 pizzas and 12 wings) and when I got there, they made me wait an additional 20 minutes after being told it would be ready in an additional 10. They charge for ranch with the wings and despite being assured twice that the ranch was in the bag, I had to again go and ask for my ranch when it wasn't. The bbq sauce on the wings was almost black in color so no one even touched them and the hot wings were not much more appetizing.

This was the second time I’ve ordered a pizza from this company, and it was awful. There was almost no tomato sauce. The mushrooms that were added were thrown only into the center area Leaving almost 3 inches (on a14” pizza) from the crust with nothing. I had to come home and doctor up the pizza to make it edible. Maybe they’re cutting back but this is pathetic for $17 buyer beware.

I am a long time customer of Tonys! I noticed that they do a Good job when pizza is ordered during non-prime time. If you order during the dinner hours - expect zero quality. This is the second time that Tony's sent me a pizza that taste worse than the Supermarket pizza. $28 for a pizza with almost no cheese. When I called up to raise an issue, Tony's apologized and promised to add an extra topping my next visit. So, a $2 topping after dropping almost $60 on 2 tomato pizzas...sounds fair to me. :( Last time ever for me...can't see them staying in business with the combination of abysmal product and poor service.

Long time loyal customer. Tonys was always good service, good food. Now after 3 different attempts to stomach this garbage there calling pizza is a joke. No more tonys. I'll drive to thousand oaks to get decent pizza. To anyone reading this save your money. Tonys is a disaster. Don't eat here

Steve Mendelson

This was the second time I’ve ordered a pizza from this company, and it was awful. There was almost no tomato sauce. The mushrooms that were added were thrown only into the center area Leaving almost 3 inches (on a14” pizza) from the crust with nothing. I had to come home and doctor up the pizza to make it edible. Maybe they’re cutting back but this is pathetic for $17 buyer beware.

Greg Docs

Long time loyal customer. Tonys was always good service, good food. Now after 3 different attempts to stomach this garbage there calling pizza is a joke. No more tonys. I'll drive to thousand oaks to get decent pizza. To anyone reading this save your money. Tonys is a disaster. Don't eat here

PAUL Lindemann

I am a long time customer of Tonys! I noticed that they do a Good job when pizza is ordered during non-prime time. If you order during the dinner hours - expect zero quality. This is the second time that Tony's sent me a pizza that taste worse than the Supermarket pizza. $28 for a pizza with almost no cheese. When I called up to raise an issue, Tony's apologized and promised to add an extra topping my next visit. So, a $2 topping after dropping almost $60 on 2 tomato pizzas...sounds fair to me. :( Last time ever for me...can't see them staying in business with the combination of abysmal product and poor service.

Felix TheKat

Hands down the WORST pizza I have ever had!!!! Way undercooked, doughy, dry, hardly any cheese. We ordered 4 different ones and they all sucked. Overpriced, cost us $90 and when we called to complain, they offered us a $10 credit. Ha!!! I don't want credit, I'm never ever going back there!! After some pushing, my sister finally got them to refund us some of the money if we brought the uneaten pizzas back. They gave us $40 back which they were reluctant to do but still never coming here again. I highly suggest you go to Ameci's and don't even bother with this ghetto place.