Really nice staff and enjoyed the quick slice.

Great pizza, pepperoni stuffed crust!!

Very tasty plain cheese slice.

Absolutely perfect everything, good service good food

Best pizza around ... by far

Great Food. Fast Delivery!

Very good as always !!

Loved this place, when I first visited..

Best slice of pizza in tivoli

Rob makes a great pizza

EVEN SLICES ARE DELICIOUS.

Our pizza stop when we are in town

Good food

Zach is the best.

Great pizza!

Great local standby.

Best pizza around

Excellent pizza and lots of different slice types to choose from. Perfect NY style thin crust.

Been ordering here for over 20 years! Love the food. Good prices. Great sauce 👍👍

The best pizza by the slice I think I’ve ever had. Mushroom stuffed crust and plain cheeses slices 🤤

Really good pizza shop, always fresh.

Great pizza and great customer service I deliver for fed ex to them and they never let me down

Best Pizza in Hudson Valley! Simple thin crust and always consistently awesome.

Great pizza bring your own sauce and there's the door if you don't like pizza

Great alternative to the crappy pizza Hudson valley has to offer. It's not NYC zza, but it's close-ish. Mushroom is a must. Cheers

The pizza here is unlike any other, it's a little pricey but definitely worth it!

I give this place 5 starts ALWAYS!! THIS is coming from the guy who comes all the way from Hillsdale N.Y. just for their Wings. Everything else is 5 star too.

Food is excellent. Prices are fair. Customer service is great.

Really good pizza and calzones. The sauce that comes with the calzones is amazing and he gives you plenty of it.

I love this type of pizza. 5 stars just on the pizza.

Used to come here and munch on a sloppy slice while listening to the sports radio. Great spot.

Great place, good food. A1 calzones

Surprisingly tasty slice of pizza from this small town pizzeria.

Great pizza and prices are reasonable.

Great pizza. We eat here probably more often than is reasonable. Their "lasagna" slices are the best thing on the planet.

Great food for a fair price! The pizza was excellent and the subs had the best bread that I've had in a long time. Thank you and keep up the no spin zone ...

Great pizza, very friendly staff, I will definitely frequent this spot.

I just discovered this Gem. Food is great. Small and more simple items. Perfect for a lunch at home. Take out. Employees are very welcoming, personable, helpful. It’s one of my new favorite places. I do have to say i was a little disappointed that they dont have balsamic dressing or glaze. HOWEVER< THE ITALIAN dressing makes up for it. It was so good i wanted more and more salad. The Greek salad is very flavorful with every bite. AWSOME PLACE TO EAT

Cute little pizza restaurant, delicious pizza, great location in town.

Quick service! Perfect spot after the lake! Variety of slices. Thin crust

Great tasting food, fantastic service. Very friendly!

Great food Great family vibs

Crystal Novotny

I just discovered this Gem. Food is great. Small and more simple items. Perfect for a lunch at home. Take out. Employees are very welcoming, personable, helpful. It’s one of my new favorite places. I do have to say i was a little disappointed that they dont have balsamic dressing or glaze. HOWEVER< THE ITALIAN dressing makes up for it. It was so good i wanted more and more salad. The Greek salad is very flavorful with every bite. AWSOME PLACE TO EAT

Andy Sram

Cute little pizza restaurant, delicious pizza, great location in town.

Natalia Zamparini

Quick service! Perfect spot after the lake! Variety of slices. Thin crust

Chad “Zhor” Zepeda

Great tasting food, fantastic service. Very friendly!

Ray “SUPREME” Czumak

Great food Great family vibs

As a REAL New York City native (unlike 99% of the reviewers), I can tell you hat Broadway is more like an old school NYC slice shop than you would think. From the flavor to the quality to the service...do they make mistakes? Sure. Everyone does. Is their pizza great? Yes it is. So are their dishes. Until recently I had only been a weekender for 40 years. I've been eating here since they opened. It has always been consistent and delicious! The staff are super friendly as are the owners who work on-site every day. The inside is sparse, and no, I don't care what newspaper is on the table (NY Post) or what's on the TV (usually a show like NCIS or Smallville). You don't come here for the media...YOU COME FOR THE FOOD!!!

We are from Pittsburgh and were camping in the area, and after a long day of travel, we were looking for some NY pizza and this place did not disappoint! Very tiny shop, folks were very nice and made us two delicious pies! We tried the cheese pizza and “the works”, both were great! i’ve never had meatballs on a pizza and I was pleasantly surprised! A+!

Great pizza and onion rings

Friendly staff and quick service. Pizza was really good with a crispy bottom. Great spot to get a quick slice

Ordered the sausage slice and it had pieces of sausage in the crust too. Garlic knots were very good. Delicious!

Stopped in this little pizza shop in Tivoli and I wasn't expecting much. To my surprise this was a Great piece of Pizza, what a Great find in upstate NY. Definitely will be back for more of this in future trips up here. Thank you guys.

Hands down, the best pizza in the Hudson Valley; State of New York; United States; and the world for that matter. Head chef, Brian, is a master of his craft and an all around terrific guy.

Delicious!!!!!! Pizza is absolutely phenomenal. Prices are fair. Services is always wonderful! Phones are often very busy, but probably because of the high amount of business they received. 10/10 recommend!!

I live in Yivoli NY and I come here occasionally. The pizza was good but the place was small. I guess I kind of liked that about it. It feel like "my spot" and nothing better than great pizza at a fair price. Its really nice having it around it is the only place I can afford around here HAHA maybe the orher busnesses will learn a thing or 2 from these guys lol

I've been eating pizza from Broadway for at least the last 15 years. It's always good pizza with a nice chewy crust. Spicy chicken is my personal favorite. A local staple

Sean-Patrick Hillman

As a REAL New York City native (unlike 99% of the reviewers), I can tell you hat Broadway is more like an old school NYC slice shop than you would think. From the flavor to the quality to the service...do they make mistakes? Sure. Everyone does. Is their pizza great? Yes it is. So are their dishes. Until recently I had only been a weekender for 40 years. I've been eating here since they opened. It has always been consistent and delicious! The staff are super friendly as are the owners who work on-site every day. The inside is sparse, and no, I don't care what newspaper is on the table (NY Post) or what's on the TV (usually a show like NCIS or Smallville). You don't come here for the media...YOU COME FOR THE FOOD!!!

Patty Ewing

We are from Pittsburgh and were camping in the area, and after a long day of travel, we were looking for some NY pizza and this place did not disappoint! Very tiny shop, folks were very nice and made us two delicious pies! We tried the cheese pizza and “the works”, both were great! i’ve never had meatballs on a pizza and I was pleasantly surprised! A+!

Gregory Reinhart

Friendly staff and quick service. Pizza was really good with a crispy bottom. Great spot to get a quick slice

Karen Anglero

Ordered the sausage slice and it had pieces of sausage in the crust too. Garlic knots were very good. Delicious!

eddie dixon

Stopped in this little pizza shop in Tivoli and I wasn't expecting much. To my surprise this was a Great piece of Pizza, what a Great find in upstate NY. Definitely will be back for more of this in future trips up here. Thank you guys.

Steven Durkin

Great pizza, very friendly staff, I will definitely frequent this spot.

Harry O'Donnell

Hands down, the best pizza in the Hudson Valley; State of New York; United States; and the world for that matter. Head chef, Brian, is a master of his craft and an all around terrific guy.

Heidi Baschnagel

Delicious!!!!!! Pizza is absolutely phenomenal. Prices are fair. Services is always wonderful! Phones are often very busy, but probably because of the high amount of business they received. 10/10 recommend!!

Casey Brown

I've been eating pizza from Broadway for at least the last 15 years. It's always good pizza with a nice chewy crust. Spicy chicken is my personal favorite. A local staple

Sebastian

I live in Yivoli NY and I come here occasionally. The pizza was good but the place was small. I guess I kind of liked that about it. It feel like "my spot" and nothing better than great pizza at a fair price. Its really nice having it around it is the only place I can afford around here HAHA maybe the orher busnesses will learn a thing or 2 from these guys lol

Straight up pizza joint.

Really good pizza

Delicious

Good stuff

Great pizza

Nice stuffed-crust pizza.

Good pizza ok food

Favorite place to get Pizza in the area.

Their pizza reminds me of the pre-foodie era, NYC street pizza that I ate growing up. And with the strangely limited hours of all the other Tivoli restaurants and shops, they're often the only meal in town

One of the best pizza places in Red Hook. Highly recommended for whenever you just want pizza!

Pretty good pizza here! Whenever I'm visiting Bard and want some good eats this is where I'm going! Nuff said!

Great selection, I love the Sicilian slices and their Italian sub.

Best pizza in Dutchess County in my opinion.

Good pzza, lousy place to eat it. Loud TV on with really old TV shows, only 2 small tables. The outside looks charming, the inside not all all. So good for takeout.

Nice place, good people, great pizza and wings. Fair prices and fast delivery. Def a solid place to get pizza

This broadway pizza has wonderful food I especially loved there popcorn chicken but they got rid of it sadly pretty good pizza tho a bit on the greasy side but still good

No-frills place, but their pizza is even better than it looks! Bonus points for baking toppings (mushrooms in this case) into the crust.

If you find yourself in Tivoli, like I did, stop in and get yourself a nice slice of pizza. It's a small, quaint little spot with a few tables. You might find a couple of newspapers to read on some of the tables why you wait. The pizza is great and the young lady at the counter was pleasantly happy and smiling. So refreshing to see.😎

Danielle Kenyon

This broadway pizza has wonderful food I especially loved there popcorn chicken but they got rid of it sadly pretty good pizza tho a bit on the greasy side but still good

Anne Hathaway did not spit in my food.

No-frills place, but their pizza is even better than it looks! Bonus points for baking toppings (mushrooms in this case) into the crust.

Rick Surrano & 1-4-5

If you find yourself in Tivoli, like I did, stop in and get yourself a nice slice of pizza. It's a small, quaint little spot with a few tables. You might find a couple of newspapers to read on some of the tables why you wait. The pizza is great and the young lady at the counter was pleasantly happy and smiling. So refreshing to see.😎

Eah.. could always be better

Delivering to Germantown is a plus. Could have special deals from time to time. The cherry on top was they were open on July 4th.

You're tired. Maybe you've been traveling through the back roads of the Hudson Valley half the day, or you've exhausted yourself vegetating. You're hungry but can't summon the energy to cook, but you also don't want to tidy yourself up for a meal out on the town. Now that you think about it, you don't want to spend much money, either. That's where Broadway Pizza comes in: a comfy, quick, cheap meal. You want pizza fast, you get pizza fast. When you want to keep things simple and cram three or four slices of pieces into your mouth without a notion of propriety, this is the place for you. It's not glamorous, but it doesn't want to be.

Rachael Gunning

You're tired. Maybe you've been traveling through the back roads of the Hudson Valley half the day, or you've exhausted yourself vegetating. You're hungry but can't summon the energy to cook, but you also don't want to tidy yourself up for a meal out on the town. Now that you think about it, you don't want to spend much money, either. That's where Broadway Pizza comes in: a comfy, quick, cheap meal. You want pizza fast, you get pizza fast. When you want to keep things simple and cram three or four slices of pieces into your mouth without a notion of propriety, this is the place for you. It's not glamorous, but it doesn't want to be.

I live in Tivoli Ny and there Pizza used too be good,that place now is the worst place to get a pie at let alone any thing else,hire another crack head,You suck third time I get a screwed up pie!I will not include any photos,there already on Facebook!

Ordered a hot meatball sub and fried mushrooms. Meatballs were victims of shrinkflation, were cut on half with the round side up soaring to be full meatballs. Barely any sauce, the sauce the was there was, bland and not much flavor. Mushrooms were good, but personal preference is not crispy. Maybe pizza was the way to go.

Rick Ahrens

Ordered a hot meatball sub and fried mushrooms. Meatballs were victims of shrinkflation, were cut on half with the round side up soaring to be full meatballs. Barely any sauce, the sauce the was there was, bland and not much flavor. Mushrooms were good, but personal preference is not crispy. Maybe pizza was the way to go.

I can’t believe that they don’t wear masks and gloves during their working time!

Pizza was OK guy just complained about wanting to close and be out of there

They never answer on Saturdays

Food took over an hour to arrive down the street side order of meatballs and they give 2 tiny meatballs the food tastes like garbage and they're rude