Kathryn Wales

One of the best places for a slice in the area! The pizza dough was baked to perfection and the sauce was the perfect balance of flavors. Must go for the charred pepperoni grandma slice!

Kalvin Thompson

Wow the pizza is so good!. Was in the area, and knew about Dave's monster review of this place. Did not disappoint. Most notable about the pizza, is the sauce flavor. Very flavorful. Cup pepperoni on the pepperoni slices. A very tight indoor shop, with surprisingly more seating than expected. A few tables outside to sit and enjoy as well. The service was friendly and quick. The place was very busy, at times the line almost out the door. The pizza was better than some of the Dave high scores I tried in New York City, ahem johns of times square for example. Will definitely be back.

Jeff Dyke

Ate here a couple of weeks ago while visiting my daughter. Really cool, no frills place that has a long time neighborhood feel to it. Service was friendly. Atmosphere was old school, busy, Brooklyn. Slices were fantastic, great flavor and crunch. Will be back.

J Acharya

Delicious pizza joint! We got the Margarita slice and garlic knot! They use quality ingredients and you can taste it. Highly recommend going here. Also grab a garlic knot, it’s done right unlike a lot of other places. It’s loaded with garlic bits and is buttery.

Monique Salas

This was great. They gave me the pizza nice and hot, the crust was slightly crunch. The garlic knot dough was nice and soft in the center and crispy on the outside. The pepperoni was thick. And the marinara sauce tastes fresh. I will definitely come back.

Dessa R

Another cozy pizza joint in Williamsburg. Thought the pepperoni slice and Margherita slice were ok (pepperoni was on the salty side? Liked the Margherita slightly better)…both large slices. They sell whole pies and slices! Super cozy with limited seating and some stools along the window. Friendly service.

Richard Nunez

Classic plain slices and classic pepperoni slices and large garlic knots. Very good

Jeffrey Gomez

They make a decent slice here at Williamsburg Pizza. The aesthetic definitely fits the shop and it’s in a good area. I tried a variety of the slices and Margherita was my favorite. It was my first time trying the Sophia Loren and it was not bad. Service is good here. Decent pizza.

+10

chinosn1per

I took it to go block away, my pepperoni roll was never heated at all cold and the slice was warm, i was less than a block away

Julian Flores

I’ve been here four times now, and three out of four times they’ve been out of the vegan pepperoni slice. If it sells that well, why not just keep more on hand? That said, the cashier did offer to add vegan pepperoni to another veggie slice, which I really appreciated.

Michelle W

Stopped by this pizza spot twice during my last trip as it was close to where I was staying and open late for a bite post-concert. What we got: - Sofia Loren Slice - Pepperoni Slice - Margherita Slice - Garlic Knot Final thoughts: Spot is okay, but I've had much better pizza elsewhere. I found the slices to be thin and crispy, but also quite oily and lacking in the cheese department (though the bites with mozz were great). I like my pizza saucier and with more cheese, but that's just my taste. A protip if you get a garlic knot is to save that marinara sauce and add it to your left over slice if you also like a little more sauce!

+2

Evelyn Nogueras

After several times of disappointments. I had to take down my previous review. Ever since they changed the night staff and Ian is not there I always get burnt pizza. Tonight they really turned a exciting take out moment to a disappointing one :-( So I guess I will be looking for another spot.