Sal & Carmine Pizza
Pizza · Broadway
About Sal & Carmine Pizza
In our cozy corner of Broadway, we serve up old-school, New York-style pizza that's been perfected over time. Amidst exposed brick walls and a handful of tables, we bring people together with flavors that never fail to please. Reviewers rave about our pies, praising the perfect balance of sauce, che...
In our cozy corner of Broadway, we serve up old-school, New York-style pizza that's been perfected over time. Amidst exposed brick walls and a handful of tables, we bring people together with flavors that never fail to please. Reviewers rave about our pies, praising the perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and crust. The atmosphere is intimate, making every visit feel like a favorite gathering spot for friends and family. We're proud to offer a taste of authentic NYC pizza, just as it's been enjoyed for generations – come see why we've become a local favorite in our little slice of Broadway.
What Customers Say About Sal & Carmine Pizza
Sal & Carmine's is a beloved spot for classic NY-style pizza, especially the plain cheese slice. Customers rave about the foldable texture, perfect sauce-to-cheese ratio, and nostalgic ambiance. Some find the sauce too sweet or the pizza too greasy.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: Make sure the slice is fresh, recently out of the oven. Ordering a whole pie ensures freshness.
Features
What to see nearby
Data from Wikidata
Explore the area around Sal & Carmine Pizza
Sal & Carmine Pizza is located in Broadway, surrounded by cultural and historical points of interest. Here are some of the most notable places nearby.
Historical Heritage
- Iglesia Episcopal de San Miguel (Manhattan) (A 253m) — church building in Manhattan, United States of America Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos
- Master Apartments (A 262m) — apartment building in Manhattan Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos
- Trinity Evangelical Lutheran Church of Manhattan (A 269m) — church building in Manhattan, United States of America Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos
- Riverside Park (A 626m) — public park on the Upper West Side of the borough of Manhattan in New York City Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos
Religious Buildings
- Ansche Chesed (A 139m) — Synagogue on Manhattan's Upper West Side
- Church of the Ascension, Roman Catholic (A 449m) — church building in Manhattan, United States of America
Parks & Gardens
- Happy Warrior Playground (A 352m) — park in the United States of America
- Straus Park (A 377m) — park in Manhattan, New York City, United States of America
Other Points of Interest
- Monumento conmemorativo a los bomberos (A 329m) — monumento en Manhattan, Nueva York
- East River Savings Bank building (A 470m) — branch building of the East River Savings Bank
Data from Wikidata
Frequently asked questions about Sal & Carmine Pizza
Sal & Carmine Pizza Broadway Reviews
I had the plain slice since the cheese here is vegetarian friendly. Service was great. Small place to eat in the back very nostalgic.
I’m so glad I took only one cheese slice ($4). It was huge! And heavy with all the cheese and salt. But man it was delicious. When I’m in NYC again, I’ll definitely re-visit this place.
Came hours away for this pizza and it was totally worth it! Thank you again!
It's a nice place with a great ambiance. Pizza is always fresh. I've never had a bad slice from there. Whenever I'm in the neighborhood with my friends, I go here. I have had many friends fall in love with the place. If you're looking for the classic New York slice, this is where to go.
Arguably, the best pizza in NYC, but not the most popular (or best service/production so theres some inconsistancy) so u have to make sure the slice is fresh (recently out of the oven, worth the wait) A tip: order a fresh pie for yourself...always fresh and u can pick your fave slice (more sauce vs cheese, welldone vs under). For NY Slice novices, never order the specialty slices on display, ie STALE Pizza. Bon Appetite :)
Classic NY slice. Perfect!! Large slice with correct amount of sauce and cheese. Great texture - foldable with no flop. Really loved it and will return.
Straight cheese slice. Phenomenal. True classic pizza men here
Everytime i take a bite of this pizza I think to myself man I love being in New York City man. I just happened to stumble upon this place one time when I was lost in the city and I wanted a quick bite to eat. The place looked quaint enough uh nothing stood out nothing fancy just straight to business. The first bite you take is going to surprise you, the second one is going to convince you. Even once you're done and you get to the CRUST, you're not wasting that crust that's part of the greatness. If you took your time out today to read this I believe you're a pizza connoisseur try this pizza you'll either like it or love it and what else can you ask for from a New York SLICE.
5 star for authentic slice served on a paper plate in an old style shop. Fast service, perfect slice every time, both traditional pizza pie and the delicious square, thick crust slice (my favorite). Eat on the street or sit at the few small tables in the back and you will be joined by a few locals, kids with a caregiver, and guys on break. Please don’t ever close 🙏🏼
Sal and Carmine Pizza has the best pizza I have ever had. The aunts were fighting over the crust and they don’t even like crust! Even my grandma who has a very strict diet made an exception for this sublime pizza. Sal and Carmine is celebrating its 68th anniversary! If you like pizza, even if you have dietary restrictions, TRUST ME, you will love 🤩this pizza! Would HIGHLY recommend!
Sal and Carmine’s on the Upper West Side is a true gem for pizza lovers! I ordered a pepperoni and sausage pizza, and it was absolutely delicious. The pizza was generously topped with a rich, flavorful sauce that perfectly complemented the savory toppings. The crust had just the right amount of crispiness—light and airy but still with that satisfying crunch. What makes this place even better are the fair prices, especially for the PIZZA SIZE you’re getting. If you’re in the neighborhood and craving an authentic New York slice, Sal and Carmine’s is definitely worth a visit! Also! The place boasts a huge interior space and a lot of seating too!
Sal & Carmine Pizza always hits the spot! To me, their pizza is underrated (which I don't mind because that means fewer people haha). Compared to all of the pizzerias in the neighborhood that sell *street pizza* they have the best. The sauce is a perfect balance of sweetness with savory. You can tell that they use fresh mozzarella. The crust is not too thick and not too thin either. If you want that crunch, ask them to heat your slice for a bit longer than usual. My bf and I always stop by to chat with the pizza maker and cashier. Both are great guys. We've never had a bad experience or a bad slice/pie. If you're in the neighborhood, definitely stop by to get a slice. You won't regret it. P.S. They're selling icees for a dollar (2 big scoops) you can't beat that deal, especially with this heat.
Very good pizza, not the best I've had in NYC, it was a bit too greasy for my taste but if you're in the area and looking to get a NY slice, this is a solid spot. Staff were very friendly, too.
Should be renamed Sal & Carmine’s Cheese Monster Pizza. A solid slice that delivers. I personally like the sauce and if you like a lot of cheese then you’ll probably rate this higher than I did. Overall - 8.0 Crust - really nice colour but taste is very plain Topping - so cheesy Sauce - nice and sweet Price - $4
Visited Sal & Carmine's Pizza two days ago. Pizza variety selection is excellent. Smells great. Sat in the back and chilled with my kids and a bud. Not too expensive...perfectly suitable for an NYC street slice of pizza.
The cheese is right, the crust is right, but the sauce is off. It is too tomato paste heavy, which leads to a tangier and sweeter sauce. If that’s your preference, this might be your spot, but for me it left a tangy taste in my mouth and wasn’t a balanced slice.
Tried the Margherita - the dough was really good, but the sauce tasted like plain tomato paste, too strong and unbalanced. A bit disappointing overall.
Honestly, I was a bit disappointed when I came here. I had looked at this place online to find a nice spot to eat with a friend to celebrate something. I had seen a lot of high rated reviews, many saying how this was “a rather iconic place in the upper west side,” and had high expectations for this place, but didn’t have the best experience. The place felt rather small and crammed, with only a few places to sit. Besides that, the food didn’t look the most appetizing. It was alright, but I had expected better. I’d probably look somewhere else for good pizza.
So average, it’s good. I guess. Regular Slice: 3.25/5 ($4) Sausage slice: 3/5 ($5) Closes at 9pm: 1/5 Destination: no Crust too thick, sauce is bland, cheese is too oily. 3rd best slice between 96th - 103rd.
Service is fine but the pizza has become trash. I moved up here about a month ago and I've tried three pies, two New York style and one margarite. I'm gonna include a picture of the margarita I just got. This thing is a joke. I ate two slices and you can see all the extra sauce that came off. Disgusting. And look at this cheese... It's so rubbery it didn't even melt into the sauce at all. Mad gross and it cost me over $30. Whatever this place did to earn it's reputation in the past, it's Nasty now. UPDATE: look how salty the owners are responding :''') His advice is just to make your own pizza, instead of buying his. We agree on this!
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
No se encontraron idiomas
Explore Your Area
32 Photos
Explore Sal & Carmine Pizza's photos
About Sal & Carmine Pizza
How to get there
2671 Broadway, New York, NY 10025
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
2671 Broadway, New York, NY 10025
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Synagogue on Manhattan's Upper West Side
church building in Manhattan, United States of America
apartment building in Manhattan
church building in Manhattan, United States of America
monumento en Manhattan, Nueva York
park in the United States of America
park in Manhattan, New York City, United States of America
church building in Manhattan, United States of America
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Sal & Carmine Pizza and other restaurants
Earn Points at Sal & Carmine Pizza!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Sal & Carmine Pizza
🏆 Rewards at Sal & Carmine Pizza
10% Discount
At Sal & Carmine Pizza
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu