Old Stone Jug
Bar · Hamilton
About Old Stone Jug
Located in Hamilton, Old Stone Jug offers a bright, clean, and welcoming atmosphere perfect for solo dining or gathering with friends. The establishment features both spacious indoor seating and outdoor tables, complemented by a large, accessible parking lot. Known for serving local specialties incl...
Located in Hamilton, Old Stone Jug offers a bright, clean, and welcoming atmosphere perfect for solo dining or gathering with friends. The establishment features both spacious indoor seating and outdoor tables, complemented by a large, accessible parking lot. Known for serving local specialties including hearty subs like the Italian Stallion, chicken bacon ranch, and classic roast beef options, the kitchen delivers piping hot, flavorful meals at an affordable price. The friendly staff goes above and beyond to ensure every guest leaves satisfied, whether ordering for dine-in, takeout, or delivery. With consistent attention to detail and genuine kindness from the team, this local favorite provides a comfortable setting for lunch and dinner alike.
What Customers Say About Old Stone Jug
Old Stone Jug is a popular sub shop known for its delicious, generously filled sandwiches and friendly staff, especially owner Will. The chicken bacon ranch and Philly cheesesteak are highly recommended. Some customers have experienced longer wait times and inconsistencies in quality.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: The staff is willing to customize orders, so ask for the Chicken Bacon Ranch on a spinach wrap.
Features
What to see nearby
Data from Wikidata
Explore the area around Old Stone Jug
Old Stone Jug is located in Hamilton, surrounded by cultural and historical points of interest. Here are some of the most notable places nearby.
Historical Heritage
- George Eastman House (A 835m) — film and photography museum and archive in Rochester, New York, United States Hito histórico nacional
Museums
- Memorial Art Gallery (A 739m) — museo de arte de la Universidad de Rochester, Nueva York, Estados Unidos
- The National Museum of Play (A 952m) — museo nacional del juguete y el juego de Estados Unidos
Other Points of Interest
- Warner Observatory (A 321m)
Data from Wikidata
Frequently asked questions about Old Stone Jug
Old Stone Jug Hamilton Reviews
Amazing! Found this place by happenstance. Stopped by for a sandwich and a refreshing beverage and was not disappointed. I got the Small Turkey Sub with a side of pasta salad and it was one of the best sandwiches I’ve had. Definitely will come back again!
The BEST subs and salads! This is a REAL Sub shop. You won't be disappointed with whatever you choose. Staff is friendly and professional.
Ordered an "Italian stallion" online having no idea what it was. Omg I want 5 of them. Thing was loaded with sausage and fillings for $10, piping hot and cheesy. So good
I mean honestly this is a staple in Rochester. I didn't see any old timers around to ask about the history of this amazing place but the gentlemen working were great. They even have different flavors of pickles. ⏸️ horseradish just to name a few.
Guy who cashed me out was super friendly generous and willing to make my meal soon before close. Was very appreciative of my business and I was very appreciative of the small conversation we had along with the 10/10 steak sub & cannoli’s. Great to see there are still good people left 🙏🏽 ✝️
Look at how picturesque the Italian sausage is! My spouse had a craving, and this did not disappoint. So glad we stopped in!
If you haven’t checked Calabresella’s out. You’re missing out. The subs are off the chart. The flavor was amazing and the people there are super friendly. Thank you Will for making our time there a true experience. My family and I enjoyed everything form the moment we walked in the door.
The Egg Salad Sandwich Special with Lettice, Tomato, Bacon, Onions and Black Olives is Outstanding! Had it Several Times, this Time All Chopped, Always Awesome! (};
Starting with the basics...The store/restaurant is bright and clean, with plenty of indoor seating, and some outdoor tables as well. The parking lot is large, has plenty of spaces, and is easily accessible from both Park ave, and Goodman street. There is a wide variety on the sandwich and salad menus to choose from, as well as sides, numerous desserts, jarred sauces, chips, bottled sodas, loaves of fresh bread, and some frozen items too. My go to is the meatball sub. Great meatballs, good red sauce that is not a salt bomb, and melted cheese on toasted fresh roll. I'm a pretty big guy and the large sub is easily two meals. They don't skimp on the meatballs! The french fries are cooked in a deep pan on the stove top burner, which means better temperature control, and oil that has not been sitting unchanged in a fryer for weeks like some other places I've tried. The staff are always friendly, accommodating, and Iv'e seen the same people working there for many years, which usually means they are treated well. It's a real positive to see the same faces behind the counter and in the kitchen who remember you, and greet you with appreciation. Those who have been there already know Calabresella's quality, but if you haven't tried them yet, you won't be disappointed.
Tell them you want CHICKEN BACON RANCH On a Spinach Wrap how JAZZY get it! & they all cook great they know what they doing 😌
Great sandwhiches, and hard workers! Made with passion, you can't make food this good without some TLC, and it shows
I just moved to Roc and tried Calabresella's for the first time this afternoon. I ordered a chicken bacon ranch. To say I'm impressed is an understatement! It was the perfect temperature, filled to the brim, with just the right ratio of cheese/ranch so it was moist enough, and the bread was perfectly toasted. This sub exceeded my expectations and it may just be the best CBR I've ever had. I will definitely be returning!
This is my favorite sub place hands down. I have been here many times. I’ve had turkey, roast beef, and Rueben among others. First the staff are a bunch of good hard working people it just pours out of them. The subs are great they have much more meat than you’d get from other places who weigh out each sub. The rolls are soft and yeasty which I love. Today my wife and I came and we split a large sub. I have finished a large by myself but splitting it is plenty. Today we got the roast beef special and they split it to two plates and even adjusted the toppings we wanted on each half for us. My wife doesn’t like pickles or banana peppers in her subs and I do! As always it was awesome. This place just covers everything you want in a sub place. It’s #1 in Rochester for us.
So delicious!! The owner Will and the rest of staff are very kind! Everytime I come here it’s always amazing food. We got a Philly cheese steak sandwich, chicken bacon ranch sandwich and fried pickles. So yummy
This was the perfect spot to stop and get some lunch before doing some shopping on Park Ave. They have a large selection of sandwiches. The staff was warm and friendly. Would recommend getting bottled water in the cooler as the sugary drinks are not great for folks who are trying to avoid sugar. The sandwich was good. I think they meant to toast the bread but they ended up burning it and it smelled and tasted burnt which is just a flavor we don't like. Would just suggest toasting the bread lightly and try not to burn it 🙂 other than that it was fabulous.
Went today (Saturday) at around 5pm. After placing our orders, a mini turkey sub and a hot pastrami sandwich, we waited for about 15-20 minutes for our sandwiches to be brought out. It wasn't necessarily the quickest turnaround for an order but the food was delicious! My partner said his hot pastrami sandwich was more like a test of willpower than a meal 😆
I drive by this place all the time and finally decided to try it. I have I have no regrets. My first sandwich was called the Royale (8inch) which they said was small but idk how 8 inches is small. 🫣🤣 However, it was delicious. This place is definitely one of my new favorite “sandwich” spot in Rochester. Glad took a chance on my curiosity.
This is definitely not the family owned original off of buffalo road we have all known and grown to love. Pastrami was excessively dry and the bread was not very fresh for being the beginning of the day. The staff aren't the most pleasant and not anywhere near as inviting as they are at their original shop. I happen to drive by this location.Thought I would get the same type of sandwich and service as I've known.This just was not the case today. Ill stick to their original location
First time checking this spot out. Decided to try something out of my ordinary for lunch. Ordered a small turkey club sub with the fixings. Sub alone cost about $16 and change. Ordered the sub to go, and waited maybe 15 minutes or so for the sub to be made. The sandwich itself was pretty good and flavorful. The bread to me looked really good and also had good flavor but was a bit chewy for my liking. Overall because the flavor was there I will try again.
Very disappointing and not like it used to be. We waited 25 minutes for a large steak sub with cheese and onions. The cost was $22.17. The wait time and the price would not have mattered if the sub was good but it wasn't. Got home and unveiled a lukewarm sub that was haphazardly thrown together. The roll was hard and not fresh tasting and the cheese was not even melted. The amount of steak on the sub did not match up with the price or subs we have gotten in the past. Will not return.
I ordered a red osier sandwich (which is on the hot side of the menu) and the guy at the front counter gave me a cold roast beef sandwich with raw peppers and onions, as well as no red osier sauce. This is the second time this has happened, which is a shame because their other hot subs are good
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
No se encontraron idiomas
Explore Your Area
Tournados
KFC
Just Juice
Marshall Street Bar and Grill
Han Noodle Bar
Skylark Lounge
The Bagel Shop by Fox's
Red Fern
Master Falafel
The Bug Jar
25 Photos
Explore Old Stone Jug's photos
About Old Stone Jug
How to get there
210 Park Ave, Rochester, NY 14607
Hamilton, NY 14607
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
museo de arte de la Universidad de Rochester, Nueva York, Estados Unidos
film and photography museum and archive in Rochester, New York, United States
museo nacional del juguete y el juego de Estados Unidos
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Old Stone Jug and other restaurants
Earn Points at Old Stone Jug!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Old Stone Jug
🏆 Rewards at Old Stone Jug
10% Discount
At Old Stone Jug
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu