Best American Restaurants in Ithaca

4.3 avg. rating 15 restaurants 7,088 reviews
Looking for the best American restaurants in Ithaca? Browse our curated list of 15 top-rated American spots. The average rating is 4.3/5 based on 7,088 real Google reviews. From casual eateries to fine dining, find the perfect American restaurant for any occasion.

What people say

Drea M.

Stopped in for a cup of fresh hot coffee, there were options 🤗 - brewed, single origin, espresso, latte, macchiato… I first tasted the cup “virgin” no cream, no sugar, and was satisfied with it. The flavor was every bit organic, but I then added light cream, no sugar. The coffee was delightful! Fo...

About Sunset Grill

Rachel Stroup

Casual spot for unique coffee and baked goods. Staff are always friendly and take pride in what they are making. Never have had a bad drink from here and the menu and rotation of baked goods are always changing.

About Sunset Grill

Aa’liyah Roams

White truffle mushroom pizza and cinco shake was soo good!! I have a great time sitting outside and would love to come back, staff was very patient and kind towards my friend and I, we love the atmosphere here.

About Sunset Grill

Thomas Novelli

A great coffee spot in North Buffalo. Coffee is consistently excellent and service is great. Outdoor seating is nice.

About Sunset Grill

Christina Carter

This is my favorite Spot Coffee location and I've visited the one in downtown Buffalo and Williamsville too. This location is so cozy. I always try to sit in the back where the big couches are. It's a great spot to sit and write. Their Cinco Shake is my favorite treat.

About Sunset Grill