Paesano's Pizzeria
Pizza · Modena
About Paesano's Pizzeria
Paesano's Pizzeria, located in Modena, is your local spot for delicious pizza and more. We offer convenient options for delivery, takeout, and dine-in. Customers rave about our friendly service and welcoming atmosphere. Our menu features classic pizzas and flavorful options like our spicy BBQ chicke...
Paesano's Pizzeria, located in Modena, is your local spot for delicious pizza and more. We offer convenient options for delivery, takeout, and dine-in. Customers rave about our friendly service and welcoming atmosphere. Our menu features classic pizzas and flavorful options like our spicy BBQ chicken wings and stromboli, prepared with care by our new owners. While our pizza is a popular choice, don't miss out on our exceptional cannolis, a customer favorite. Whether you're stopping by for lunch, dinner, or a solo meal, we strive to make your experience enjoyable. We also offer wheelchair accessibility. Join us and experience the Paesano's difference!
What Customers Say About Paesano's Pizzeria
Paesano's Pizzeria in Modena is known for its friendly staff and tasty food, especially the pizza, wings, and meatballs. New owners Kim and TJ are receiving positive feedback. Some customers have noted inconsistencies in food quality and service.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: The spicy BBQ wings and chicken bacon ranch pizza are highly recommended. Be aware that delivery might be cash-only.
Features
Frequently asked questions about Paesano's Pizzeria
Paesano's Pizzeria Modena Reviews
One of the best pizza spots around! The pizza is always delicious, the staff are incredibly friendly, and the service is consistently great. The zeppoles are amazing!!! Especially the dessert version, which I now order every time. The creamy chicken Francese is also fantastic and full of flavor. I was hesitant when the new owners took over, but they truly exceeded my expectations. If you’re looking for great pizza, Italian food, and friendly service, this place is a must-try. I’ll definitely be a repeat customer!
Delicious soups! Friendly staff!! Best meatballs I’ve ever had! Can’t say enough great things about this place!!!
Haven't been disappointed yet. Good food.
Food very tasty, generous servings and reasonable prices Will definitely be going back. Good luck to new owners Kim and TJ!!
Congratulations to the new owners! The only thing that I have to suggest is when the customers walk in have somebody designated to approach them and say we will call out your name when your order is ready. Otherwise, good luck with everything and the food is great!
Hey Everyone! You have try this place out! The new owners have delicious food, We bought stromboli and it was a classic!! Not greasy at all, just the right amount of meat/cheese!! So Good!!! We wish you the best of luck in your new business!!
TJ and Kim the new owners are two of the most genuine people I know, they made my experience here amazing. On top of great food the hospitality was top notch. I highly recommend stopping by for a bite to eat.
Excellent pizza! I learned they were under new ownership recently and stopped in. Very sweet family, and the food is still amazing! Wish them all the best!
I am from Chicago which has an insane amount of choices for amazing pizza, so I am.always skeptical about other state's pizza. But this was sooooooo good. Like so so good. I wish we had more time in NY to eat more of this pizza!
Was welcomed with lots of smiles and hellos from the staff. Ordered an Italian combo and Buffalo chicken wrap. Both were very good. I don't tip when picking up food but I tipped when I was greeted with so much enthusiasm and friendliness. I recommend this place 10 out of 10
Was staying at the KOA campgrounds around the corner from this place and ordered a large pepperoni pizza and an order of the Spicy BBQ chicken wings for pick up. The pepperoni pizza was great but the wings were where things got really good. The spicy BBQ wing sauce was delicious and the meat on the wings was cooked perfectly and basically fell right off the bone into my mouth. Would definitely recommend this place and eat here again in the future.
Great food, and friendly people. I've been about 4 times now so far and have had good experiences. Living locally, it's nice to have a place that actually has good food that doesn't make me sick. However, their pasta dinners are quite expensive; so, I'll just stick to the hot subs.
New owners. Good pizza! Got a large margarita!
NOT GREASY! Thin crust if you don't like it doughy. Got 3 pies and they were tasty. There wasn't enough cheese on the pizza for us but like I said it wasn't greasy so that was a plus! They give you a rewards stamp card for incentive to come back 👍
Not the best pizza slices in the world. Not sure how they do on pies, but slices weren't a hit. Seems like the only game in town.
Was 40 min pickup time for a few things , waited longer at pickup time food wasn’t ready, around 15 mins / so 1 hour total since ordering . They were very busy , tried to double charge us , didn’t seem to know what orders were whos. The pizza was not well done as requested. The garlic knots were good though. Edit: I’m allowed to share a true experience whether it’s liked or not, sounds like you don’t take criticism well or seriously enough to change. Just condescending with customers you should be trying to for one, be sincerely sorry to and get back. 👎 not looking good for the future.
Being it's new ownership I expect some hiccups, and as a casual customer this is still one of my go to spots for a good pie, so I'm not looking to dock stars permanently more so than provide constructive feedback. My recent experience wasn't horrible, but it shouldve been a lot better. I ordered two large pies, one plain, one bbq chicken. It seems the bbq chicken pie was made a bit too large and the folded the pie in on itself to fit it in the box; while I appreciate more pizza, thats a quality control check that should never happen like this and should at least be conveyed to the customer instead of them opening up the pie to a sloppy surprise. Both pies were cut absolutely horrendously, some of the slices were practically a quarter sizs of the whole pie and others were like half a slice! And a lot of the pie I had to go through with my own slicer since they werent cut through enough. Lastly, for a bbq chicken pie you really ought to make the pie without tomato sauce; it should either have a light layer of bbq sauce, then cheese, then the chicken, or just cheese, then chicken and drizzle more bbq on top. The marinara really clashes and ruins the taste of the bbq chicken. Again, I'm a fairly long time customer, I'll always continue to support local business and I wish the absolute best for the new owners, but please take some time to make proper quality control checks especially when it's busy. Wishing yall the best going forward and looking forward to my future orders improving more 🙏
The food was not good at all very plain and seems like they didn’t even try. Got penne and vodka sauce tasted like just plain pasta sauce and got garlic bread with cheese and it also had no flavor and barely any cheese on it. Very disappointed ☹️
Been going here 6 years now. Since the new ownership first time was not good. They over charged me for an everything pizza ehich should have included 7 toppings. When they delivered it she tried to tell me they don’t have everything pizza. I said yes it is we looked several times online and even site where it said new ownership took over the and Kim.it listed the everything pizza. 65.80 for 2 pizzas! Seriously!! Then the one was overcooked. Burnt on the sides and bottom. Even the meatball on top was burnt!they are nothing like before. Never ever again!disgusted!!!
Very disappointed with the chicken parmesan, which I found to be overcooked and soggy. The quality of the sandwich, which I described as being comparable to chewing on an old leather shoe, is certainly not up to previous ownership standards
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
Beans Cat Cafe
Moonburger
Bacchus Restaurant
Main Street Bistro
Coppala's La Fantasia
Karma Road
Asian Fusion
China House
The Parish
Starbucks
10 Photos
Explore Paesano's Pizzeria's photos
About Paesano's Pizzeria
How to get there
1914 US-44, Modena, NY 12548
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
1914 US-44, Modena, NY 12548
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Paesano's Pizzeria and other restaurants
Earn Points at Paesano's Pizzeria!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Paesano's Pizzeria
🏆 Rewards at Paesano's Pizzeria
10% Discount
At Paesano's Pizzeria
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu