The Sheffield

Name: The Sheffield
Address: 1776 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14618, Rochester, NY, 14618, US
Telephone: +15853635500
Price range: €€
Rating: 4.6

Pub · Rochester

4.6 · 347 reviews Google

The Sheffield

Your name

Your phone

Your email

We'll send your confirmation and prize here

Date & Time

Party size

Special requests

Free for you. The reward awaits you at the restaurant.

Reservation received!

www.sheffieldtavern.com

About The Sheffield

The Sheffield is a friendly pub in Rochester offering a relaxed and inviting atmosphere, perfect for enjoying a casual meal or catching a game. Customers consistently praise the attentive and welcoming service, noting the staff's dedication to ensuring a pleasant experience. The menu features familiar pub fare executed with care, alongside unique Rochester-inspired twists. Signature dishes like the fish and chips, bangers and mash, and shepherd's pie are frequently mentioned as favorites. Guests appreciate the extensive beer and cocktail selection, along with the availability of vegetarian and vegan options. With features like outdoor seating, trivia nights, and full wheelchair accessibility, The Sheffield aims to be a welcoming spot for everyone.

What Customers Say About The Sheffield

The Sheffield is a popular pub known for its delicious homemade food, stellar drink selection, and friendly service. Standout dishes include the Shepherd's Pie, fish and chips, and CLT sandwich. Prices are perceived as a bit high, and it can get loud.

Popular Dishes

Shepherd's Pie fish and chips CLT (3) Bangers and Mash Sticky Toffee Pudding The Sheffield Burger roast Turkey Sandwich

Best For

Groups Locals Casual

Tip: Visit on a Sunday night for a quieter experience, or on Tuesdays for trivia. Reservations are accepted for groups of 4 or more.

Features

📶 WiFi 🌳 Outdoor 🅿️ Parking ♿ Accessible

🎯 Casual 🛋️ Cozy ✨ Trendy 👥 Groups

Frequently asked questions about The Sheffield

The Sheffield is located at 1776 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14618, Rochester.

The Sheffield offers pub cuisine.

The Sheffield has regular opening hours. Check their profile for updated schedules.

The Sheffield offers the following services: dine-in, takeaway.

The most recommended dishes at The Sheffield based on customer reviews are: Shepherd's Pie, fish and chips, CLT, Bangers and Mash, Sticky Toffee Pudding.

The Sheffield is ideal for groups, locals, casual dining.

Visit on a Sunday night for a quieter experience, or on Tuesdays for trivia. Reservations are accepted for groups of 4 or more.

347

Reviews

The Sheffield Rochester Reviews

4.6

347

5★

75%

4★

15%

3★

2★

1★

Reviews (21)

Sean Crowell

We had a great dinner and drinks. The service was awesome. Highly recommend and we will be back. We had the shepherd’s pie, English dip, and brownie sundae.

Diana Valenti

The roast Turkey Sandwich is probably the best sandwich I’ve had in years. Love the atmosphere here too!

Lialette Bullock

The food here is unique and very delicious. Also a cozy dining room and atmosphere. This is a new go-to spot!

Steve Melnick

The arugula salad its awesome, I always get the chicken tikka masala and have never been disappointed. Mushy peas are a bit dry, but still good. Cocktails are on point too.

Stephanie Hymes

Had the most delicious CLT aka, smoked coconut ,lettuce, and tomato(with aioil)sandwich EVER! This might just be my new favorite sandwich! Thanks for having a really GOOD vegan option!!!

Claire Hardie

Perfect bar for when you want a good bar but don't want a dive but kind of want a dive feel, if that makes sense? I feel cool and classy when I come here, and the drinks and food take me there as well. Great bar food with an elevation - he owner Joe is just the best lad and if you get the chance to talk to him you'll want to go back every night.

Patricia Hanley

Sausage roll, Reuben sandwich with side salad, and Sticky Toffee Pudding with vanilla ice cream. Fantastic beer menu. Wow!! So good, so well presented. Great wait staff - Joel. Kudos to the kitchen! Will be coming back again and again. We shared everything and took home most of the salad.

Christine DeLozier

I have a weakness for delicious homemade food and this place delivers! Even the salad dressing is home made. Very high quality, which is surprising for a pub

Vignesh's Honest Reviews

Nice little pub we visited on our way back to Canada. Good vibes and great service! ♥️ Our waiter Kelly was courteous, Cheers! 🥂 IPA beer options were really good 👌🏽 Food we tried and loved: Nuggies and Dippies, and Ricotta. Prices: 3 pints of IPA beer + 2 dishes above cost us $56+tip.

Pam Wilbur

What a sweet find on Monroe Ave. Stellar drink selection. Great meal enjoyed outside on the patio. Server was exceptional.

Ryan Chojnacki

Familiar food choices executed cleanly and excellently along with some Rochester twists, with quick and friendly service. Great cocktails and many vegetarian and vegan options. The coconut lettuce tomato (CLT) sandwich was particularly good.

Denise Skidmore

Was a bit confused by British pub seating rules, usually US restaurants have a sign of you're supposed to seat yourself. The fish and chips were delightfully crispy but tender in the middle. When I declined the peas I was offered a substitute without asking. Husband had the shepherds pie which he really enjoyed except it was really hot. Be prepared to sit and converse while it cools. It was pretty busy but the wait time wasn't horrendous and there were a few tables free on a Wednesday night.

Ray Miller

Went to watch the Manchester United game with my daughter and have lunch. The lady behind the bar was very pleasant and continuously checked to ensure everything was okay. Had the Bangers and Mash, and my daughter had "The Sheffield" Burger. Both were served hot and tasted very good. Nice pleasant atmosphere to watch the game. Unfortunately Manchester United lost, but time spent with my daughter was priceless. Thank you.

Laura Potter

Went on Sunday night, it was quiet with lots of tables available. After chatting with our server, she said that it can get very busy some nights. Especially Tuesday for trivia! They take reservations for 4+ people. Our food was great with lots of fun options! Prices were appropriate for the portion and quality! Wing nights on Wednesdays, half off. Trivia night on Tuesday.

Melissa Stio

Love visiting the Sheffield with my friends! It's got great food for excellent prices! My go-to is the Shepherd's Pie 😋 it's so filling! Need to branch out and try different things on their menu when I go back!

Kelsey C.

Excellent service (shout out to Adam our server), and amazing food! We will definitely be back! 10/10 would recommend to a friend! Update - Still wonderful!

Matt Ruffell

Great English style pub. Beers and food are excellent. Prices are a bit high. Limited seated and service is a little slow but acceptable. When it comes to beer and food quality it's hard to beat.

Josh Perkins

Food was great. Everything we tried was very good. Very pricy though, $24 for bangers and mash is pretty high imo. But the mushy peas were amazing. Personally didn’t love the atmosphere, was more of a bar feel and was too loud for my taste. Overall great food for a price.

Nicki Lerczak

The fish fry was a bit overcooked, kind of fell apart while eating but it wasn't bad. The pub fries were delicious chunky potato slabs and the French onion soup was amazing! Also the brownie was totally tasty!

Cheebs God

The food and service are both quite good but they weren't showing the bills today so we had to leave. Which is a shame cuz i wanted their fish and chips which are super good

Joshua Hubbard

Showed up and they blasted football at the loudest volume possible. If you like that, then this place has great food, drinks, and the staff is friendly to regulars.