Koi Sushi Lounge
Sushi · Sayville
Deals available
Be flexible, save more
Be flexible, save more
About Koi Sushi Lounge
Located in Sayville, Koi Sushi Lounge offers a welcoming atmosphere perfect for relaxed dining or solo visits. Guests consistently praise the fresh, high-quality fish and delicious signature rolls like the Panhandle and Crazy Tuna. Beyond sushi, the menu features tasty gyoza and great cocktails to s...
Located in Sayville, Koi Sushi Lounge offers a welcoming atmosphere perfect for relaxed dining or solo visits. Guests consistently praise the fresh, high-quality fish and delicious signature rolls like the Panhandle and Crazy Tuna. Beyond sushi, the menu features tasty gyoza and great cocktails to satisfy diverse palates. The friendly and helpful staff ensures every experience is warm and professional. With wheelchair accessibility and convenient takeout options, this local favorite provides a clean, pleasant environment for lunch or dinner. Whether you are walking down Main Street or celebrating a special occasion, Koi Sushi Lounge delivers consistent flavor and outstanding service in an inviting setting.
What Customers Say About Koi Sushi Lounge
Koi Sushi Lounge is a popular spot known for fresh, tasty sushi and a relaxing atmosphere. Many customers praise the friendly staff and diverse menu, including Chinese food options. Recent negative reviews mention inconsistent quality, high prices, and issues with takeout orders.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: If you're unsure what to order, ask the servers for recommendations.
Features
What to see nearby
Data from Wikidata
Explore the area around Koi Sushi Lounge
Koi Sushi Lounge is located in Sayville, surrounded by cultural and historical points of interest. Here are some of the most notable places nearby.
Historical Heritage
- Sayville Congregational Church (A 341m) — church building in New York, United States of America Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos
- St. Ann's Episcopal Church (A 757m) — historic building in Sayville, New York, United States Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos
Parks & Gardens
- Sparrow Park (A 282m) — park in the United States of America
Data from Wikidata
Frequently asked questions about Koi Sushi Lounge
Koi Sushi Lounge Sayville Reviews
I enjoyed a nice relaxing meal with my wife. The service was good and the food was delicious.
My go to sushi spot. We went in the other night to sit down and eat and they were kind enough to bring us a free roll to try. We love coming here for date nights and for takeout most Fridays when we are craving sushi. Staff is extremely nice and very patient when we are ordering our food as well and everything is always delicious. I highly recommend
Everything is always super fresh and delicious. We love the staff - they are wonderful.
Koi sushi is my favorite place on the island to go for sushi! I've never had anything bad from here and the fish is always fresh
Nice food! Had the gyoza and it was good even for a picky eater like me! Then got two rolls, Panhandle and Crazy Tuna, and it was fresh, plus the server was nice to me when ordering it and she recommended me it. Always depend on the servers if you do not know what to eat. They did remove hibachi, but I think the sushi won me over easily.
Koi Sushi, Well, I have to say… I dont want to know about you guys competing with Onsen (😉♥️) but boy oh boy that was so amazing and so delicious! Thank you for such a relaxing atmosphere and food to relish in! I absolutely loved it! Thank you Ps- I hope you giggle at my friend Jason’ s review 🙏🏼 Marian T Gourlay 84 B Rollstone Avenue West Sayville, NY. 11796
Dined in and had a wonderful experience. Most recently ordered take out. The cashier barely spoke to me when my food wasn't ready (no "it will just be a few minutes, sorry for the delay" no communication at all) Then they packaged a hot dish on top of the sushi rolls which cooked the fish on the sushi rolls. Very disappointing.
Our food was expertly prepared, delicious and came to the table promptly. I was a little disappointed when the "tuna" combo I ordered arrived as a *salmon* combo. I brought it to our server's attention, but she insisted that I had ordered salmon [which I didn't and never have]. She very begrudgingly offered to exchange it for tuna, but I recognize how much work goes into preparing and presenting it, so I accepted it. I can't recall the last time I sent food back because I just can't stand waste and I don't ever want to be demanding_customer_guy. Unfortunately, they made no effort to "meet me halfway" or offer a comp of any sort, which I found disappointing. Atmosphere: The interior seems to have improved since I was there last which was a welcome change. Fun fact: This is the former location of "Saville Modern Diner" where a live hand grenade was found under the floorboards by a contractor fixing a gas leak in 2012. Luckily, the closest you'll probably come to that these days is if you order the "Bomb Lobster Roll" on the "KOI Special Rolls" menu LOL.
I was in this area and I read very bad reviews about this restaurant.I can't say that I was surprised by this place.and yes it was edible, but I won’t say that it’s of very good quality.i ordered tuna bowl,and added red onion,which was cut into such large pieces that it was impossible to eat it all.All in all, I would not say that I would return to this place or recommend it to anyone.
Sushi wasn’t the best I’ve had. It was just ok. What got me was the being charged $17 for a side of broccoli. Unreal.
Not like what it used to be. Ordered through GrubHub, and the food came a lot later than I expected, and it was cold, and a fried rice with beef I ordered didn’t come. Food isn’t that bad, but ordering is very risky when it comes to food not arriving and the temperature of it. Don’t think I’m ordering here ever again.
Pretty expensive. Sushi definitely should’ve been colder. Honestly mid
I don’t really care what the food tastes like. The obnoxious staff at the front desk to the left of the bar ruined any and every experience for me just by picking up my order. They had zero manners, and had horrible customer service. Their rude remarks were not appreciated either. The disgusting taste that the staff in this place left in my mouth is good enough of a reason for me to never return.
unfortunate service was not good inside, one of the server was very rude and he doesn’t understand the orders.
I have been coming to Koi for years. I’m not sure if they changed hands, or what the issue is… but needless to say, with the countless sushi restaurants locally, I won’t be back here. All hibachi menu items have been completely removed from the menu. Ordered the angus steak teriyaki. When it came to the table, it was extremely fatty and had a grey tint to it. When I spoke to the server regarding the poor cut of beef, the server was extremely rude and flat out told me I was wrong. Then, the manager came over and explained to our table that steak is 8oz, regardless if they trim the fat or not. The chef also came out of the kitchen and was glaring at us. They did switch the protein, being that I did not want such a fatty piece of beef. I was given chicken, but was still charged the angus steak price and there was no apology. The portion size of the vegetables and sides were also much smaller than in the past. When I asked for a soda refill, I was snapped at and told that they charge for refills… which I already knew because I’ve been there countless times. Once we were done eating our entrees, they didn’t even offer for us to see a dessert menu. A check was placed on our table and they walked away. Overall, very disappointed.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
18 Photos
Explore Koi Sushi Lounge's photos
About Koi Sushi Lounge
How to get there
136 Main St, Sayville, NY 11782
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
136 Main St, Sayville, NY 11782
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
park in the United States of America
church building in New York, United States of America
historic building in Sayville, New York, United States
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Koi Sushi Lounge and other restaurants
Earn Points at Koi Sushi Lounge!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Koi Sushi Lounge
🏆 Rewards at Koi Sushi Lounge
10% Discount
At Koi Sushi Lounge
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu