Famous New York Pizza
Pizza · Staten Island
About Famous New York Pizza
At Famous New York Pizza, we're proud to serve up classic pies with a personal touch. As a simple takeaway with delivery service, we've honed our craft to bring you the best of Staten Island's pizza scene. Our customers rave about our traditional and specialty pies, cooked to perfection in our brick...
At Famous New York Pizza, we're proud to serve up classic pies with a personal touch. As a simple takeaway with delivery service, we've honed our craft to bring you the best of Staten Island's pizza scene. Our customers rave about our traditional and specialty pies, cooked to perfection in our brick oven. From a perfectly balanced slice at 430 Jersey St, where we're located on Staten Island, to being able to enjoy it in the comfort of your own home with delivery, we're dedicated to satisfying your cravings.
What Customers Say About Famous New York Pizza
Famous New York Pizza is known for tasty pizza slices and catering services. Many praise the food's taste and freshness, especially the pizza. However, expect potential issues with delivery, cleanliness, and inconsistent customer service.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: If ordering for delivery, be prepared for potential delays or mistakes. Consider ordering in person for single slices to avoid delivery issues.
Features
What to see nearby
Data from Wikidata
Explore the area around Famous New York Pizza
Famous New York Pizza is located in Staten Island, surrounded by cultural and historical points of interest. Here are some of the most notable places nearby.
Historical Heritage
- Christ Church New Brighton (A 810m) — church building in Staten Island, New York Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos
Religious Buildings
- Assumption – St. Paul (A 296m) — church building in New York, United States of America
- Our Lady of Good Counsel's Church (Staten Island, New York) (A 671m) — church building in New York, United States of America
Parks & Gardens
- Harvard Yard (A 179m) — park in Staten Island, New York
- Liotti-Ikefugi Playground (A 272m) — park in the United States of America
- Skyline Playground (A 291m) — park in the United States of America
- Davis Playground (A 517m) — park in the United States of America
- Fort Hill Park (A 594m) — park in Richmond County, New York, United States of America
- Mahoney Playground (A 637m) — park in the United States of America
- Haven Esplanade (A 724m) — park in the United States of America
Data from Wikidata
Frequently asked questions about Famous New York Pizza
Famous New York Pizza Staten Island Reviews
I absolutely love their pizza! The ingredients taste authentic and fresh!
The slices of pizza were tasty and was excellent but they didn't have tables or chairs to eat at. Poor atmosphere and needs some improvements.
Ate here a few times after long days of sightseeing. $21.50 for an 18” regular cheese. Got a takeout and ate in the hotel room. Really tasty. The ordering counter can be a bit chaotic and it gets very busy but I think it’s worth the wait. Right after we arrived in NYC, it started raining so we decided to follow an ad that the hotel had in the room and Rays had it delivered in 30 minutes along with a lot of seasonings to go on the pizza and it was fantastic, even had the leftovers for breakfast!
The food was hot, fresh, I call cuz I try to do it with other apps for a salad and it was pretty much charging me double. I got the mozzarellas ( delicious 6 pieces) juicy. The chicken roll .. last me till the next day.. and my Partner had the chicken salad. I recommend this place only thing which I’m not mad at was the time for delivery but since food was hot means it wasn’t just there waiting.
Delicious Hot Fresh Food ! Amazing Staff kept me cheerful during my experience. Very clean place! Amazing prices! The Owner and the Manager delivered incredible service 2 my event last minute with amazing prices and incredible Food Service! I highly recommend Famous NY Pizza to everyone in NYC!!! The Delievery Drivers are polite and they actually know what they are delivering that makes if you like they know my individual order from the rest of the deliveries that they are taking. A real customer service that no one else can really deliver anymore!
I used catered trays of food from Famous NY Pizza for my daughter's party. It was delivered hot and delicious! The driver was courteous and friendly. The trays were full and the food looked great too! They came with trays of bread and bags of complimentary zeppoli. My guests couldn’t stop raving about how good the food tasted. I will definitely be using them again for my next party! Thank you again.
The slices are good if your pizza cheesy. I personally dont like the pizza pies, they taste different from the individual slices. The chicken parm is ok and their salads are good. Delivery timing has gotten better. I recommend this place if yi our looking for a quick bite to eat. They also take cashapp, so that's cool.
Fantastic local business deserving of local support. If you come here to buy single slices it's certainly worth your time and money. Slices are large, and I've heard other members of the community say it's the best pizza in the world. They have good deals and specials they run as well
The food's great with a wide range of options to choose from but the wait is considerable. There seems to be some confusion behind the counter at times and the place is small therefore creating a level of uncomfortability, so, I stepped out on multiple occasions to have a smoke. However, I thought the food was worth the wait!.
I ordered there 3 times. Food was 5-star delicious, but delivery is 1-star extraordinarily terrible. They have a really good dough! BUT Delivery is that bad that I’ve learned how to cook shrimps&alfredo pasta by myself just to never meet their delivery persons again.
It was ok. I'm from quEEns 👑💖. No 🍕 beTTer than Margheritas on Jamaica Ave. Fresh moZZareLLa 😋😋😋 🧀. Try it.
Their pizza is good but customer service sucks. Orders arrive wrong, cancelled without warning, cheese sliding off the pizza in delivery - and if you call they don't apologize or try to make it right, just excuses. It sucks because their pizza tastes great. Wish they would learn how to treat customers.
The food is good but some of the employees are rude, impolite, and not reliable. I ordered a large pizza and a fries and it's costs $13 plus tax if you add it up and the next day I got the same thing but different employee and he said $18 and I'm confused cause the prices are still the same and when I told him it was 13 dollars and he started yelling so I walked to the door and said I'm not going here again. Future visitors I recommend you to not go here if you do not want to be rigged for your money.
Food and specials are good and that's about it. Not very clean. There is only one table and its usually taken so you can't usually eat in. If you do eat in there is NO BATHROOM to wash your hands at least. The neighborhood is not good so be careful. I don't plan to go there again, too uncomfortable.
Waited over an hour for 2 items and didn’t receive it.. Ordered on uber eats and didn’t get any refund. (Didn’t answer the phone.. called numerous times)
I ordered from uber eats been waiting going on 3 hours no one answers the phone been saying the food on its way for 3 hours now nothing yet poor customer service
Crust tastes like saltine crackers. I ordered cheese and it was still disappointing somehow.
Terrible experience today. I ordered A sausage and cheese pepper sub for $10 And Also I paid $5 for VERY SOGGY wet full of Grease ,very dark Burnt ,French Fries . I had Re fry the My already burnt LIMP FLLOPPY SOGGY FRIES On my Stove. To make them crunchy. I called him to complain and he lied to my face And Never offered me any refund or No resolution as the manager he should know better. APPARENTLY He put the fries in DIRTY OLD GREASE before the grease before the oil got hot . Terrible customer service 👎🏼.
I don't understand how this place has 3.9 when the girl yes girl who answers the phones obnoxious snobby unprofessional and rude you tell her the order she cuts off you have to repeat yourself numerous times and she speaks perfect English Everytime order it's the same crap she don't know how to listen she needs better customer skills and their prices are subject to change at their discretion. Too bad the previous owner left he served the community better and looked out for the community
Ordered at 5:31 it's now after 7pm and no food delivery. I called and was told it takes 45mins..a shame because I really do like their food however they just lost a customer.
I like the food but the girl they got who does the orders is messing up the business.. She constantly get the orders wrong and she does nothing to fix her mistakes and she gets an attitude about it
food is usually fine but there service is absolutley terrible sometimes. i had ordered 2 beef patties but was only given one. Although i was told i was not charged, i asked if the second beef patty could be sent and i would pay for it, she said that would be fine amd would be there soon. it was around 9:30 when i called amd ive waited 2 hours and they are only around the corner and it seems they are ignoring me. Ive ordered from here before and even give tips when i can but their service continues to upset me. i may never order from here myself ever again. EDIT: I have just now decided to take my first bite of the beef patty and its kinda not good,my stomach is starting hurt
Visiting the city and heard this was the best pizza. I ordered a large cheese and received with a long woman’s hair in the middle of pizza. I called to explain and was told I was probably lying because no one has hair in the Pizza place. Disgusted and ripped off.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
West Cork Union Hall
Bake Culture
Seppe Pizza Bar
Chang Noi Thai
My Family Pizza
Shorty's Roti Shop
Cinderella's Restaurant
The Basement
El Patron Restaurant & Lounge
Taqueria El Gallo Azteca
4 Photos
Explore Famous New York Pizza's photos
About Famous New York Pizza
How to get there
430 Jersey St, Staten Island, NY 10301
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
430 Jersey St, Staten Island, NY 10301
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Upcoming Events
Jaws Movie Screening with Johnny Fish & The Fins
17 Jul. 2026, 19:15
St. George Theatre
Wild Child - Doors Tribute
18 Jul. 2026, 20:00
St. George Theatre
Staten Island FerryHawks vs. Southern Maryland Blue Crabs
21 Jul. 2026, 18:30
SIUH Community Park
Staten Island FerryHawks vs. Southern Maryland Blue Crabs
22 Jul. 2026, 10:30
SIUH Community Park
park in Staten Island, New York
park in the United States of America
park in the United States of America
church building in New York, United States of America
park in the United States of America
park in Richmond County, New York, United States of America
park in the United States of America
church building in New York, United States of America
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Famous New York Pizza and other restaurants
Earn Points at Famous New York Pizza!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Famous New York Pizza
🏆 Rewards at Famous New York Pizza
10% Discount
At Famous New York Pizza
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu