New York Pizza
Italian · Taylor
Deals available
Be flexible, save more
Be flexible, save more
About New York Pizza
New York Pizza is a Pizza restaurant located in Taylor, TX. Rated 4.6 out of 5 by guests. Known for: Serves local specialty. Popular for lunch, dinner, solo dining. The menu features comfort food, quick bite, small plates, vegetarian options. Offers dine-in, delivery, takeout. Casual, cozy, quiet at...
New York Pizza is a Pizza restaurant located in Taylor, TX. Rated 4.6 out of 5 by guests. Known for: Serves local specialty. Popular for lunch, dinner, solo dining. The menu features comfort food, quick bite, small plates, vegetarian options. Offers dine-in, delivery, takeout. Casual, cozy, quiet atmosphere.
What Customers Say About New York Pizza
New York Pizza in Taylor is a local favorite known for its generous portions, friendly staff, and authentic Italian food. The meatlovers pizza, spaghetti and meatballs, and garlic knots are highly praised. Some customers have experienced inconsistent food quality.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: Dine in for a relaxed and quiet experience, or order carry out. If ordering online, consider ordering in person for better accuracy.
Features
What to see nearby
Data from Wikidata
Frequently asked questions about New York Pizza
New York Pizza Taylor Reviews
Staff is extremely friendly and amazing, food is excellent as always. As well as decently priced. Plus I've ordered thru DoorDash and the order was messed up before but they gave me credit for the next time.
The marinara sauce served with the Stromboli and Puzza rolls is so very tasty! The housemade dressing was surprisingly multi-herbed, neither too tart nor too sweet, and the supreme slice had many flavors of meat and veggies, with an amazing crust, which they make in house!
I can’t speak highly enough about the food. My perfect pizza search has ended. Pizzas are well priced and are delicious. The cheese, the sauce, the dough all cooked great and tasted amazing. Even the plain cheese pizza was packed with so much flavor. The calzone was just as perfect. Cooked to perfection, delicious mozzarella and they seasoned the outside with Parmesan cheese buttered garlic which added that something extra. Can’t say enough!
Best pizza around. Great dough, tons of toppings, loads of cheese. The pasta comes out hotter than lava, awesome! We love the pizza, pasta, pepperoni rolls, garlic knots, wings and more. It's the go to joint.
We found this place about a month ago and have now made it our pizza night favorite. We have had their pizza, their tiramisu, cheesecake, garlic cheese bread and their chicken parmigiana. We haven’t had one single thing that we didn’t find amazing. It is the best New York style pizza we have found in the Austin area. If you are wanting amazing food at a good price and unparalleled quality, you have to try this place!
Just have to brag on the place! Ive been in taylor for a couple months for work. Most of the restaurants ive tried are mediocre. I tried the beef ravioli in pink sauce, absolutely delicious. So rich an flavorful. The stuffed meatlovers pizza is probably the best pizza ive ever had. Full of meat and cooked perfect! This pizza could feed me for a week. Value, quality, full of flavor. 11 out of 10
Best Greek salad ever! Big chunks of feta, garden fresh red pepper, crisp lettuce, juicy olives. Soft buttery garlic knots. Pizza to die for, the toppings all fresh and full of flavor, crust baked perfectly inside and out. Spaghetti is delicious, just what I was craving and so good! Cheese cake and cannoli were amazing!
I ordered the chicken parmesan and my husband got the meat stromboli with garlic rolls. Everything was really good, affordable, and the portions fed us for a couple of days! The only small complaint was that there was a bit too much cheese for our taste, but that’s an easy fix—we’ll just ask for less next time. Overall, the best pasta and pizza in Taylor!
Really wanted to give 5 starts. I'll get to that at the end. We weren't expecting much, and we were happily surprised. It's very authentic, in my opinion. Various types of pizza were ready to go for a slice, in addition to other Italian staples. Their Greek salad was good and large enough to share. OK, so now why 4 and not 5 stars. Allegedly, per my GF, the main guy was observed digging for gold nuggets on the job. No clean-up after, straight back to food prep. 😬
We've tried this place a couple of times and their pizza never disappoints, freshly made. We even tried the spaghetti and meatballs and it was delicious, also very generous portions and decent prices, we drive all way from Pflugerville. The only complain is that we've had mixed attitudes from the lady at the front, sometimes she's nice and some other times she seems annoyed by simple request, that's why I'm only giving it 4 stars.
The pizza was a but cardboard, reheated Nd not enough cheese. Tasted reheated frozen. The roll now that was hearty and very tasty. The garlic knots...hut and miss. The lasagna, manicotti, and cannoli again hit and miss. It had a lot of cheese and tasty. Might try again earlier in the day.
Tried the Mediterranean pizza at New York Pizza Pasta after reading reviews on Google. Placed an online order, and they were spot-on with the timing. However, major letdown – the pizza was too runny, and the saltiness was off the charts. The crust was super soggy at the bottom so all the topping kept falling off. Not sure if it was a one-time thing, but it was so disappointing that we ended up tossing the whole pizza. Disappointed for sure.
Terrible gross! My pizza was burnt and my husbands pizza was not cooked all the way, it was dripping water from the middle and the dough was not cooked all the way the 6 dollar cheesecake slice was obviously from the store not home made. I could have bought the whole cheesecake for that price at heb. Food is not good. Can’t believe they sent out food like this. Paid a lot of money for food we couldn’t eat. Even the dog wouldn’t eat it.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
Louie Mueller Barbecue
Chuy's
Randy's Ice House
El Taquito
Gonzales Tacos
Ben Hoa
Jack Allen’s Kitchen
DQ Grill & Chill
Taco Bell
Sirloin Stockade
34 Photos
Explore New York Pizza's photos
About New York Pizza
How to get there
1701 W 2nd St, Taylor, TX 76574
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
1701 W 2nd St, Taylor, TX 76574
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
park in Williamson County, Texas, United States of America
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at New York Pizza and other restaurants
Earn Points at New York Pizza!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at New York Pizza
🏆 Rewards at New York Pizza
10% Discount
At New York Pizza
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu