Caputi's Sheridan Pub
Pub · Tonawanda
About Caputi's Sheridan Pub
Caputi's Sheridan Pub is a local Tonawanda favorite offering a relaxed pub atmosphere with a reputation for delicious homemade food and a great drinks selection. Customers rave about the fast and friendly service provided by our personable staff, making every visit a pleasure. Our menu features pub...
Caputi's Sheridan Pub is a local Tonawanda favorite offering a relaxed pub atmosphere with a reputation for delicious homemade food and a great drinks selection. Customers rave about the fast and friendly service provided by our personable staff, making every visit a pleasure. Our menu features pub favorites, with particular praise for our pizza, noted for its crisp crust and flavorful pepperoni. Don't miss our freshly cut fries, hand-battered fish fry, and of course, our wings with unforgettable blue cheese. Enjoy our offerings through dine-in, takeout, delivery, or curbside pickup, and take advantage of our outdoor seating and bar games. We also boast a wide selection of beers and cocktails, perfect for enjoying while catching a game on TV.
What Customers Say About Caputi's Sheridan Pub
Caputi's Sheridan Pub is a popular local bar known for its delicious food, friendly staff (Maddie, MacKenzie, and Lisa mentioned), and great atmosphere. The wings and wood-fired pizza are highly recommended. Some customers have reported inconsistent customer service and order issues.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: Don't miss out on the pizza, especially from the wood-fired oven. Tuesday is wing night.
Features
What to see nearby
Data from Wikidata
Frequently asked questions about Caputi's Sheridan Pub
Caputi's Sheridan Pub Tonawanda Reviews
Ordered a margherita pizza and a Caputi's burger to go... soooooooo good! Can't wait to come back and try the wings!
Great beer selection, killer wings, and pinball for days? Ya this place is my jam.
Tuesday wing night. Delicious pizza. Friendly staff. Amazing owner.
Stopped here with friends for a quick bite and ended up ordering pizza, wings, fries, and mozzarella sticks. We were pleasantly surprised. Everything came out pretty fast and hot. The pepperoni pizza was perfect. Wood fired pizza with a perfect crust. The garlic parm wings have a touch of honey that makes these superior, with excellent bleu cheese. The fries were crispy with the right amount of salt and the mozzarella sticks were filled with cheese and not mostly air. The staff here was so friendly and helped us with our indecisiveness. Thank you. Great place! We'll be back!
Excellent pizza from the wood fired oven next door, cool barcade experience, good draft beer selection. Would recommend
I need more blue cheese delivered to Michigan it was so delicious I had to use my finger cause michigan doesn't know how to make wings lol
Went to dinner last night with my parents and fiancee. This is very much a bar more than a restaurant, so that's the vibe you'll get upon entry. The bartender said we can grab a table anywhere so we went into the other side where all the pinball machines and pool tables are (next time I'd sit on the bar side). We ordered drinks and food and everything came out within a normal amount of time. The burger was great but the wings really surprised me in a positive way. They were very very good classic medium and the blue cheese was top tier. I really liked being able to order 5 wings as a side. I would definitely come back! We had a blast.
My husband and I, from Niagara Region, Ontario came to Buffalo yesterday to do some Christmas shopping. We stopped in to Caputi’s for lunch. I had the wings and my husband had the roast beef on weck. The wings were the best wings I’ve ever tasted! So crispy and saucy! My husband said that his sandwich was terrific too! We were served by Lisa, who was always there if you needed anything and was outstanding! I can’t say enough great things about this tavern!
Yes, the food and the atmosphere was wonderful, however, the staff is what makes this place a gem to visit. Excuse the spellings..Maddie, MacKenzie and Lisa were so personable, it was a pleasure to sit at the bar and enjoy their company and conversation. Definitely try the pizza and do not be afraid to try a unique topping..it's worth it! Try the Cajun Cattleman and Honey Sriracha wings. We overheard, who I assume was a pastry chef, that he made Brownie Bottom Cheesecake with Caramel...YES PLEASE! All in all, a great experience. Thank you.
I was looking forward to their very tasty pizza, with a crisp crust and flavorful cup and Char pepperoni, but we noticed that the table next to us got two pizzas that they said they didn’t order it was given to them by a different server than ours. So it took an extremely long time to get our pizza. Our server made up for it. It wasn’t her fault. Bourbon bbq wings were also done on the pit and worth the wait.
This is such a great bar, the beers are a good selection. Food and people are great, bartenders are attentive and super friendly, but, the bar has no Wi-Fi. The NFTA bus has Wi-Fi. I’m sure with all the tv’s going , there’s got to be a Wi-Fi package. You are made to use your own data package. If a bus can have Wi-Fi why can’t the bar?
I had a burger here yesterday and had terrible food pooling last night . I am Sure this is where I got infected as it’s all I ate all day . (It did taste good !).
Horrible!!! Never again!! Heard good things about it, and decided to go with the honey for some wings. Sat at the bar, three workers behind the bar. Not busy at all, male bartender took drink order, asked for food menu, got the drinks immediately and then we just waited and waited and waited all while the two females behind the bar were just congregating, male bartender running all over the place; honey and I are still waiting to place our food order. Twenty minutes later, (again, not busy at all) we decided to pay for our drinks and leave. Horrible customer service! I can spend my money anywhere!. Needless to say, ended up at Kelly's Korner and it was DELICIOUS.
The customer service is always a challenge. The food is good that is why we go. When we call to order out it is alway an issue. The food is not cooked right or not ready 45 minutes if they tell us 30 minutes and when you call the phone us off the hook most days.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
Olive Garden
Olisi's New York Style Pizza
Mattina's Pizzeria
Dickey's Barbecue Pit
Koreana
The Gallery Grill
Little Lamb Hot Pot
Hoagie Hounds
Frank Gourmet Hot Dogs
Yummy Thai
23 Photos
Explore Caputi's Sheridan Pub's photos
About Caputi's Sheridan Pub
How to get there
2351 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda, NY 14150
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
2351 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda, NY 14150
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
park in the United States of America
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Caputi's Sheridan Pub and other restaurants
Earn Points at Caputi's Sheridan Pub!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Caputi's Sheridan Pub
🏆 Rewards at Caputi's Sheridan Pub
10% Discount
At Caputi's Sheridan Pub
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu