Nonna's of Buchanan

My sister had ordered pizzas from here one of the weekends we visited. The pizzas consist of a large cheese, a white & a Greek. All were absolutely delicious. Perfect thin crust. We enjoyed the pizzas. The menu has a lot of delicious choices for everyone. Great Italian establishment. Very friendly staff. Definitely check out Nonna's!

The pizza here is absolutely amazing! Whenever we're in the area, it's a must-stop for us. Highly recommend checking it out!

This is an amazing little gem of a pizzeria. I wasn't sure what to expect being about an hour out of the city. I was pleasantly surprised at how amazing the two slices i tried were. The grandma and, an white slice. The flavor on both were so great and, the dough was perfect. So the very next day i made a special trip to try two more slices and, they were also incredible. I highly recommend Nonna's pizzeria if you are up in the Buchanan area.

We had a snafu with our order and Nonna's took care of it tonight. I really appreciate quality customer service. We are just down the street and order there frequently so I was very pleased with how things were handled. The food is always good and delivery is always fast. Thank you, Nonna's for doing the right thing by a frequent customer. We love your pizza and chicken caesar salad wrap!

The food is great 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼 The workers are friendly and the place is clean. I recommend it ❤️

Great experience at Nonnas of Buchanan. The food was fresh and flavorful and clearly made with care. Portions were generous and everything tasted homemade. The staff was friendly and welcoming and the atmosphere was comfortable and relaxed. Definitely a spot I’d come back to and recommend to others.

Their plain pizza 🍕 is perfect, great crack in the bottom crust and a nice soft crust with just enough crunch. Nice guys behind the counter, good selection of slices, depending on how busy they are. Good selections of quality pastas to make for yourself at home if you want to get your Nona sauce making self on. Worth the visit.

We ordered through uber eats and requested an allergen to not be included and they accidentally added the allergen to a pie. They immediately made a new pie and sent one of their own employees to deliver it. This was much appreciated and great customer service! Pizza was delicious as well

Stopped in for lunch while passing through the area. Crust had a solid crunch and the sauce flavor was definitely one of the better ones I've ever had. Service was great and friendly. I wish I lived closer so I can try more stuff.

The Ace

Great experience at Nonnas of Buchanan. The food was fresh and flavorful and clearly made with care. Portions were generous and everything tasted homemade. The staff was friendly and welcoming and the atmosphere was comfortable and relaxed. Definitely a spot I’d come back to and recommend to others.

Doris Doreen

The food is great 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼 The workers are friendly and the place is clean. I recommend it ❤️

William Pepe

Stopped in for lunch while passing through the area. Crust had a solid crunch and the sauce flavor was definitely one of the better ones I've ever had. Service was great and friendly. I wish I lived closer so I can try more stuff.

Andrea Geiger

We ordered through uber eats and requested an allergen to not be included and they accidentally added the allergen to a pie. They immediately made a new pie and sent one of their own employees to deliver it. This was much appreciated and great customer service! Pizza was delicious as well

John O'Sullivan

Their plain pizza 🍕 is perfect, great crack in the bottom crust and a nice soft crust with just enough crunch. Nice guys behind the counter, good selection of slices, depending on how busy they are. Good selections of quality pastas to make for yourself at home if you want to get your Nona sauce making self on. Worth the visit.

Tina Nolan

I love their pizza! I just tried the Marguerita pizza and it was so so so good! Amazing even cold! I usually get plain or sausage and peppers, but this is my new favorite!

John W Smith II

The pizza here is absolutely amazing! Whenever we're in the area, it's a must-stop for us. Highly recommend checking it out!

Jeannine Weinstein

I have been ordering from Nonna's Buchanan since they opened. I can't say enough about this place. Their food is incredibly delicious. They pretty much do a good job with everything. However, they do a superior job with their seafood. I'm always hesitant to order things like shrimp, fish, muscles, etc. at an Italian place. However, you can't go wrong ordering seafood from here. 85% of the time their shrimp is so tender and succulent you can cut it with a fork. It's cooked to perfection almost every single time. I ordered the seafood paella for new years and they nailed it! Don't get me started on their pizza. Their crust for many of their specialty pizzas is so crispy and light. It's just all around one of the best places around to get Italian food. I'll admit no place is perfect and there have been times that I've been disappointed. It's bound to happen when you order there at least once or twice per week. But those times are few and far between and it's usually nothing major. I have at least one to three dishes catered for all of the events I host at our home. Everyone raves about their food and that makes me the hostess with the mostest!

Charles Valenza

My sister had ordered pizzas from here one of the weekends we visited. The pizzas consist of a large cheese, a white & a Greek. All were absolutely delicious. Perfect thin crust. We enjoyed the pizzas. The menu has a lot of delicious choices for everyone. Great Italian establishment. Very friendly staff. Definitely check out Nonna's!

Megan O'Mara

We had a snafu with our order and Nonna's took care of it tonight. I really appreciate quality customer service. We are just down the street and order there frequently so I was very pleased with how things were handled. The food is always good and delivery is always fast. Thank you, Nonna's for doing the right thing by a frequent customer. We love your pizza and chicken caesar salad wrap!

Zachary Barden

This is an amazing little gem of a pizzeria. I wasn't sure what to expect being about an hour out of the city. I was pleasantly surprised at how amazing the two slices i tried were. The grandma and, an white slice. The flavor on both were so great and, the dough was perfect. So the very next day i made a special trip to try two more slices and, they were also incredible. I highly recommend Nonna's pizzeria if you are up in the Buchanan area.

I like the pizza, and I would probably choose it over most of the pizza in this area cuz it's closest to New York style slice. They consistently undercook the garlic on their garlic knots, so their garlic knots have this unfortunate, intense acidic taste of raw garlic to them

The Pizza at Nonnas tastes great. No complaints about the food. Also the staff is wonderful - but. Here's the but: Their Personal Pizza shrunk by 50% and the price was raised by 50% at the same time. If you have a pizza graving, get a large one. Leave the Personal size pizza out. Toooo expensive!

C R

I like the pizza, and I would probably choose it over most of the pizza in this area cuz it's closest to New York style slice. They consistently undercook the garlic on their garlic knots, so their garlic knots have this unfortunate, intense acidic taste of raw garlic to them

Holger Lersch (fahrbier)

The Pizza at Nonnas tastes great. No complaints about the food. Also the staff is wonderful - but. Here's the but: Their Personal Pizza shrunk by 50% and the price was raised by 50% at the same time. If you have a pizza graving, get a large one. Leave the Personal size pizza out. Toooo expensive!

After eating here, both of us started feeling stomach aches and nausea shortly after the meal. Throughout the entire day, we experienced diarrhea, which was very concerning. Since we both ate the same food and felt sick at the same time, it strongly suggests an issue with food handling or storage. We genuinely love this place — the food is usually delicious and the service is always great. We are sharing this only to bring attention to the issue so it can be addressed and prevented in the future.

Ekaterina Zanaeva

After eating here, both of us started feeling stomach aches and nausea shortly after the meal. Throughout the entire day, we experienced diarrhea, which was very concerning. Since we both ate the same food and felt sick at the same time, it strongly suggests an issue with food handling or storage. We genuinely love this place — the food is usually delicious and the service is always great. We are sharing this only to bring attention to the issue so it can be addressed and prevented in the future.

I am so very upset! My daughter moved to California and wanted some NY pizza on her visit back home. We were told 42-45 minutes for delivery. After an hour, we got our pizza cold!! We are less than 10 minutes away. What was that delivery boy doing? Joyriding with the pizza?

Jacqueline Green

I am so very upset! My daughter moved to California and wanted some NY pizza on her visit back home. We were told 42-45 minutes for delivery. After an hour, we got our pizza cold!! We are less than 10 minutes away. What was that delivery boy doing? Joyriding with the pizza?

I have had more than one disappointing experience with Nonna’s. I typically order delivery. They have proven it takes 6 orders to get 1 right. Pretty low satisfaction rate. When I call to tell the restaurant I got one sorry, otherwise I am to blame per the owner/manager. Every time the owner takes an order it is wrong. I am pretty sure I am familiar with what I like and dislike regardless of what the owner decides to make me and then be rude about it! I will never again order from this place

Joanne McCarron

I have had more than one disappointing experience with Nonna’s. I typically order delivery. They have proven it takes 6 orders to get 1 right. Pretty low satisfaction rate. When I call to tell the restaurant I got one sorry, otherwise I am to blame per the owner/manager. Every time the owner takes an order it is wrong. I am pretty sure I am familiar with what I like and dislike regardless of what the owner decides to make me and then be rude about it! I will never again order from this place