Canan Soylu

There were many options in the town but we picked Sheldrake Point Winery and I think it was the right choice . We loved all wines we tried and bought 4 bottles before left. Ppl were kind with big smiles and of course the winery absolutely gorgeous!

Matt Veatch

When asked what had brought us to the Finger Lakes, we said it was to taste the regional wines! Sheldrake Point Winery represents the region nicely. Their friendly tasting room staff made our visit delightful, and the case of wine we bought kept the magic going over several more weeks. We look forward to ordering a case to share with my parents over the winter holidays.

Shaylyn Kissinger Traver

Sheldrake Pointe Winery was the perfect venue for our rehearsal dinner. Nestled in a picturesque vineyard setting, the winery offered both stunning views and a delightful culinary experience. The staff at Sheldrake were incredibly professional and helpful, ensuring that every aspect of our event went smoothly. The wine was great and they were able to make a menu for us using their services so that we didn't have to hire an outside caterer. Everyone enjoyed the relaxed yet refined atmosphere, making it the perfect kickoff to our wedding festivities. We couldn’t have chosen a better place to gather and celebrate with our closest friends and family before the big day photos by @jonamiguelphotography

Mike S

Everything here is very tastefully done. The venue is wonderful, even classy. The staff are friendly and inviting. The wines are good and the total experience is well worth the trip!

+18

Kathryn Reilly

We love this winery. The wine is delicious, the service is gracious, and the views are unmatched, especially on a clear day. You can order a tasting of 5 wines or order a glass and walk around. We did both!

+1

Jasmine Schwarten

I'd call this place a positive experience. For one, it's a beautiful and welcoming place. The staff is friendly, attentive, and informative. Their wines are dry by natural, so that almost gave me pause because I like sweet wines primarily. The smoothness of most of the wines really surprised me though. My husband and I ended up taking a few home too! We've got a lot more wineries to visit among the Finger Lakes, but this is one to keep on the list to revisit.

Yu-Chen Chiu

We did the Vintage Room tasting- it was wonderful! The room was cozy with beautiful arrangement. The wines were good as well! fantastic service and food (I loved the cheese and homemade jam!). We had a very nice conversation with the staff who helped us with the tasting. She was very friendly and knowledgeable. Definitely recommend the vintage tasting experience!

Travis Fuhrman

This winery isn’t conveniently located along Rt 89 but is nested in down next to lake..like literally a stone throws away. It sets itself apart from the other wineries alone just based on scenery and proximity to the very lake that defines the region from which wineries in located(The Cayuga). Tasting room has nice clean crisp architecture that reminds one of a country club boathouse. Use of natural lighting inside is beautiful and presents well the escape room like spaciousness of the multiple spaces. Two tasting bars, outdoor space with pergola all is a great formula for an awesome experience. Our wine room attendant was friendly, knowledgeable and had a great outward personality. This was a 2nd stop for us coming out of Ithaca and was a wonderful experience all around.

+3

Cat Mascis

Enjoyed a nice afternoon sitting outside doing a lovely dry white wine tasting. You get a free Reisling bubbles glass to start & then you pick the rest! Loved the wine glasses the wine was served in. The gentlemen serving us were very nice & kept checking on us. We bought additional glasses & sat outside in the Adirondack chairs looking at the view - very nice!!

Kevin Markman

Good drinkable Finger Lakes wines. The staff were helpful and knowledgeable. View by the water is beautiful as ash the burrs of the lake are beautiful.

+5

B. Simeon Goldstein

We sat inside for a wine tasting. In retrospect, we wish we had sat outside. It seemed very formal inside. The tasting itself was disappointing. Our server simply took our sheets that indicated our wine choices. He then returned with the wines but took absoluteky no time to explain anything about the wines. He was pleasant but wholly uninformative. The wines were okay but nothing remarkable. At $15 per person for a wine tasting, it was so not worth it, based on the above. We won't be back. As an aside, we also went to Thirsty Owl. It was $5 per person and the server was far more informative ... as one would expect at a wine tasting.

Jen Leipold

The outside of the winery was very nice! However, when we entered, no one greeted us for at least five minutes and they weren’t super busy. We were seated and made our choices and all four of us chose different wines or taste. The person brought the wines to our table and didn’t even tell us which order to drink them in and didn’t tell us anything about the wines. I am not a super picky wine drinker, but I was only able to finish one of the wines as they all tasted bad to me. My friends each left at least one or two and didn’t enjoy their wines either. For a $15 tasting, SO not worth it!