Peter's Hot Bagel

I love this place. Peter the Korean owner puts his passion in everything he does. Most weekends I enjoy a BEC on a roll, bagels and cheese or chocolate croissants. They always get my order right with an occasional pancakes or French Toast. The owners are pleasant and friendly and does his best to light up my morning with a witty joke or comment. Even though there is another bagle place geographically closer to me I go outta my way to got to Peter's Bagels because he is just that good.

Korean guy at counter is a phenomenal bagel maker. I’ve met many bagel makers in my life and he is by far the most experienced. Truly a master of his craft. If you ever have a chance to stop by this quaint shop, please do. I traveled from my village in Mandi Gobindgarh to visit Peters hot bagels and used my kids college tuition savings to fund the trip. It was well worth it

Few years ago it was a 3/5 experience, but now, I have to say it's a 5/5. The new management made the bagels pretty damn good, they are nice and fluffy. I don't think I have had a better bagel since.

Service: impeccable. This is my favorite place for my morning hot coffee and sandwiches. Honestly, I really do feel like I’m part of the family when I am here. They always know what I want when I get there.

Highly underrated, the bagels here are great. However, I admit I never come during the morning/afternoon rush so I don't know how the service is around those times.

Great spot been going here for years!!! Soo good and nic variety! My girl really likes it tooo. Ask them to sauté the Jalapeños it’ll make the omelette way better for no extra cost

Great little bagel shop that opens early in the morning with a good crowd. You can enjoy eating indoors or out, your choice. The Bakers dozen comes with 14 bagels which is a steal and they have a good variety to choose from. They also make some great breakfast sandwiches to help you start your day. The omelettes are great as well.

Yogamannn

Great spot been going here for years!!! Soo good and nic variety! My girl really likes it tooo. Ask them to sauté the Jalapeños it’ll make the omelette way better for no extra cost

Juan Lima

Great little bagel shop that opens early in the morning with a good crowd. You can enjoy eating indoors or out, your choice. The Bakers dozen comes with 14 bagels which is a steal and they have a good variety to choose from. They also make some great breakfast sandwiches to help you start your day. The omelettes are great as well.

My favorite bagels to get. Fresh and home made always

This place is a sleeper. Not a place to go for atmosphere but the product is a 10. YES THE BAGELS ARE GREAT . I go early in the morning and they never disappoint. For bagels and nothing else this place is a gem

The quality of home fries and omelet was great. I enjoyed the food here a lot. They were cooked and served in a nice manner. Maybe because of a new cook. Every thing was much better than before. I strongly recommend this place.

This is an amazing place for Breakfast! They make their own breads, bagels etc and everything is made in-house, breakfast sandwiches are very well done and made to your liking. They also serve sandwiches ,cold cuts or hot on Grill not Microwaved like some other places.

I moved away and still come to peter’s to buy my bagels, I won’t go anywhere else. Their bagels are really nicely sized stay soft after toasting and have the perfect amount of chew. I hate going to bagel places and struggling to eat a hard impossible to chew bagel. They have gotten my order wrong some times but just make sure to check your bag before you leave and they’ll take care of any mistakes. Im writing this as I eat a day old bagel that was left in the fridge, toasted and smeared with their cream cheese that I bought to-go and it’s still so soft and the perfect texture idk how.

Amazing bagel place! If you ask, they will provide you hot fresh bagels right from the oven! They make bagels 4x per day and they are quite literally the most delicious bagels in NYC!

Good breakfast sandwiches. Been there two ncw and it's been good both times. It was recommended by a local.

I ordered a veggie wrap today. It's the best I've ever had! It's great to have this bagel shop in the neighborhood. Every time I stepped into the shop, the owners and the staff greeted me with smiles.

Trevis Love

Good breakfast sandwiches. Been there two ncw and it's been good both times. It was recommended by a local.

Sawan Singh

My favorite bagels to get. Fresh and home made always

Steven Brady

Amazing bagel place! If you ask, they will provide you hot fresh bagels right from the oven! They make bagels 4x per day and they are quite literally the most delicious bagels in NYC!

Monica

I ordered a veggie wrap today. It's the best I've ever had! It's great to have this bagel shop in the neighborhood. Every time I stepped into the shop, the owners and the staff greeted me with smiles.

Spiro Fourniotis

This place is a sleeper. Not a place to go for atmosphere but the product is a 10. YES THE BAGELS ARE GREAT . I go early in the morning and they never disappoint. For bagels and nothing else this place is a gem

Ahmed Khan

I honestly love the bagels here you can’t go wrong. The egg everything bagel toasted with scallion cream cheese is my favorite . The iced coffee is nice here too would recommend trying that . They have a nice area to sit down and eat.

Carolina Strunz

I love trying random bagel shops all over the city so this was my first time here. The bagels are hand rolled, made fresh, they’ll pack it however you like and they’re super nice and welcoming. Highly recommend for a great way to start your day.

I stopped in for a quick bite. The lox was fresh and the bread was toasted to satisfaction.

just check your order before you leave bc they are always too busy to get it right

Good prices for a bagel/deli store and consistant tasty sandwiches, and friendly customer service. I look forward on stopping by here again when back in Bayside.

Sunghyun Kim

Good prices for a bagel/deli store and consistant tasty sandwiches, and friendly customer service. I look forward on stopping by here again when back in Bayside.

Peters CAN serve up some delicious bagels... however they are very inconsistent. I come here for the convenience as it is located in my neighborhood. However, ordering here is a coin flip. Frequently I will be missing an add-on or will ask my bagel toasted and it will not be. I suggest going to Slims or Utopia if you're in the area. Edit: NGL when I ended up eating it...was delicious tho lol

Good food and prices, place very small, not much seating

One of my favorite local bagel spots can go wrong with a bacon egg and cheese here

I love this place but sometimes you have to be careful because the prices are always different and never the same. It bothers me but since i really love their bagels and sandwiches, I go back. My mom also loves it here so we return.

Tracy Jerone

Good food and prices, place very small, not much seating

Samson S

One of my favorite local bagel spots can go wrong with a bacon egg and cheese here

Collins Sigler

Peters CAN serve up some delicious bagels... however they are very inconsistent. I come here for the convenience as it is located in my neighborhood. However, ordering here is a coin flip. Frequently I will be missing an add-on or will ask my bagel toasted and it will not be. I suggest going to Slims or Utopia if you're in the area. Edit: NGL when I ended up eating it...was delicious tho lol

An ok bagel. The store is small and there are a few tables to eat at. The bagel was good but the line was kind of chaotic.

Read the reviews and decided to give it a shot. Pros: friendly service; quick delivery of order and good egg and bacon sandwich. Cons: Just one but it is a major one. Took a sesame seed bagel to toast at home the next day. When I cut it open it proved my suspicion that these are not bagels at all. It is just bread in the shape of a bagel seasoned with the same flavorings (sesame, everything, etc). If you advertise as a BAGEL shop then by golly you should be serving honest to goodness real bagels! A real bagel is dense and chewy achieved by boiling them first. These are just regular baked bread imitations. I don’t know what is happening in NY but i find this is true of way to many places.

I love this place at first. Today is my 5 times getting my bagel here, now I absolutely hate it here. I waited 30 minutes for my order. She gave me an untoasted bagel, then I said I always getting toasted bagel here. She gave me an mean look. After all … she gave me a burned bagel, I can’t even eat it. I don’t think I will go back, waste money.

I only continue to buy here because it’s close to my apartment. Bagels are soft and chewy which I like. However they are so cheap with the toppings. I ordered a bacon egg and cheese and it has literally 2 slice of the thinnest bacon. Might as well go to Dunkin’ Donuts for a breakfast sandwich. Same vibe if you order a BLT. Also they frequently will mess up your order. Usually leave here with feelings of frustration.

I ordered a breakfast sandwich. A new employee was there. I repeated my order at least 5 times and still was missing the bacon from the Bacon, egg and cheese bagel. I know next time to check before I leave.

Monica E

I ordered a breakfast sandwich. A new employee was there. I repeated my order at least 5 times and still was missing the bacon from the Bacon, egg and cheese bagel. I know next time to check before I leave.

Natalie

I only continue to buy here because it’s close to my apartment. Bagels are soft and chewy which I like. However they are so cheap with the toppings. I ordered a bacon egg and cheese and it has literally 2 slice of the thinnest bacon. Might as well go to Dunkin’ Donuts for a breakfast sandwich. Same vibe if you order a BLT. Also they frequently will mess up your order. Usually leave here with feelings of frustration.

Private Matter

Read the reviews and decided to give it a shot. Pros: friendly service; quick delivery of order and good egg and bacon sandwich. Cons: Just one but it is a major one. Took a sesame seed bagel to toast at home the next day. When I cut it open it proved my suspicion that these are not bagels at all. It is just bread in the shape of a bagel seasoned with the same flavorings (sesame, everything, etc). If you advertise as a BAGEL shop then by golly you should be serving honest to goodness real bagels! A real bagel is dense and chewy achieved by boiling them first. These are just regular baked bread imitations. I don’t know what is happening in NY but i find this is true of way to many places.

The bagels tasted like they had been frozen, and not a lot of sesames, or stuff on top, cheap with the butter, and it took too long to get the order. They need to go

Hopefully the owner sees the reviews and give the people what they want Your sandwiches are very skimped of ingredients My BLT had 2 little depressing pieces of bacon tucked in it, why are we being so cheap? Come on now why charge me full price for half the size

Only went there bcus my daughter likes their bagels. When u go there make sure u add up ur items b4 paying. They hav a serious problem charging you more than what the price should be.

Service fine but bagel very chewy , coffee watery and...no bialys! No bialys in a New York bagel shop? Wouldn't recommend

Lmao is the bagel too big or the cream cheese shrunk!? Never went to a bagel place thats so stingy with their cream cheese especially in NY. Sucks coz i like this place

M Magz

Lmao is the bagel too big or the cream cheese shrunk!? Never went to a bagel place thats so stingy with their cream cheese especially in NY. Sucks coz i like this place

I ordered a coffee breakfast sandwich. A new employee young kid made coffee ask for two sugar， he made more than four sugar， too sweet can not drink it， first and second time understand mistake， on third time some happen， call store let them know。 on other day go store，he dont care what you said， just show he made with giant spooon sugar。

Sky Sunlight

I ordered a coffee breakfast sandwich. A new employee young kid made coffee ask for two sugar， he made more than four sugar， too sweet can not drink it， first and second time understand mistake， on third time some happen， call store let them know。 on other day go store，he dont care what you said， just show he made with giant spooon sugar。

Tom Szyszka

Hopefully the owner sees the reviews and give the people what they want Your sandwiches are very skimped of ingredients My BLT had 2 little depressing pieces of bacon tucked in it, why are we being so cheap? Come on now why charge me full price for half the size

Always messing up the order or forgetting something that was paid for. EVERY single time. Guess it’s a common mistake here. Definitely going to have to find a different place.

Expensive, rip off.. normally don't mind about prices but they were cheap on the meat and egf for egg sandwich and they were cheap on the cream cheese in my bagel.. disgusting

Always messing up my order. I always leave instructions and they always seem to not get it right. I had enough, I'm never ordering from here again !!!

I hate to write bad reviews, but seriously if you can't speak English and you are taking an order and can't understand what I am ordering or help with my order you should consider having someone else to help with people who only speaks English. The food is great , but swap your rep for someone else to handle your orders over the phone.

Terrible place to go as a new customer. Talk about highway robbery. Don’t go here they over charge and come up with hidden fees like Verizon! Forgot to mention the garlic bagels taste like dirty water!!!!

I went to buy a bagel, nd the person making it sneezed on it. Also bought a drink and it smelled like armpit it made me want to throw up

DO NOT GO TO THIS PLACE!!! ABSOLUTE RIP OFFFF!!!!! They had the nerve to charge me $10 for a bagel with lox. See the photos to see what I actually got.

Laurie Hirsch

DO NOT GO TO THIS PLACE!!! ABSOLUTE RIP OFFFF!!!!! They had the nerve to charge me $10 for a bagel with lox. See the photos to see what I actually got.