Randal Race

This was my first time coming to this establishment. Mia, was very helpful and considerate and knowledgeable for giving me great recommendations. Miss A as in Angel, the manager of the establishment vast knowledge and hires the most expertise employees with customer service that went above and beyond above. I will be returning in the future.

Omari King

*This is a legitimate review. I didn’t take the cookie. lol* I walked in at 9:40 and Melissa was as polite as you can be when you close in 20min. She took my order and immediately starts knocking it out. Then Anthony walked out and he’s the coolest guy you’ll meet. The Melissa Anthony comb got me in and out in less than 10min. Two things: Get the banana pudding shake, it has a cookie on top and get the chicken pot pie soup. I didn’t even eat my sub the soup filled me up. I’m sure they don’t need my help advertising but I suggest you go give them a try.

+7

Thomas Catucci

The line was quite long about 15 people deep. Took them about three minutes to get through everyone. Talk about freaky fast! The ladies in the back will make you feel like you’re at home. The sandwiches are loaded, and the price is just as nice. Only about 10 bucks on average a sandwich. The atmosphere is like old-time sports bar. In a fun way that makes you feel like you’re on the television set. The tables are filled with Orlando teams as well. Great stuff will definitely come back for another sandwich. Ms A the pink haired manager is the bomb

Adriano Masjuan

Potbelly is a gem in the world of sandwiches and desserts. From the moment you enter, you are greeted by a welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff. The Chocolate Brownie Cookie is a real delight: soft, chewable and full of pieces of melted chocolate, perfect to close any meal. Coffee complements the experience, creating moments of pure happiness. I recommend Potbelly to those looking to enjoy a good sandwich and an unforgettable cookie. Five stars!

Amanda Palla

Fantastic food, service, and atmosphere! I have loved Potbelly sandwiches since I had my first one in Chicago 20+ years ago. I was so happy to see a location in Orlando. The toasted sandwiches are just as good as I remember, and their mac and cheese is amazing, too. I can never leave without an oatmeal chocolate chip cookie. The staff here are super friendly, and the seating area is clean and comfortable. We will definitely be back!

Katie Richardson

So I have a list starting with my favorite sub to my least! Potbelly just reached the number one spot!! Sorry firehouse subs…Adrienne was a beautiful face that took our money , her smile made me feel like I was ok with handing over cold hard cash! Mr chuck was outstanding with dressing our subs, accommodations were made for me and my sister splitting two subs and he did it with pleasure. We didn’t feel as though we were just another customer. Rhonda was amazing as well great team work. Kris took our order and made great recommendations for our first time eating here. The establishment was very clean well lite and the music was perfect. I will be back !

Calvin Yerke

Had one buddy recommend and another tell me no, so I was going to head to Laspadas but I was intrigued by the pepper blend the first friend mentioned. I got the prime rib size big, substituted provolone for the Swiss that usually comes with it and added the hot peppers which is a lot like giardiniera but I would prefer this sandwich with peppers over Portillos beef. The caramelized onions and garlic aioli give a lot of flavor and the beef is not shaved style but still crazy tender. I also liked the chili Mac, but it also brings my only complaint. I think the price of the cup should be the price of the bowl. I will definitely go back and try another sandwich, very clean place with unusually happy staff. The bread is really good too and holds up well considering I didn't eat it till an hour later.

+1

Cin Gro

Stopped in on a Friday night before a Plaza live concert. Very tasty sandwich, had the medium Italian. The bread was fantastic. Was the 2nd time here, and would definitely repeat.

Nick Cangemi

Had been excited to try Potbelly since I heard they were coming to Orlando, and now that I’ve been, I’m a bit let down. First, it’s one of those places (like Moe’s) where multiple employees loudly welcome you into the restaurant, which is ok if that’s your thing, but I tend to prefer quieter environments. Staff was friendly and I received my order quickly. I ordered an original “Wreck” with provolone, garlic aioli and caramelized onions. The bread was alright, a bit crispy a bit doughy. Not very much meat. The caramelized onions weren’t really caramelized, they were just like raw onions, only softer. All in all a pretty standard, decent sandwich, certainly nothing to write home about though. But don’t take my word for it, just look at the sandwich in my photo. Lots of bread, a thin line of meat, and some aioli. Not exactly a gorgeous cross section.

Sharad Jones

Ordered a prime rib sandwich, started eating in the car right after I left the restaurant so I’m confused as to how the meat was cold… took three bites, all of which were too chewy and I had to spit it out. Gave up on the sandwich as a whole. First and last time not sure what I was thinking.