Brooklyn Italian Heroes
Sandwich · Avenel
Sobre Brooklyn Italian Heroes
Brooklyn Italian Heroes, located in Avenel, is a local favorite known for serving up delicious Italian fare with a focus on heroes. We're a small business committed to providing a convenient and enjoyable dining experience. With a 4.4-star rating from over 100 reviews, our customers appreciate our q...
Brooklyn Italian Heroes, located in Avenel, is a local favorite known for serving up delicious Italian fare with a focus on heroes. We're a small business committed to providing a convenient and enjoyable dining experience. With a 4.4-star rating from over 100 reviews, our customers appreciate our quality and service. We offer delivery, in-store pickup, and takeout options to fit your needs. Visit us any day of the week, with extended hours Monday through Saturday from 11 AM to 7 PM, and Sunday from 10 AM to 2 PM. We also provide a wheelchair accessible entrance and accept credit, debit, and NFC mobile payments for your convenience.
Què diuen els clients de Brooklyn Italian Heroes
Brooklyn Italian Heroes is highly praised for its exceptional Italian sandwiches, especially the chicken cutlet and roast beef. Customers rave about the friendly staff, fresh ingredients, and generous portions. Many consider it the best sandwich shop in the area.
Plats populars
Ideal per a
Tip: Ask for recommendations from the staff, as they have favorite sandwiches and can guide you through the extensive menu.
Services
Què veure a prop
Dades de Wikidata
Explora els voltants de Brooklyn Italian Heroes
Brooklyn Italian Heroes es troba a Avenel, envoltat de llocs d'interès cultural i històric. Aquests són alguns dels punts més destacats als voltants.
Parcs i Jardins
- Annadale Green (A 53m) — park in the United States of America
- Ida Court Park (A 899m) — park in the United States of America
Dades de Wikidata
Preguntes freqüents sobre Brooklyn Italian Heroes
Opinions de Brooklyn Italian Heroes Avenel
Trying to decide what was better at Terrible Eddy’s in Annadale—shooting the shit with Eddie himself or the absolutely phenomenal roast pork sandwich with provolone and broccoli rabe, dipped in a side of au jus. Honestly, it’s too close to call. Growing up just blocks away and being back in the old neighborhood set the stage perfectly. Add in a complimentary espresso while I waited for my hero, and it was already a special visit before the food even landed. When I tell you this sandwich was nearly perfect, I mean it. The bread was spot on, the pork was juicy and packed with flavor, and everything just worked. If I’m being hyper-critical, I would’ve taken a touch less meat for slightly more cheese and broccoli rabe—but that’s nitpicking at a very high level. This hero easily cracks my top two pork sandwiches of all time, and for me it’s a straight coin flip between this and DiNic’s at Reading Terminal Market in Philly—and that’s about as high praise as it gets. If you’re anywhere near Annadale, this is a must-try. No question.
Walked into the shop for the first time today, and was greeted by the wonderful staff and felt welcomed in, like family would welcome one. I met Eddie, and he was a pleasure to talk to! Not the to mention, the freshly made tuna salad sandwhich— was out of this world. I will be back to try more sandwiches!
Terrible Eddie’s is an amazing sandwich shop. This isn’t your normal deli or bodega. You are going to get quality and a nice sized sandwich. I tried the terrible eds It was so good they cook the chicken cutlets while you’re there and you can tell everything is fresh. They aren’t kidding when they say the sandwich will feed two people. The staff that was there were top notch. Looking forward on going back.
Had a great time chatting with Eddie and browsing through all the sandwich options. They are definitely fit for two stomachs worth of food. Got the roast pork and terribleeddie cutlet, both were great, with quality ingredients. Yes it may just be better than the reading terminal market
Been seeing all the buzz about the new old-school sub shop in Staten Island — Terrible Eddie’s — so I had to check it out. Critics are calling it the best sub shop in the tri-state area… and they’re 100% right! The subs are insane — bread fresh out of the oven, portions huge, and everything made with real care. You can tell it’s family-owned and not some corporate chain. Met Eddie himself and you can see how much pride he takes in every sandwich. From the first bite, you know this guy pours his heart into it. If you love a legit sub, this place is worth the trip from Jersey!
Walked in for the first time was very clean, fair room temperature, never had a hero there asked what their most popular was, it must be a frequent question because they had their four favorite which I appreciated. Asked which was the counter person favorite was she said # 54 and let me tell you it was an amazing hero!!! Bbq bacon mozzarella chicken cutlet I asked if they could add some lettuce, tomato and jalapeños she said Np!! It was hands down best hero I’ve had thus far!!! It was crisp and bbq flavor was beyond my expectations!!!!
****Have to do research on the claim about their Facebook comments.... Will revisit this review first two weeks of June. Stopped by here randomly for some food, and ordered a random ssif that sounded good to me. I got #62(there's so many sandwiches🤯). My sandwich happened to be warned and has toasted bread. The prosciutto and chicken were great along with their sauce. The flavor is great and the food taste fresh. If i had to get it again, the only thing i would change is getting the mozzarella cold instead of melted. If you are in need of sandwiches stop here at any time.... Sandwich was damn good.
Had a great time chatting with Eddie and browsing through all the sandwich options. They are definitely fit for two stomachs worth of food. Got the roast pork and terribleeddie cutlet, both were great, with quality ingredients. Yes it may just be better than the reading terminal market
Trying to decide what was better at Terrible Eddy’s in Annadale—shooting the shit with Eddie himself or the absolutely phenomenal roast pork sandwich with provolone and broccoli rabe, dipped in a side of au jus. Honestly, it’s too close to call. Growing up just blocks away and being back in the old neighborhood set the stage perfectly. Add in a complimentary espresso while I waited for my hero, and it was already a special visit before the food even landed. When I tell you this sandwich was nearly perfect, I mean it. The bread was spot on, the pork was juicy and packed with flavor, and everything just worked. If I’m being hyper-critical, I would’ve taken a touch less meat for slightly more cheese and broccoli rabe—but that’s nitpicking at a very high level. This hero easily cracks my top two pork sandwiches of all time, and for me it’s a straight coin flip between this and DiNic’s at Reading Terminal Market in Philly—and that’s about as high praise as it gets. If you’re anywhere near Annadale, this is a must-try. No question.
Been seeing all the buzz about the new old-school sub shop in Staten Island — Terrible Eddie’s — so I had to check it out. Critics are calling it the best sub shop in the tri-state area… and they’re 100% right! The subs are insane — bread fresh out of the oven, portions huge, and everything made with real care. You can tell it’s family-owned and not some corporate chain. Met Eddie himself and you can see how much pride he takes in every sandwich. From the first bite, you know this guy pours his heart into it. If you love a legit sub, this place is worth the trip from Jersey!
Terrible Eddie’s is an amazing sandwich shop. This isn’t your normal deli or bodega. You are going to get quality and a nice sized sandwich. I tried the terrible eds It was so good they cook the chicken cutlets while you’re there and you can tell everything is fresh. They aren’t kidding when they say the sandwich will feed two people. The staff that was there were top notch. Looking forward on going back.
Walked in for the first time was very clean, fair room temperature, never had a hero there asked what their most popular was, it must be a frequent question because they had their four favorite which I appreciated. Asked which was the counter person favorite was she said # 54 and let me tell you it was an amazing hero!!! Bbq bacon mozzarella chicken cutlet I asked if they could add some lettuce, tomato and jalapeños she said Np!! It was hands down best hero I’ve had thus far!!! It was crisp and bbq flavor was beyond my expectations!!!!
****Have to do research on the claim about their Facebook comments.... Will revisit this review first two weeks of June. Stopped by here randomly for some food, and ordered a random ssif that sounded good to me. I got #62(there's so many sandwiches🤯). My sandwich happened to be warned and has toasted bread. The prosciutto and chicken were great along with their sauce. The flavor is great and the food taste fresh. If i had to get it again, the only thing i would change is getting the mozzarella cold instead of melted. If you are in need of sandwiches stop here at any time.... Sandwich was damn good.
Best Italian style sandwiches in NYC by far!
My boyfriend saw this shop on Staten Island Food and wouldn’t stop talking about how good it looked for weeks. I came to visit and we got the #54 on Friday and it was so great that he giggled while eating. Each ingredient would be outstanding on its own but combined…good Lord. We didn’t even talk to each other because we enjoyed eating our sandwich so much! The chicken was well seasoned, the barbecue sauce was unique, and the bread was absolutely perfect! Crispy and flaky on the outside and soft on the inside. We loved it so much that we went back today, two days later, for a #136, and we cannot wait to try all 150! The best part-the sandwich had just enough dressing to be not dry but not so much that it’s soggy. I can’t recommend the service and the food here enough!!!
First time visit and everything was amazing. Sub sandwich was on point. Try the meat balls and Sicilian rice balls for an added bonus! Will definitely be back soon!
Tremendous sandwiches. Perfect size not too big not too small. Courteous, friendly staff in a nice atmosphere. Must have! And will be back for sure
My first time at Terrible Eddie’s. Slight wait to put your order in but well worth it. I had the Anthony Cumia hero. Wish I knew this spot existed before today’s visit. Will definitely be going back.
Excellent food. We had the Terrible Eddies sandwich and the gravy boat and both were amazing. Their bread was perfect and both their roast beef’s and chicken cutlets were quality. Can’t wait to come back. The owner was super nice and engaging. Highly recommended.
Everything was great. We had Big Mike make our heros. There was a perfect amount of fixings on the hero. Nice and neat. The meat/roast beef and cold cuts were quality and very fresh. The bread was amazing (very important trait when it comes to heros) He came around and checked on how we were doing and made sure we were comfortable. I'd certainly recommend this place. Bring your appetite because the heros are large.
I went to terrible Eddies looking to cater my work Christmas party that was being held at my house! Immediately, Michael and Rocky came to help me plan what I can get. I had a limited budget! I ended up ordering, a tray of chicken Marsala and they recommended a tray of assorted sandwiches! Although the name of the shop is called Terrible Eddie’s, the food is far from terrible! My co-workers, all loved the food, and kept asking where I got the food from! It’s a little hidden gem in the town of Annadale, right near the Annadale bakery! This will be my new go to place for all of my catering needs, or just to go and pick up some sandwiches! Michael and Rocky were so accommodating! They really helped make my Christmas party a success! Thanks guys!
Excellent sandwich. Went with the gravy train, roast beef was cooked to perfection!!!! Sliced paper thin! Went with seeded Italian bread..you can choose unseeded if you like. Fresh mozz and the Au jus was AMAZING! Dunked and ate 😋 that delicious sandwich like it was my last meal 😂. It’s a big sandwich…you won’t be disappointed. Can’t wait to come back and try the eggplant parm!! Next on my list. Great job guys.
Terrible Eddie’s is one of the best sandwich spots around. The owners and entire staff are friendly, welcoming, and always provide great service. The food is fresh, flavorful, and consistently excellent. Highly recommend the Gravy Train—it’s a must-try and easily one of the best sandwiches on the menu. If you’re looking for great local sandwiches and top-notch service, this place delivers every time.
This is the absolute best sandwich I have ever had!! We got the terrible eddie and im not surprised it’s considered the best! The whole time eating me we couldnt stop saying how delicious it was! Cant wait to try other sandwiches! Highly highly recommend you wont regret it!
Tried Terrible Eddie’s yesterday for the first time and had a great experience from start to finish! I spoke with a gentleman named Spider behind the counter who gave me a ton of awesome recommendations. He said his personal favorite was the Gravy Train on garlic bread with Cooper Sharp and chopped stuffed breadcrumb peppers — and wow, what a recommendation! The sandwich was absolutely delicious (and huge!). I could only finish half, and the other half made for an amazing lunch the next day — just as good reheated. I also got to chat with Eddie, the owner, and you can tell he truly cares about what comes out of his kitchen and what his customers are eating. Great food, great people, and great vibes all around. I’ll definitely be back again soon
Hands down the best chicken cutlet, mutz, & roasted pepper hero I’ve eaten in a long time. Sandwich was warm, bread was crunchy, breading on the cutlets was perfection. I’ll definitely be back to try another…
Gentleman who answered the phone was very polite/professional as well as helpful. He transferred me to a woman who was very helpful and friendly. The food came within 30 minutes. The food was hot and very tasty . Definitely ordering from here again .
This is the absolute best sandwich I have ever had!! We got the terrible eddie and im not surprised it’s considered the best! The whole time eating me we couldnt stop saying how delicious it was! Cant wait to try other sandwiches! Highly highly recommend you wont regret it!
Terrible Eddie’s is one of the best sandwich spots around. The owners and entire staff are friendly, welcoming, and always provide great service. The food is fresh, flavorful, and consistently excellent. Highly recommend the Gravy Train—it’s a must-try and easily one of the best sandwiches on the menu. If you’re looking for great local sandwiches and top-notch service, this place delivers every time.
I went to terrible Eddies looking to cater my work Christmas party that was being held at my house! Immediately, Michael and Rocky came to help me plan what I can get. I had a limited budget! I ended up ordering, a tray of chicken Marsala and they recommended a tray of assorted sandwiches! Although the name of the shop is called Terrible Eddie’s, the food is far from terrible! My co-workers, all loved the food, and kept asking where I got the food from! It’s a little hidden gem in the town of Annadale, right near the Annadale bakery! This will be my new go to place for all of my catering needs, or just to go and pick up some sandwiches! Michael and Rocky were so accommodating! They really helped make my Christmas party a success! Thanks guys!
Excellent sandwich. Went with the gravy train, roast beef was cooked to perfection!!!! Sliced paper thin! Went with seeded Italian bread..you can choose unseeded if you like. Fresh mozz and the Au jus was AMAZING! Dunked and ate 😋 that delicious sandwich like it was my last meal 😂. It’s a big sandwich…you won’t be disappointed. Can’t wait to come back and try the eggplant parm!! Next on my list. Great job guys.
Tremendous sandwiches. Perfect size not too big not too small. Courteous, friendly staff in a nice atmosphere. Must have! And will be back for sure
Hands down the best chicken cutlet, mutz, & roasted pepper hero I’ve eaten in a long time. Sandwich was warm, bread was crunchy, breading on the cutlets was perfection. I’ll definitely be back to try another…
First time visit and everything was amazing. Sub sandwich was on point. Try the meat balls and Sicilian rice balls for an added bonus! Will definitely be back soon!
I’ve been seeing the hype of this place all over Facebook so me & my wife gave it a shot & I understand why everyone’s so excited! Everyone in there was more friendly than the next & the chicken cutlet sandwich we got was exactly what we were in the mood for.
Tried Terrible Eddie’s yesterday for the first time and had a great experience from start to finish! I spoke with a gentleman named Spider behind the counter who gave me a ton of awesome recommendations. He said his personal favorite was the Gravy Train on garlic bread with Cooper Sharp and chopped stuffed breadcrumb peppers — and wow, what a recommendation! The sandwich was absolutely delicious (and huge!). I could only finish half, and the other half made for an amazing lunch the next day — just as good reheated. I also got to chat with Eddie, the owner, and you can tell he truly cares about what comes out of his kitchen and what his customers are eating. Great food, great people, and great vibes all around. I’ll definitely be back again soon
The most amazing Eggplant sandwich the most amazing stuffed mushrooms, light and just like I was eating the topping from baked clams they were like baked mushrooms amazing just amazing thanks Ed. Best of luck I’ll be back.
My first time at Terrible Eddie’s. Slight wait to put your order in but well worth it. I had the Anthony Cumia hero. Wish I knew this spot existed before today’s visit. Will definitely be going back.
Terrible Eddie's serves very good food that's definitely the highlight. Unfortunately, the service and atmosphere are both just average and don't match the quality of the food. Worth visiting for the good eats, but don't expect much from the setting or staff.
I didn’t even get to the food, every time I placed an order they called me back telling me they didn’t have something that was on their menu, and this happened 3 times, then when I finally did find something they had, they told me their computer won’t let me pay with my card because the delivery address wasn’t the same as my billing address. So if you’re ordering from work, or at a friends or family’s house, you basically can’t use your card, and they have no work around for that. That’s gotta be the stupidest thing I’ve ever heard, and I’d never bother ordering from them again.
Inicia sessió per deixar una ressenya
Inicia sessióElimina anuncis i gestiona el menú
No se encontraron idiomas
Explora la teva zona
Mona Lisa Pizzeria & Ristorante
Kingdom Cafe
Salvatore & Lloyd's Pizza Place
Hong Kong Kei One
Planet Wings
Peking Taste
Giuseppe's Pizza
Chopstick House
Popeyes
Patrizia’s of Brooklyn
Galeria
No hi ha fotos disponibles
Les fotos apareixeran aquí quan se sincronitzin des de Google Places
Informació sobre Brooklyn Italian Heroes
Com arribar
829 Annadale Rd, Staten Island, NY 10312
Avenel, NY 10312
Destacats
Serveis
Opcions de Menjador
Informació del Restaurant
Comoditats
El Barri
Ubicació
📍 Explorar el Barri
park in the United States of America
park in the United States of America
Jocs
🎮 Guanya Punts Mentre Explores!
Juga a Find Me i canvia punts per descomptes a Brooklyn Italian Heroes i altres restaurants
Guanya Punts a Brooklyn Italian Heroes!
Juga a Find Me i canvia recompenses aquí
Guanya punts extra i canvia'ls per recompenses de Brooklyn Italian Heroes
🏆 Recompenses de Brooklyn Italian Heroes
Descompte 10%
A Brooklyn Italian Heroes
Aperitiu Gratis
A la teva propera visita
Taula VIP
Experiència premium
per canviar recompenses i guanyar punts
📋 Com funcionen les recompenses?
Juga a Find Me
Cada 100 punts de score = 1 punt de recompensa
Acumula Punts
Els workers obtenen 2x punts per partida
Canvia Recompenses
Descomptes, menjar gratis i experiències VIP
És teu? Reclama'l GRATIS!
Elimina anuncis i gestiona el menú