Justin Scofield

Cocktails are definitely in the .95 percentile in NYC(!) Nothing fancy but they hit the basics really good! We had to wait 5min to get in but the staff ensured us to get us seated soon! They don’t serve food unfortunately.

+1

Andrew Berto

Pretty cool cocktail bar in WB. No menu here you tell them what you would like in a drink and the one I got was very well made.

Brock Zych

Fresh Kills is a swanky and cool spot for a unique drink. I wouldn't recommend getting drinks before visiting here though. We ended our night here and if I could have done it again I would have started the night here. Every drink we had was strong but pretty impressive.

Blake Rasmussen

Amazing atmospheric cocktail bar. There’s no menu, and the bartenders and servers simply take what you like and make a classic cocktail that fits that description. You can also ask for classics, as we did with the espresso martini and the clover club. The drinks were solid, and we were happy with what we got. It’s not quite the top level cocktail bar we’ve been to but it was distinctly enjoyable, and the atmosphere and pleasant staff made our visit really enjoyable and memorable. We’ll be back.

+4

Becky A.

Loved the ambience and unique experience this bar offers. Thankfully didn’t have to wait for long to get in and was happy with the service I received. Described my preference to the bard tender and she came up with well mixed and strong drinks. Had a lemon drop and then a drink that infused pineapples in it (can’t remover the name). Kinda feels like there’s an unofficial menu in the waiter’s head when you state your preference but it’s interesting to see what they churn out when you share your preference.

Seckin Uysal

Great atmosphere. Not goos acoustics. Don’t expect a menu to order your drink, the cool guy will ask you what you like and bring a drink. White negroni was not amazing but mezcal negroni was pretty good.

+4

Michael Horne

Excellent cocktails, super creative, no menu but if you don’t know what you want, they’ll create something delicious. Would be 5* but prices are high (and not published) - $95 for 5 cocktails 😳. Definitely go if you’re ok with the spend. Could get expensive.

+2

Kevin L

They have the best ice in Brooklyn. The happy hour cocktails are a good deal at 11 dollars, but the regular price is on par with cocktail bars in Manhattan. The mixologists put time and effort into making drinks from scratch instead of pouring syrup out of a bottle and spraying the glass from a soda fountain gun. Excellent effort in shaking the cocktails as well.

Tapan Desai

We were visiting Williamsburg and stumbled upon this bar. It's a pretty small place and dimly lit. However, they serve really great cocktails. The staff is very friendly and helps you to have a great cocktail experience. We order the bartenders choice. They asked for our choice alcohol and other preferences (fruity, citrusy, and so on). We were a group of 6 people and each of us was served with a perfect cocktail matching our preferences. This was really mind blowing. We also had the Julep which was pretty good. They can definitely have more food options. Apart from that I would highly recommend this place if you want some good cocktails.

Nicky Patel

Amazing drinks!! Such a fun place if you enjoy cocktails and trust the bartenders in their work... except one thing, the service The reason I'll never go back.. the service. The waitress/hostess was one of the most rude and standoff-ish person Ive ever encountered. She should not be in the service industry. Very cold and dry and sucked all the fun out of this type of experience. So I'd say overall, find yourself another cocktail bar- there are plenty of them with a friendly face and the good drinks.

Kyle Maxwell

I never write reviews like this, but I was honestly shocked by how rude the staff was here. When I arrived, I told the host/server I was meeting friends at the bar. She asked me to wait while she took an order, which was mildly annoying but understandable. When she returned, she asked again if I was meeting people, and I said yes, at the bar. She walked me in, then stopped in the narrow walkway to chat with a friend. After a moment, she looked back at me and said, “If you’re meeting people at the bar, you should probably go find them,” then turned back to her conversation. It was a confusing interaction that made me feel like I had done something wrong? It turned out my friends were actually at a bar across the street, so I grabbed them and we all came back together. We were seated and the host/server was cold but polite. After our first round, she disappeared for a while and we wanted to order again. I waved to her very mildly, nothing urgent, but she didn’t notice because she was on her phone. We waited and kept chatting. A few minutes later, I waved again, still gently and honestly a little embarrassed. She was still on her phone. I caught the eye of a blonde bartender, who was also chatting with a friend, and she just stared at me. Eventually the bartender walked over and said, “I thought I’d come over since you CLEARLY need something IMMEDIATELY,” in a very tense, sarcastic tone. The host ran over and started apologizing while the bartender rolled her eyes and walked away. My friends were stunned and actually asked me if I knew her, because it felt so personal and hostile. After that, the host suddenly became overly nice, which made it even more uncomfortable. I work in service myself and I try to be an easy customer because I know how hard these jobs can be - but none of these people were busy. You can’t be a bar that insists on table service and then ignore your guests. And you definitely shouldn’t make people feel difficult for wanting to order. The vibe in here is nice and we would’ve stayed longer had it not become so weird. Do a little better