Sal's Pizzeria

Brandon Goodno

Every worker is great and friendly. Food is always amazing. The only downside to the place is the father and son are both fans of terrible soccer teams.

Elizabeth Anselm

The pizza is amazing. The sauce is savory and the crust is thin, and foldable. Absolutely delicious. Family said the wings were great. The garlic knots are perfect with lots of garlic butter for dipping. The cheesecake was authentic and delectable. 10/10 Can't wait to visit again.

Travis Ward

Great pizza here. Probably the best I've had since I moved to NY a couple years ago. Great dough and excellent sauce. The garlic knots were top notch. Dude was very welcoming when we came in for a dine-in dinner with the grandson. Our waitress was great, brought our food out as soon as it came out of the oven. Restroom was clean, as was the dining area. Prices were great for the current state of the economy. 27 bucks for a large specialty pie. Along with the garlic knots, we took a few slices home, so we definitely got our money's worth. Even the teen aged boy got full! We will most definitely be going back to Sal's!

Jay Warner

Love eating their the food is great and they are very friendly. It's a great Italian restaurant where you walk in and get greeted like you've been friends for years. That's what I call small home town charm and personality. I would recommend this place to anyone. Ps great prices for families and anyone traveling through the area.

Christopher Graham

Absolutely great pizza. Got 2 cheese slices and bottled soda for $6.99 special. Pizza was amazing great dough and crispy, sauce just right and fresh mozzarella cheese 7.8 rating... Owner was present and extremely friendly to be serving you. Worth the stop if in the area. Have nice menu for other stuff as well. Forgot to mention no flob so that's great dough

+1

Broc Burkhow

Very amazing pizza! There is a really cool story behind the business! Would definitely recommend getting eating there and it is a very good price. There pieces are very large and would lick’n the pizza to New York style.

Renee Burnham

Ordered 2 sheet pizzas, on a timed order the day before event...they were perfect, and ready on time. Family owned business, very nice people. This is the first time I have been a customer, but my family orders from here alot.

Joseph Worcester

Stopped in while passing through the area. Pizza was great. Nice cheese and sauce. Owner was very hospitable.

Ed T

Love this place! If I'm within 10 miles of DeRuyter I always drive to Sal's. Great (4.5-star) pizza. 5-star, friendly service. 6-star price for the 2-slice special ($5 for two slices and a large drink!).

Nikki

Best pizza around - My family and I love Sal’s pizza. We miss it a lot now that we have moved away from DeRuyter, But always a nice treat when we are able to visit family in town and get Sal’s for dinner. My husband and I love the Broccoli and Ham pizza! Be careful of the wings though as far as the spice level. There mild is known to be spicy and it’s just gets hotter as you move up to medium and hot.

Cricket “G”

Sal’s is one of those spots that’s been part of the local rhythm for years—pizza’s solid, and the garlic knots bring the kind of garlic that sticks with you (in the best way). Prices lean a little high, but you get your money’s worth. Pro tip: timing matters. Catch it earlier in the day and things tend to come out just right. Still one of the more reliable comfort stops around.

Matt Sober

When a customer points to the fresh slice, give them the fresh, not the old, was thin in the middle, flapping down, with too much cheese. Made puzza fir 25 years, sorry, easy to critique. Otherwise, not bad.