Marta's Market

Angela Ryan

I have driven by Marta’s Market and just the exterior looked so inviting! We finally tried it and it did NOT disappoint. From the moment I walked in the door, I felt a warm welcome. The staff/owners were friendly and knowledgeable. Their enthusiasm palpable. The interior decor is really interesting and beautiful. Our food was delicious. My husband had the Vivani; the chicken cutlet was perfection and the Italian roll baked fresh. I had the Careen which is a flat bread pizza. The flavor explosion was the chef’s kiss! Absolutely delightful experience! We will be back!

Julia L

First time stopping in today for brunch and we’re so happy we did. Great breakfast sandwiches, very cool staff and owners who came out to the table to ask us how we like everything. We had the Angel and Bernard, the bacon on the Bernard was insanely good and crispy. Highly recommend this place!

Madison Hoeflich

I have been to Marta’s Market a couple of times now. Each time is the best experience! I love the atmosphere and decor of the restaurant. Kara was our server and she is the most delightful and hardworking person. We love her!! I will definitely be going back and would recommend anyone to visit Marta’s if they’d like to have a delicious lunch or dinner (my favorite is the Vivani sandwich).

Zack Intrabartolo

My wife and I both had a breakfast sandwich and they were both great! The bacon I had on mine was cooked to perfection. Also the meatball bomber was excellent

Grabbed some takeout, soup and a sandwich! Soup was homemade moroccan chicken and it was phenomenal. Sandwich was the Chicken Parm, also 10/10. Perfect portions, great price for the quality, super efficient & friendly service!

A must stop for lunch or dinner! The best food I've had in the area. Good selection of food and drink. Nice and quiet atmosphere with very friendly staff. Chicken Parm sandwich was delicious and amazing pizzas.

Loved this place! Shared a meatball sub and Christi flatbread. Flatbread crust was incredible. They get it from Italy. Truly delicious!! Highly recommend. We will go back!,

Dining here was the most pleasurable dining experience I’ve had. The food was delicious with generous portions. The service was top notch. We will definitely be dining here again.

Great sandwiches, delicious pizza! A wonderful new place that I hope stays around for a long time - give it a try!

Stopped after a visit to Vidlers. Cozy little bistro with limited seating but at 2pm we had no problem getting a table for 3. Service was quick and friendly. We each had a sandwich (Vivian, Trinity and Chicken Parm). All were excellent. Would highly recommend checking them out. Well done!

We stopped in for lunch and everything was so delicious! I had the chicken parm sandwich and it was absolutely amazing, I loved the fresh Parm they sprinkled on top of it— super flavorful, perfectly cooked, and so satisfying. Our kids shared a pizza and loved it. It came out hot, fresh, and perfectly cheesy. The service was friendly and quick, and the whole experience was fantastic. We’ll definitely be coming back!

Came here for lunch with my husband and honestly was blown away by how delicious the food was! Not a lot of tables so we actually sat at the bar, but such a cute little place with board games. GET THE MEATBALL SUB! By far, the best meatball sub I have ever had in my entire life. Homemade meatballs, delicious marinara perfectly toasted. We will be going back to get it again and again.

Scott Hayes

Stopped after a visit to Vidlers. Cozy little bistro with limited seating but at 2pm we had no problem getting a table for 3. Service was quick and friendly. We each had a sandwich (Vivian, Trinity and Chicken Parm). All were excellent. Would highly recommend checking them out. Well done!

Kara Gurgol

Grabbed some takeout, soup and a sandwich! Soup was homemade moroccan chicken and it was phenomenal. Sandwich was the Chicken Parm, also 10/10. Perfect portions, great price for the quality, super efficient & friendly service!

Tom Marsteller

Great menu good atmosphere.

Tonya Schriever

Came here for lunch with my husband and honestly was blown away by how delicious the food was! Not a lot of tables so we actually sat at the bar, but such a cute little place with board games. GET THE MEATBALL SUB! By far, the best meatball sub I have ever had in my entire life. Homemade meatballs, delicious marinara perfectly toasted. We will be going back to get it again and again.

Alex

A must stop for lunch or dinner! The best food I've had in the area. Good selection of food and drink. Nice and quiet atmosphere with very friendly staff. Chicken Parm sandwich was delicious and amazing pizzas.

N F

We stopped in for lunch and everything was so delicious! I had the chicken parm sandwich and it was absolutely amazing, I loved the fresh Parm they sprinkled on top of it— super flavorful, perfectly cooked, and so satisfying. Our kids shared a pizza and loved it. It came out hot, fresh, and perfectly cheesy. The service was friendly and quick, and the whole experience was fantastic. We’ll definitely be coming back!

Joshua Delmonico

Loved this place! Shared a meatball sub and Christi flatbread. Flatbread crust was incredible. They get it from Italy. Truly delicious!! Highly recommend. We will go back!,

Sarah Maloney

Marta’s Market is one of those rare gems you instantly fall in love with. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with friendly faces and a welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel like family. The food? Always fresh, flavorful, and made with love. You can tell there’s real care behind every dish. The service is just as impressive—attentive, kind, and consistent from Kara annd Syd every time we visit. We’re lucky to call the owners and bartender friends, but even if we weren’t, this place would still be at the top of our list. Highly recommend stopping in—you’ll be glad you did!

Food is great here. We split two sandwiches... one hot one cold. Both were excellent. Don't go around lunch time if you are in a rush... you will wait a solid hour for your food. LOTS OF PEOPLE. We weren't in a hurry but we're hungry! Food was well worth the wait!!

When I see Italian sandwiches with authentic Italiano ingredients, that’s just where I need to be! The Main Street in East Aurora is a vibe. Part old world/all charm. The inside is perfectly decorated, inviting with its own unique design that is thoughtful with its touches. They have bar seating available with table options limited to one side of the restaurant. All the servers are very welcoming and the people in the restaurant also where so friendly. We started off with the Prosecco on tap because SI!! If you have the opportunity to have Italian sparkling wine on tap you take it! The food options are a selection of cold and hot option, pizzas, a pasta dish or antipasti which gives everyone a choice of different flavors and styles to suit your taste. I had the ‘Mike The Bike’ hot sandwich and the chicken cotolletta or cutlet which was delicious. The bread was an Italian style which is hard on the outside and fluffy in the middle. My only problem with the sandwich itself was the amount of sauce. There was a sauce situation lol. The Calabrian Chilli Aioli had unfortunately used too much of the oil, from Pepperoncino I presume(?). My suggestion is you need to either drain the oil more OR use the actual chilli pepper in the pepperoncino. I mean it’s meant to be hot. My friend had Vivani which looked perfecto. No notes. This is an amazing place, which is a refreshing take on Italian cuisine here in the US.

Super delicious sandwiches, great service. One of my new favorite places for when I'm in East Aurora.

Cece Louise

When I see Italian sandwiches with authentic Italiano ingredients, that’s just where I need to be! The Main Street in East Aurora is a vibe. Part old world/all charm. The inside is perfectly decorated, inviting with its own unique design that is thoughtful with its touches. They have bar seating available with table options limited to one side of the restaurant. All the servers are very welcoming and the people in the restaurant also where so friendly. We started off with the Prosecco on tap because SI!! If you have the opportunity to have Italian sparkling wine on tap you take it! The food options are a selection of cold and hot option, pizzas, a pasta dish or antipasti which gives everyone a choice of different flavors and styles to suit your taste. I had the ‘Mike The Bike’ hot sandwich and the chicken cotolletta or cutlet which was delicious. The bread was an Italian style which is hard on the outside and fluffy in the middle. My only problem with the sandwich itself was the amount of sauce. There was a sauce situation lol. The Calabrian Chilli Aioli had unfortunately used too much of the oil, from Pepperoncino I presume(?). My suggestion is you need to either drain the oil more OR use the actual chilli pepper in the pepperoncino. I mean it’s meant to be hot. My friend had Vivani which looked perfecto. No notes. This is an amazing place, which is a refreshing take on Italian cuisine here in the US.

Mik B

Food is great here. We split two sandwiches... one hot one cold. Both were excellent. Don't go around lunch time if you are in a rush... you will wait a solid hour for your food. LOTS OF PEOPLE. We weren't in a hurry but we're hungry! Food was well worth the wait!!

I’ve passed this restaurant on the street many times and because my favorite pizzeria in East Aurora was closed on Wednesdays, I decided to come here instead with my family. We got the Viviani, chicken Parm, and meatball sandwiches. As well as a Caesar salad and the Rita pinsa (which is just pizza. Don’t let the name freak you out.) we split everything and were satisfied by that amount of food. Across the board, the flavors of the food were just as I needed them to be aside from the salt level. I saw another reviewer say that the Caesar was too salty for their taste, which made me worry that things would be too salty here, on the contrary, I found that all of the sandwiches could’ve used a nice sprinkling of salt. Aside from that, everything was delicious. I did find it odd however that there is very minimal seating in this restaurant, almost to the point where it is difficult to have anything higher than a group of four, if the outside seating is closed, just something to be mindful of. Also something I didn’t really love was that we were given paper dishes to eat our food on. I’m not sure if this is a choice based on lack of dishwasher space or if it’s supposed to be more of like a carryout sandwich vibe, and this is supposed to deter people from eating in, however, it cheapens the experience and I wished that we were eating off of real plates so it would feel like a real family dinner out. It’s possible that I missed the intention of vibe of this place, but it didn’t really seem as though they were doing a lot of takeout business. All in all I would go back, but I won’t be running back.

Sabina Mogavero

I’ve passed this restaurant on the street many times and because my favorite pizzeria in East Aurora was closed on Wednesdays, I decided to come here instead with my family. We got the Viviani, chicken Parm, and meatball sandwiches. As well as a Caesar salad and the Rita pinsa (which is just pizza. Don’t let the name freak you out.) we split everything and were satisfied by that amount of food. Across the board, the flavors of the food were just as I needed them to be aside from the salt level. I saw another reviewer say that the Caesar was too salty for their taste, which made me worry that things would be too salty here, on the contrary, I found that all of the sandwiches could’ve used a nice sprinkling of salt. Aside from that, everything was delicious. I did find it odd however that there is very minimal seating in this restaurant, almost to the point where it is difficult to have anything higher than a group of four, if the outside seating is closed, just something to be mindful of. Also something I didn’t really love was that we were given paper dishes to eat our food on. I’m not sure if this is a choice based on lack of dishwasher space or if it’s supposed to be more of like a carryout sandwich vibe, and this is supposed to deter people from eating in, however, it cheapens the experience and I wished that we were eating off of real plates so it would feel like a real family dinner out. It’s possible that I missed the intention of vibe of this place, but it didn’t really seem as though they were doing a lot of takeout business. All in all I would go back, but I won’t be running back.

Great vibe. Plain food that's unimpressive. Prices are a bit high for glorified Panera foods. I had a pasta special, garlic mushroom and cheese? It was just cheese & mushrooms no garlic at all, no herbs or flavor. Mac & cheese. My wife had a sandwich which had aluminum foil stuck to it in a couple places. Just disappointing food. It needs work on the Food. Atmosphere was great. Unlikely to return. I don't know how anyone would give it 4-5 stars. Low standards?

Andrew

Great vibe. Plain food that's unimpressive. Prices are a bit high for glorified Panera foods. I had a pasta special, garlic mushroom and cheese? It was just cheese & mushrooms no garlic at all, no herbs or flavor. Mac & cheese. My wife had a sandwich which had aluminum foil stuck to it in a couple places. Just disappointing food. It needs work on the Food. Atmosphere was great. Unlikely to return. I don't know how anyone would give it 4-5 stars. Low standards?

Dennis Coughlan

food was not good we had ceaser salad it was so salty couldn't eat it. then we had pasta and meatballs 2 meatballs each one the size of a tennis ball and that's not exaggerating