Anew Sirus

Thankfully we found a pizza place around here thats worth going to.. And that is Joeys! After moving up here from long island, we have not found any pizza place even close to resembling what we are used to (good pizza) until we came here.. the setup is amazing. Theres a walk up icee window, a door to go and order food to go, and then the door to the sit-down restaurant section.. Our server was Calla, and she is Incredible. She was very attentive and took care of our every need. I highly recommend u stop in here whenever in the area

Amber Duke

Pizza, and steak Milanese were delish! The steak was huge and smothered with Milanese! Also tried the custard!

Tim Hall

I am in Endicott for 3 months working at a local hospital. I am ashamed that it took 2 of those months before I found Joey’s. I tried their Large Quattro Carne pizza and it was delicious! I also tried the Joey’s sampler platter. With the sampler, the fried cheese ravioli was amazing. I admit I wasn’t a fan of the ponzarotti but that was a person preference. Everything else was great! Friendly service as I picked up. I look forwarded to trying their subs!

Leslie Joscelyn

First time here. Our waitress, Macie, was very quick and friendly. Food came out quickly and was filling and delicious. Would definitely eat here again.

Alex Neil

While I can't comment on the full menu or indoor atmosphere, the gelati here is a standout. With a diverse selection of Italian ice flavors layered with indulgent frozen custard, it's a true summer delight. The custard comes in vanilla, chocolate, or a playful twist option, each enhancing the flavor experience. Outdoor seating lets you savor your treat before it melts, a quintessential summer experience. Do note, this spot accepts only cash at the window. For a refreshing and tasty dessert, this place is a top choice.

Dana Sullivan

Unquestionably the best pizza in the Binghamton area. I usually go for the Pizza Bianco without the meat, and it's just a white pizza, but something about the perfectly cooked crust and the whipped, herby ricotta is very special. The red pizzas I've tried have also been really good, my heart just belongs to the Bianco. In my experience the quality has been very consistent over the years. Besides pizza, they also make excellent sandwiches, which I'll get if I'm going for lunch and don't feel like dealing with a whole pizza. Their potato salad side has a unique taste from a lot of others I've tried - I think it's just more mustard and maybe a bit of sugar in the dressing but it really makes a difference. Even without considering the quality, the food is very reasonably priced for the amount you get. If I'm really hungry and only getting pizza, I can eat 4/6 slices of a medium, but a medium could definitely feed 2 if you pair it with a salad or something, or if you're not as hungry. The portions are generous for other entrees. The Italian ice is good. They usually have a good assortment of flavours, some fixed and some seem to rotate. I really like the Cannoli flavour- it has the classic rich cannoli taste but with the lightness of Italian ice. The ice window is only open during the summer, but I just discovered they serve other Italian desserts in the restaurant! I had their tiramisu - I liked how distinct the layers were and the thick layer of cream on top. Even through the lady fingers and cream, it tasted like they used a high quality espresso to soak it. I will not be skipping dessert here again. I haven't seen the new upstairs that just opened, but I love the feeling of the downstairs room. It's cozy, you can see into the kitchen, and it really feels like you're at home being served by family. And it helps that the people are very nice.

Chris Kaczor

It's amazing how I've passed this place 10,000 times and have never tried it until now. I've lived 5 blocks away on the same street as Joey's for almost 4 years now and I've never actually had a sit down meal here. But I will certainly be coming back more often. One time a while back I had their pizza and also a sandwich here and they were very good. But I kinda overlooked the fact that they actually had full dinners here. Well the other day I saw a picture of a meal on Instagram that looked so delicious that I had to ask the person where they were. When they responded with Joey's I was shocked. So fast forward a few days and my lady and I head here for dinner. And boy they did not disappoint. I had fettuccine alfredo with grilled chicken and my fiance had penne vodka with shrimp. Everything was awesome. If you're looking for a reasonably priced, really good Italian meal I'd highly recommend Joey's!

Heather L.E.

The pizza was excellent, the service was great, the portions were substantial, & the atmosphere was casually comfortable. We had a great time & sat for a long time after we finished eating without any pressure to hurry along by the staff. We enjoyed our visit very much.

Zachary Chandler

Order a Calabrese sandwich and get a Barese sandwich. Simple mistake, ok. Call back and tell the guy who took order. I said can I come back and get what I ordered. Dude says " umm i mean, I guess". Almost like it was my fault. So i hung up, not an appropriate answer for customer service, at all. Call back next day, to order more food despite this, and was denied making the sandwich right with me . I order the same thing everytime, i order everytime they have the soups i like. I get a Calabrese sandwich everytime they have garlic potatoe soup or tomato basil like clockwork. Not the first issue I've had here, but it's certainly the last.

Chase Martino

Honestly love the food here but after today will never try eating there again, came in with my larger size family to find out upstairs wasn’t open instead of getting a time frame of when we could eat where I could of took my kids to play across the street till we got turned away all together because they had a reservation, didn’t know that meant we couldn’t have a table after other tables were empty drove 25 minutes to still be hungry with kids crying called and said something about how inconvenient that really was person could of cared less