Rebecca Lynn Hansen Lmt

The food is always stellar! They ARE renovating and making improvements, adding room.

Chris

Hardworking folks who make a damn good pizza, always on time 🍕 no complaints.

Connor Jarvis

Found this place with the ole lady on our way back home from turning stone! It was 10 min out of the way but i would say it was worth the detour. The wait time for our pizza was a tad longer than we liked... but the pizza was perfect. The crust was golden brown underneath with a perfectly covered top (half cheese half pepperoni), the sauce spread was spot on! Not to much too little. Over all if you need good pizza for any occasion order from here but of youre in a rush order early because you can't rush that perfection

David Gray

Me and my family were passing through on our way to Massachusetts and the pizza and mozzarella knots were AWESOME!! Definitely recommend stopping here as a local or passing through. Customer service was great too, very friendly and helpful. Highly recommend and I would be happy to stop by on our way back to Michigan in a week and a half!!!

Mike Goliber

On a bike ride along the Erie Canal Trail? Grab a pie here, you won't be disappointed!

Coffee Connoisseur

I come here 2-3 times a week after work the food is good the service is good but the thing that always stands out is the CLEANLINESS. They keep their kitchen and front of house so clean I am always very impressed. It’s not easy keeping a restaurant that clean!

Steve Naas

rode the Erie Trail last week. After a hard morning on Saturday trying to stay ahead of the rain, we decided to stop in at Papa Joe's in Fort Plain. Are we glad we did! The largest pizza slice we've ever seen. Good New York style. But the best was the staff. They appreciated us coming in and let us hang out for 2.5 hours while the heavy rain came down. They did a very busy carryout for that little small village. Great place to stop if you are in the neighborhood or on the Erie Trail.

Rye LeBrun

As an out of state visitor I kept being told I needed to try true NY pizza. This place was super quaint and the workers seemed to enjoy working with each other. The food was quite good, we had pizza and wings. The mid size pizza was a great sharing size for four people, the original buffalo wings were also very good as well. The chicken was cooked perfectly and there was a perfect amount of sauce on each wing.

Darla Parsons

We've had take out three times from Papa Joe's. The food was excellent everytime. We have gotten their EBA pizza 3 times, chicken wings twice, subs, chicken tenders and onion rings. The service is top notch. We will definitely be ordering again.

Michael Ryan

Came here from 25 minutes away on a Sunday because literally EVERY other place in the region was closed. Wow are we glad we did! The pizza was absolutely unreal. I've eaten pizza from pretty much every place from one end of the valley to the other and honestly, this is one of the best, if not THE best. Truly delicious.